Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Stable Democracy

By Mike Dorf

My new Verdict column uses the developing story in Egypt as an opportunity to make a few points about the potentially different roles that constitutional courts play in new democracies versus established democracies.  It concludes with a deliberately provocative comparison between last week's decisions by the Supreme Constitutional Court of Egypt and our own Supreme Court's decisions in Bush v. Gore and Citizens United v. FEC.  I do not say--because I do not believe--that the SCOTUS is as much a holdover of the Presidential administrations that appointed the respective justices as the the Supreme Constitutional Court of Egypt is a holdover of the Mubarak regime.  Nonetheless, there are at least some similarities.

Still, the column distinguishes between mature democracies and emerging democracies.  Although I think this is a reasonably clear distinction in many cases, I should clarify that it is a difference of degree rather than kind.  Moreover, by "mature" democracies, I do not necessarily mean "old" democracies.  The Roman Republic existed in one form or another for centuries but by the middle of the first century BCE, it was no longer stable.  A "mature" democracy as I use the term, is a democracy that is likely to be stable over the long run going forward.

But how can one tell whether a country will remain a stable democracy going forward?  I think the short answer is that one cannot.  The best one can do is play the odds.  Good public institutions--including civil society institutions--are probably a necessary condition but not a sufficient one.  Shocks--such as wars, severe economic downturns, or natural disasters--can so undermine the basis for social and political cooperation as to empower undemocratic forces.  Is it unthinkable that Greece, say, could slip into authoritarianism in the event that continued austerity or an exit from the Eurozone leads to political unrest and violence in the streets?

The United States avoided this fate during the Great Depression but much of Europe did not.  Most academic discussion of that juxtaposition focuses on what led Weimar Germany to fail.  The usual answer is some combination of the wrong political structures and a weakness in German culture.  Let's assume that's right.  The resulting question is how one builds up the right political structures and culture.  For Francis Fukuyama circa 1992 the answer is that it just more or less happens, more or less everywhere, because of the superiority of liberal democracy to the alternatives.  I think I agree with Fukuyama over the scale of centuries.  In two hundred years, if advanced human civilizations still exist, it would be surprising if liberal democracy hadn't taken hold pretty much everywhere.

But we know what Keynes said about the long run.  How, in the course of less than a human lifetime, does one move from political institutions and a political culture in which the military/security forces dominate politics to institutions and culture in which they do not?  My column raises this question with respect to Egypt and Pakistan but it could also be raised about China and (to a lesser extent) Russia.  To my mind, the best place to look for answers is not in long-established democracies that made the transition in the 18th or 19th century but in Latin America.  The transition of most of Latin America from autocracy to democracy over the last generation is not irreversible, of course, but it's remarkable nonetheless.  So, my advice to small-d democrats in the democratizing world: Learn to speak Spanish!


Shak Olreal said...

The Combined Declares prevented this destiny during the Excellent Depressive disorder but much of European countries did not. Most educational conversation of that juxtaposition concentrates on what led Weimar Malaysia to fall short. The regular response is some mixture of the incorrect governmental components and a weak point in In german lifestyle. Let's believe that's right. The producing concern is how one creates up the right governmental components and lifestyle. For Francis Fukuyama circa 1992 the response is that it just more or less happens, more or less everywhere, because of the brilliance of generous democracy to the solutions. I think I acknowledge with Fukuyama over the range of hundreds of decades. In two century, if innovative individual cultures still are available, it would be amazing if generous democracy hadn't taken keep fairly much everywhere. misogynistic
Windows 7 professional product Key
Windows 7 ultimate activation Key

Anonymous said...

The United says avoided this fate in the training course of the fantastic depressive disorders but a whole good offer Buy Cheap RS Goldof Europe do not. Most educational discussion of that juxtaposition focuses on what led Weimar Germany to fail.

Unknown said...

The perfect!These articles written too great,they rich contents and data accurately.they are help to me.I expect to see your new share.
Runescape Gold Cheap Diablo 3 Gold WOW Gold

cartier said...

If we keep going with the example of competition in this nation, let's create the following (also controversial) assumptions: (1) Many evangelicals take seriously the concept of "spare the rod to
, mess up the child" and thus spank their children;(2) an frustrating variety of shades of dark are evangelicals and thus spank their kids at a much greater amount than other categories in this country; (3) paddling is an assortment power, a breach of physical reliability that the law generally does not countenance. Do you really mean to say provided that the taint of racial discrimination prevails, a legislature here could not ban paddling missing some powerful to evidence-- beyond power supply itself—that it damages kids, merely because dark evangelicals exercise the exercise at greater prices and believe it to be consistently mandated?

Anonymous said...

The currency used in World of Warcraft, WoW is known as cheap wow gold. World of Warcraft itself is arguably the most popular MMORPG in the world today, with over 10 million subscribers playing regularly across the globe. Since its release on November 23, 2004, WoW has experienced phenomenal growth and seen the release of a number of expansion packs, including Burning Crusade, Cataclysm, Wrath of the Lich King, and Mists of Pandaria. Thanks to a team buy wow gold dedicated to regularly updating and tweaking the title, it continues to dominate the online game market.The game's currency, aion kinah is obtained by completing quests, defeating monsters and even through the in-game auction house. You can also buy aion kinah right here on, we offer low prices and speedy, guaranteed delivery cheap aion kinah.

Unknown said...

Thnaks dorf on law, silahkan klik disiniutuk melihat berbagi kebutuhan anda, anda bisa juga melihat website ini jika anda memtuhkan software kami memiliki detail lihat disini yang terjangkau

Di Jogja kami punya serta blog dan tentu saja kunjungi kami juga berbagai pilihan rak untuk Gudang terbaik