Posts

Showing posts matching the search for sherry colb

Sherry Colb

Image
by Michael C. Dorf I'm writing with unspeakably sad news. Sherry Colb--my co-blogger, co-author, colleague, best friend, and wife for over 31 years--died this morning.  A funeral service will be held this Sunday August 28 at noon at  Plaza Jewish Community Chapel  on Amsterdam Avenue at 91st Street in Manhattan (five blocks from where Sherry grew up), followed by burial at  Cedar Park Chapel and Cemetery   in Paramus, NJ. There will be an additional memorial service at Cornell in Ithaca some time in the coming months. I expect that this news comes as a great shock to most readers, given Sherry's relative youth, and how, until very recently, she was extremely prolific--not just her  Verdict  columns and blog posts but also four law review articles in the last year.  Accordingly, I will add a bit of background.

Remembering and Celebrating Sherry Colb

by Neil H. Buchanan   A week ago today, Professor Michael Dorf posted on this blog the sad news of Professor Sherry Colb's passing earlier that morning. As he noted, Professor Colb was one of the bloggers on Dorf on Law , and she was also his "co-author, colleague, best friend, and wife for over 31 years."  Earlier this week, I posted a few brief comments but conceded that I was not yet prepared to wrestle with my emotions in a way that would allow me to write a proper eulogy.  I added that "I will soon publish my own thoughts about the death of my wonderful friend and colleague."   I am still not truly ready, but I doubt that I ever will be.  Here, I will do what I can.  As an aside, I generally maintain a certain formality in my writing on Dorf on Law .  Under the circumstances, however, I will set that practice to one side as I discuss personal matters.   Because Mike's published eulogy was so beautiful, I asked him whether it would even be ...

Sherry Colb's Argumentative Style

Today is the Symposium in Honor of Professor Sherry Colb , hosted by Rutgers School of Law in Newark and co-sponsored by the Cornell Law Review. Last week I described and linked the paper I'll present on the panel exploring crosscurrents in Sherry's writing spanning various areas of interest. Since then, one of our speakers had to back out, so I'll also be replacing him on the animal rights panel. Because my crosscurrents paper is already likely to use more pages in the law review than a typical symposium-length article, I didn't think it appropriate to ask the law review to publish my write-up of my remarks on animal rights as well. Accordingly, I'll use this essay to preview my remarks, which I'm titling Sherry Colb's Argumentative Style . I discuss the patient and gentle tone of Sherry's influential 2013 book, Mind If I Order the Cheeseburger? And Other Questions People Ask Vegans   (hereafter Cheeseburger ). As I explain, the style of Cheeseburger ...

Sherry Colb's Penultimate Article: Reconceptualizing Double Effect

  by Michael C. Dorf Last week the Connecticut Law Review published an article on the doctrine of double effect (DDE) that Sherry Colb wrote before she passed away last August. Titled A New and Improved Doctrine of Double Effect: Not Just for Trolleys , the article makes important contributions to both moral philosophy and law. By reconceptualizing DDE as properly focused on objectively permissible possible intentions rather than actual subjective intentions, the article renders DDE defensible as against common critiques (especially that of T.M. Scanlon). Sherry shows that DDE as she reconceptualizes it plays a much larger role in extant law than commonly appreciated. Here's the abstract: In its standard formulation, the doctrine of double effect (DDE) permits an action that causes foreseeable and harmful, even dire, collateral consequences, so long as the actor merely foresees but does not intend them and the harms are proportional to the benefit. Yet DDE’s critics question the mo...

When Sex Counts

Image
That's the title of a brand new book by Dorf on Law blogger and Rutgers Law Professor Sherry Colb. Actually, as you can see from the cover (left), the full title is When Sex Counts: Making Babies and Making Law . You can buy it from Amazon , Barnes & Noble or directly from the publisher . Beginning with a riff on the Supreme Court's famously obtuse distinction between pregnant and non-pregnant persons in Geduldig v. Aiello , the book addresses a host of sex equality issues by observing the centrality of reproduction and pregnancy (or the capacity for pregnancy) to nearly all of them. I think this is a rare and successful effort to write across the spectrum of sex equality issues. But don't take my word for it. Here are the blurbs: "With deft writing, clear thinking, and deep knowledge, Sherry Colb illuminates the dark intersection of law and sex. She displays both journalistic verve and scholarly rigor. The result is a wonderful book that makes advanced think...

