Thursday, June 27, 2013

Affirmative Action and the Court: What Happened to Article Three and the Eleventh Amendment? (Guest Post by Eric J. Segall)

By Eric J. Segall

This week the Supreme Court has given us a lot to talk about: affirmative action, gay rights, voting rights, and several five-to-four pro-big corporation statutory interpretation decisions decided along partisan lines. Lost in this wild scramble, however, and yet quite troubling, is what happened to Article III and those pesky little “case” or “controversy” requirements the Justices, especially Justices Scalia and Thomas, say they love so much. You remember those pre-requisites to federal jurisdiction, the ones that have kept numerous public interest and Establishment Clause challenges out of court for so long in cases like Allen v. Wright, Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, Hein v. Freedom from Religious Foundation and now Hollingsworth v. Perry as well. Moreover, related to the concerns for appropriate jurisdiction is the Court’s Eleventh Amendment doctrine which has been used by the Justices to block virtually all suits for damages against states and their officers. The Eleventh Amendment was also ignored by the Court this week. Although history may not record it, the Court’s decision in Fisher v. Texas (along with the no-standing decision in Perry) is yet another conspicuous reminder of what everyone who teaches a course on or even follows federal jurisdiction already knows: Supreme Court Justices, especially the conservatives but not only the conservatives, manipulate Article III and Eleventh Amendment case law to simply hear cases they want to hear and dismiss cases they want to avoid.

As I detailed here, the Fisher case needed to be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction because the plaintiffs’ constitutional claims were moot, she had no standing, and the Eleventh Amendment blocked her claims for damages.  (Theoretically the plaintiffs have statutory claims under Title VI which may be viable under the Eleventh Amendment because that federal law was enacted under Congress’ Section 5 authority.  But, even if that is true, the Court should have dismissed all of the plaintiff’s constitutional claims. Moreover, as discussed below, even possible Title VI claims would likely be barred by standing requirements.) If you don’t believe me, Adam Chandler wrote a longer, more scholarly-oriented, article concluding that the case’s jurisdictional defects made the case “botched beyond repair.”

To sum up the problems, Abigail Fisher, who has graduated from LSU, conceded that she would never again apply to the University of Texas, thus mooting her claims for injunctive relief. In fact, she didn’t even appeal the Fifth Circuit’s holding that all her non-damages claims were moot. Significantly, and unlike the plaintiffs in Grutter and Gratz, she didn’t bring a class action on behalf of other non-minority students.

The only damages claims Fisher has asserted are for her application fee and housing deposit to be returned to her. But she is suing officials of the State of Texas and therefore her constitutional claims for retroactive monetary relief are barred by the Eleventh Amendment under unambiguous Supreme Court precedents such as Edelman v. Jordan. Texas could waive that immunity but usually the Court requires an unambiguous, explicit waiver, which hasn’t happened here. Moreover, the fees she wants back were totally non-refundable whether she was admitted to the school or not, and thus her alleged injury wasn’t caused by the possible illegality of the schools’ affirmative action program flunking the second prong of Justice Scalia’s beloved three-part standing test.

The most amazing aspect of the Fisher case, therefore, is not that it took so long to decide, or that only one moderate Justice dissented, or that Justice Kennedy was able to garner the votes of the conservatives (other than Thomas), but that despite the substantiality of the numerous jurisdictional defects, some of which, like causation, can’t be waived by the defendant, the Court didn’t spend one syllable on whether it had the power to hear the case. Not one! And this happened during the same week that Justice Scalia ranted in Windsor (the DOMA case), that:
declaring the compatibility of state or federal laws with the Constitution is not only not the ‘primary role’ of this Court, it is not a separate, free-standing role at all. We perform that role incidentally—by accident, as it were—when that is necessary to resolve the dispute before us. Then, and only then, does it become “‘the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is.’
Well, it was completely unnecessary for the Court to decide the Fisher case because the only plaintiff in the case had nothing to gain. The moral of the story, therefore, is not a newsflash but it should serve as a somber reminder of an important fact. The Justices of the Supreme Court have no stake in the principled application of jurisdictional pre-requisites but simply use them when they are convenient. The next time the Court dismisses an important public interest or Establishment Clause lawsuit based on standing, mootness, or even the Eleventh Amendment, we will be reminded of this sad state of affairs one more time.

