Justice Barrett's "Evil Day" and Other Infuriating Lowlights From the Voting Rights Act Oral Argument
The instant consensus--with which I agree--is that last Wednesday's oral argument in Louisiana v. Callais portends the final step in the Roberts Court's destruction of the Voting Rights Act (VRA). I won't dissect it all. Instead, I'll discuss the pivotal claims made by Justice Barrett and a couple of other lowlights. But first, a brief synopsis. Section 2 of the VRA forbids the use of voting standards or practices that have the effect of diluting the voting strength of a racial group, regardless of whether or not the standards or practices were adopted for that purpose. That is plain from the provision's text and the legislative history that led Congress to amend Section 2 in 1982. It is also confirmed by cases like Thornburg v. Gingles nearly forty years ago. At issue in Callais is whether a state--acting on its own or as ordered by a court--is permitted to remedy a Section 2 violation by deliberately taking account of race to draw majority-minority electoral ...