One of My Best Moments with Sherry Colb

by Neil H. Buchanan Here at Dorf on Law , we are still in shock as we try to cope with the passing of Sherry Colb.  Her husband Michael Dorf posted a beautiful eulogy this past Thursday, and I will soon publish my own thoughts about the death of my wonderful friend and colleague.  Today, however, I am not yet ready to wrestle with those thoughts and emotions, and I know that I would not be able to turn them into cogent (or even minimally coherent) prose.  I will do so soon, I promise, but not yet. Today, I want to share a column that I wrote in 2008, which was my announcement that I had become a vegan.  I include a link to it every year in my "veganniversary" posts, but I am republishing it today because, as the title of today's column indicates, publishing that column led to one my best moments with Sherry.   The moment was great not only because she had been hoping to convince me to become a vegan -- although that was obviously important and essential. ...

Intentionally targeting civilians and proportionality (in general and in Israel and Gaza)

The standard version of the doctrine of double effect (DDE) posits that it is sometimes permissible to intentionally commit an act that has the foreseeable consequence of causing serious harm (including the death of innocent people), so long as that harm is an incidental effect rather than the goal of the act and is proportionate to the act's benefit. Standard DDE has been offered as a basis for permitting a lethal dose of palliative medication where the doctor intends to alleviate a terminal patient's pain, with death as a foreseen side effect. More directly relevant to current events, DDE operates in the international humanitarian law of war, which forbids targeting civilians but permits targeting combatants even though civilian casualties are a foreseeable collateral consequence, so long as the attacker attempts to minimize civilian casualties and the foreseeable civilian casualties are proportionate to the military advantage to be gained by attacking the combatants. In  A N...

Symposium on the Scholarship of Sherry Colb: September 29 at Rutgers-Newark and co-sponsored by the Cornell Law Review

  by Michael C. Dorf On Friday September 29, 2023, the Rutgers Law School and the Cornell Law Review will co-host a one-day symposium commemorating and exploring the scholarship of Sherry Colb. The symposium will take place at the Rutgers-Newark Law School. The day's events will feature papers and discussion by three panels of distinguished faculty from Rutgers, Cornell, and around the country, focusing on and inspired by Sherry's work in: criminal procedure; feminist jurisprudence; and animal rights. The papers will ultimately be published in the Cornell Law Review. Sherry was a beloved member of the Rutgers law faculty from 1993 to 2008 (for the first two years at Camden and then at Newark) and the Cornell law faculty from 2008 until her death in 2022 (interrupted by stints as a visiting professor at the University of Pennsylvania and Columbia law schools).  In the coming weeks and months, the other organizers of the symposium and I will launch a website and provide addition...

The Co-Authored Article I'll Present at the Symposium in Honor of Sherry Colb

As I have previously noted, next Friday, September 29, Rutgers School of Law in Newark will host a symposium co-sponsored by the Cornell Law Review and honoring the life and work of Sherry Colb. On behalf of myself and the other members of the organizing committee, I'm happy to say that we have a good-sized audience registered, but I have also heard from various of Sherry's former students, colleagues, and admirers who have said that they plan to attend but haven't yet registered. By the end of the week, we need to give final numbers to the caterer (for the free food throughout the day -- vegan, of course), so I would much appreciate if you plan to attend but have not yet register, please do so here . It's free. If you want CLE credit, you can get that (for a modest administration fee with a discount for public interest lawyers) by  registering for CLE credit here . All of that info is easily accessible via the tabs on the symposium webpage . We also have a terrific sch...

Suffering in Animal Agriculture is Inevitable

[Note from Mike Dorf: The following post by Sherry Colb went up virtually simultaneously with Neil Buchanan's post yesterday morning due to a scheduling mix-up on my part. In case it was missed, I'm moving it up the page for a bit. Please note also that this means that the reference in Paul Scott's post to Sherry's post "below" now refers to this post, which is above. So many bloggers; so little room . . . .] In recent posts, there has been much discussion about whether it might be morally acceptable to consume animal products if their production involved death but not suffering. The realities of agriculture, of course, have nothing to do with painless or cruelty-free death, whether one is consuming "cage free" or "organic" animal products or factory-farmed versions of such products. (For a useful antidote to "cage-free" and other such claims about humanely raised animals, read this ). But some argue that due to (hypothesiz...

Do Public Intellectuals Avoid Advocating Fringe But Worthwhile Ideas for Fear of Discrediting Themselves in the Eyes of the Public?

The most recent episode of the podcast Our Henhouse ( available here and wherever else you get your podcasts) features an interview with filmmaker Mark DeVries. Those of my readers who come here for the occasional vegan/animal-rights content will be familiar with DeVries from his film Speciesism: The Movie . That film includes interviews with important figures in the animal rights movement, including Peter Singer and the late great Sherry Colb. DeVries is now promoting his new film, Humans and Other Animals , which is currently screening and will be available for streaming in the near future. I look forward to seeing the film and very much hope that it is widely influential. In today's essay, I want to focus on something DeVries said early in the interview. Discussing the positive influence on his thinking of Steven Pinker, he and host Mariann Sullivan wondered why public intellectuals whose logic seems to lead to veganism do not change their behavior. Part of the answer is that t...