21 comments:

Unknown said...

Amen.

Joe said...

Ha. I'm pretty liberal as to standing, and even I think Fisher looks like a dog of a case.

james carter said...

That"s a great attitude, I hope the incoming comments and suggestions are equally positive. Sub Poker : Panthar Poker : King Poker Choice : Groom Poker : Pro Poker Mania : Luxury Slot : Summer Slot : Temple Slot : Golden Night Casino : Lucky One Casino : Stud Casino Room : Typical Gambling

jorden jems said...

Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I genuinely enjoyed reading it,you are a great author. 7game slot : Lenny casino game : palace casino wheel : Maxino casino games : 77vegas casino : 88poker games : sky pokernet : silver poker news : online poker kings : free win pokies : casino memory : ezine poker

奇堡比 said...

新女性徵信
外遇調查站
鴻海徵信
亞洲徵信
非凡徵信社
鳳凰徵信社
中華新女性徵信社
全國新女性徵信社
全省女人徵信有限公司
私家偵探超優網
女人感情會館-婚姻感情挽回徵信
女子偵探徵信網
女子國際徵信
外遇抓姦偵探社
女子徵信社
女人國際徵信
女子徵信社
台中縣徵信商業同業公會
成功科技器材
女人國際徵信社
女人國際徵信
三立徵信社-外遇
女人國際徵信
女人國際徵信
大同女人徵信聯盟
晚晴徵信

marly aaran said...

I have not much time to visit many websites. But today I found this site accidently. I explored much information which is useful to my life. Thanks!
http://www.healthykskids.org |

Richard Lake said...

I've seen your awareness about this theme whenever you post it and it really gives an informational message to us readers. I am hoping that you'll continue writing this kind of blog. Thanks for sharing this information.
soupehe.com |

abbi barclay said...

I just got to this amazing site not long ago. I was actually captured with the piece of resources you have got here. Big thumbs up for making such wonderful blog page!
www.neuro-tox.org |

Affiliate Marketing said...

Inspection causes 13 to miss Cup qualifying : Women MMA makes leap with top two fights on UFC 184 : Live: Aussies fight back after horror show : UFC 184 matchups : Aaron Hernandez sent urgent text to friend on night of murder : Browns, vet McCown agree to 3-year deal : Crash and burn: Aussies; worst ever ODI collapse : Stadium near LAX a terror risk, report says : Kiwi spin wizard destroys Oz : UK Free Online Casnio Slot

Peter Roil said...

sbo-casino : cyprusopenpoker : usonlinepokersites : panoramapoker : 4-casinos : fulltiltpokerreferralcode

obat herbal said...

obat kemaluan keluar nanah cara menangani wasir atau ambeien cara menghilangkan wasir obat wasir herbal de nature indonesia

wasirdenature said...

pengobatan hebal wasir pengobatan herbal obat penyakit kanker penyakit kanker payudara stadium 3 cara mengobati kanker cara mengobati kanker payudara kanker payudara obat kanker payudara herbal

herbal medicine said...

pengobatan hebal wasir pengobatan herbal obat penyakit kanker penyakit kanker payudara stadium 3 cara mengobati kanker cara mengobati kanker payudara kanker payudara obat kanker payudara herbal

Mark Taylor said...

I enjoyed so much to read your blog. Generally writing skills is attained via practice but you are awesome writer. I am going to share it with my other friends on social networking sites. Keep continue your outstanding job.