Final Classic of the Year: The Morality of Abortion

  by Michael C. Dorf [The following essay first appeared on the blog on July 3, 2017 under the title  Can Non-Sentient Entities Have Interests? (and Other Questions Raised by a Recent Review of Our Book) . I thought it an appropriate piece to re-post as the last classic of the year in light of the urgency questions about abortion have taken on post- Dobbs. I also thought it appropriate, as it reflects not only my views but also Sherry Colb's. The essay takes the form of a response to a book review, but it's more important as an exegesis of a view about when abortion is and isn't immoral, as well as about the proper relation between that kind of question and the law.] The latest issue of  Between the Species , an online philosophy journal, contains  a review  by Philosophy Professor Mylan Engel, Jr., of my book with Professor Sherry Colb,  Beating Hearts: Abortion and Animal Rights . (Engel's paper is styled an "article" because it is substantially long...

Of Love and Loss

By Eric Segall Followers of this blog know that Mike, Neil and I have each suffered great losses over the last few weeks. Mike lost his wife Sherry Colb, Neil lost his sister, and my best friend of 45 years and college roommate lost his wife Bonni the day after Sherry passed. In fact, I was on my way to Sherry's funeral when Rob called me to tell me Bonni had died. I am so grateful to Mike, whose name is on the blog, to let me write my weekly posts for the last decade mostly about how the Court isn't a court, how originalism is mostly about faith not reason, numerous other legal issues, and, from time to time, about personal matters, sometimes very serious, like when my Mother died, and sometimes trivial, like my love for the NBA. Writing a weekly post, while obviously often self-indulgent, has been a great release for me over the years and I greatly appreciate Mike and Neil, and the regular readers of this blog, for putting up with all this.  So with all that as a disclaimer, ...

The Impossible Burger: A "Pythagorean" Dialogue on Vegan Marketing

Image
by Sherry Colb & Michael Dorf Preface : On a recent trip to NYC, we had occasion to try the "Impossible Burger," a vegan burger made by Impossible Foods . The Impossible Burger is not yet widely available. We tried it at Momofuko Nishi in NYC. It is far from a vegan restaurant. Our experience prompts this dialogue, fashioned "Pythagorean" rather than Socratic in recognition of Pythagoras's vegetarianism . The views expressed by the characters "Sherry" and "Michael" are not necessarily our respective views. Sherry : This is a delicious burger. I'm not sure it's qualitatively superior to all other vegan burgers, but it sure is tasty. I could see ordering a second one. Michael : I agree about the taste, although frankly, it has been so long since I last ate meat that I can't really judge one of the apparent main selling points--the claim that it tastes just like an animal-based burger. Sherry : But in a way that do...

Losing Scooter

by Sherry F. Colb [Note from Michael Dorf: A reader suggested that we run a series of Sherry's "greatest hits," which I think is an excellent idea. Over the next several weeks, I'll periodically post Colb classics interspersed with new essays by my co-bloggers. I begin with an essay Sherry posted last December on Medium but not on Dorf on Law . Re-reading it now, it is evident that in talking about our dog Scooter, Sherry was in some way talking about her own illness, but I hesitate to make too much of the point. Sherry never liked when people used the stories of non-human animals simply as a vehicle for talking about humans. In any event, I'll let Sherry's own prose do the work, as it always did.]  --------- Losing Scooter When I first met Scooter, he was a small, soft pillow of black, beige, and brown. I picked him up and he licked my nose and eyes. He smelled like corn chips. His mother Hiccup stood outside in the yard, looking in through the sliding doors...

What I Plan to Tell the US Civil Rights Commission About Antisemitism on Campus and the Government Response Thus Far

Tomorrow I will testify at the U.S. Civil Rights Commission's briefing on  Antisemitism on America's College and University Campuses: Current Conditions and the Federal Response . I am one of six panelists during the first session, which runs from 10:15 am - 11:25 am. We have been instructed to speak for no more than 7 minutes in our opening statements, followed by questions from the commissioners. All panels will be live-streamed via the Commission's YouTube channel . Panelists were asked to submit written testimony, which I have done and which I reproduce (minus the footnotes) below. Readers who are interested in a version with footnotes can find my full written statement, as well those of the other panelists, by clicking on "panelist materials" . Having done so myself, I was struck by the general agreement among the four law professors on the panel (Ben Eidelson of Harvard, Genevieve Lakier of the University of Chicago, Eugene Volokh of the Hoover Institution, ...