Visit: Online GED Course

obat herbal said...

pengobatan hebal wasir pengobatan herbal obat penyakit kanker penyakit kanker payudara stadium 3 cara mengobati kanker cara mengobati kanker payudara kanker payudara obat kanker payudara herbal

Fabricio Teixeira said...

Noticias do Flamengo

Fabricio Teixeira said...

Assistir Futebol ao vivo

Futebol ao vivo

UFC ao vivo

Bambang Wisanggeni said...



OBAT AMBEIEN HERBAL DI APOTIK
OBAT HERBAL UNTUK GEJALA GEJALA SAKIT AMBEIEN
OBAT WASIR HERBAL YANG PALING MANJUR
OBAT AMBEIEN MANJUR OBAT AMBEIEN BIASA
OBAT WASIR HERBAL DI APOTIK
OBAT AMBEIEN HERBAL DI APOTIK
OBAT KENCING KELUAR NANAH
KENAPA KECING BERDARAH

Herbal de nature said...

Obat wasir herbal yang manjur dan aman
PENGOBATAN PENYAKIT SIFILIS ALAMI
CARA MENGOBATI KUTIL KELAMIN TANPA KE DOKTER
Pengobatan Alami Kanker Payudara
Obat Alternatif Kanker Serviks
OBAT HERBAL TRADISIONAL UNTUK AMBEYEN DALAM
Penyakit Raja Singa Dan Obatnya | Obat Herbal Penyakit Raja Singa
BAGAIMANA MENGOBATI KUTIL KELAMIN CARA HERBAL
TERAPI HERBAL UNTUK KUTIL DI KEMALUAN
pengobatan kencing nanah
OBAT TRADISIONAL GONORE | KENCING NANAH
Obat gonore ampuh untuk pria
obat gonore untuk wanita
Pengobatan penyakit sifilis
OBAT HERBAL ALAMI UNTUK PENYAKIT KANKER PAYUDARA
CARA SEDERHANA MENGOBATI KUTIL KELAMIN
kutil kelamin
Pengobatan penyakit sifilis
CARA MENGOBATI AMBEYEN YANG TEPAT
JUAL OBAT WASIR

Herbal de nature said...

Obat wasir herbal yang manjur dan aman
PENGOBATAN PENYAKIT SIFILIS ALAMI
CARA MENGOBATI KUTIL KELAMIN TANPA KE DOKTER
Pengobatan Alami Kanker Payudara
Obat Alternatif Kanker Serviks
OBAT HERBAL TRADISIONAL UNTUK AMBEYEN DALAM
Penyakit Raja Singa Dan Obatnya | Obat Herbal Penyakit Raja Singa
BAGAIMANA MENGOBATI KUTIL KELAMIN CARA HERBAL
TERAPI HERBAL UNTUK KUTIL DI KEMALUAN
pengobatan kencing nanah
OBAT TRADISIONAL GONORE | KENCING NANAH
Obat gonore ampuh untuk pria
obat gonore untuk wanita
Pengobatan penyakit sifilis
OBAT HERBAL ALAMI UNTUK PENYAKIT KANKER PAYUDARA
CARA SEDERHANA MENGOBATI KUTIL KELAMIN
kutil kelamin
Pengobatan penyakit sifilis
CARA MENGOBATI AMBEYEN YANG TEPAT
JUAL OBAT WASIR

obat herbal said...

Obat kencing Nanah De Nature Obat Herbal obat Kutil Kelaminkutil kelamin pada ibu hamil dan cara mengobati kutil di kemaluan kutil di sekitar kelamin wanita dan kutil di sekitar kemaluan wanita dan cara mengobati kutil di sekitar kemaluan dab tumbuh kutil di sekitar kemaluan dan bahaya dan resiko penyakit kutil kelamin dan kutil di sekitar kelamin pria dan kutil di sekitar kemaluan merupakan solusi pengobatan herbal dari denature indonesia