Friday, June 29, 2012

Media Absurdity, the ACA Decision, and Society's Need for a Strong Press

-- Posted by Neil H. Buchanan

About two weeks ago, I was contacted by a broadcast network, asking if I would be willing to be interviewed after the Supreme Court ruled on the ACA. I asked about the format, and they said that it would either be a panel discussion (which, they assured me after I asked insistently, would most definitely not be one of those absurd shows where people yell at each other) or simply an interview by a reporter. I told them that I would be happy to do so, under either format.

Earlier this week, the producer called me to set things up for yesterday's big announcement. She told me that they would want me to be interviewed on the steps of the Supreme Court at 9, 10, and 11am. I told them that the 10am slot would be odd, because the decision could be released in the middle of the interview. They told me that the interview would proceed as planned, even if the decision came out at exactly 10am.

I suddenly flashed on a memory from December 2000, when I was watching network coverage of the Bush v. Gore decision. I remembered vividly the ridiculous site of a reporter juggling a microphone and the slip opinion, flipping through the document and reading random phrases from the text. Because the decision did not say "Bush wins" on page 1, the unfortunate reporter was stuck babbling on live TV, providing nothing of value to viewers (except a memorably embarrassing moment for everyone involved).

I decided to contact the TV producer and tell her that I could not do the 10am slot. In an email, I explained that there would nothing to be gained by having me on TV, either talking again about an opinion that had not yet been released, or finding myself interrupted mid-interview by the release of the decision. I did not mention Bush v. Gore, but I did point out that this was going to be a particularly complicated decision, with the likelihood of different justices combining in different voting blocs on different issues. Snap analysis would be worse than nothing.

I soon received a call from the producer. She said that she completely understood my concern, and that they would not expect me to be able to speed-read the opinion. She then contradicted herself, saying that they would merely want me to give my best reaction to the opinion as soon as it came out, based on whatever I was able to read quickly. I immediately said, "No, I won't do that." She then tried to reassure me that they would not mind if I got it wrong. I said, "No, this is not a reasonable way to provide expert analysis."

She then said -- apparently thinking that this would help -- that "we'll just have you and the reporter divide up the pages, so that the two of you can get through it more quickly." I did not bother to say, "You're making it worse!" I simply said that it was ridiculous to think that one could react on the spot to an opinion of this magnitude and complexity. Finally, she said, "But all the other networks are going to do it this way!" At that point, I simply told her to find someone else.

Perhaps I was being a worry-wart, worrying my silly little head about nothing. Oh, right. For those of you who missed it, yesterday morning both CNN and Fox did exactly what I described. I happened to be checking CNN's website after 10am, and the first headline that came up was: "Mandate Struck Down." There was no associated story. (I realize that The Onion does headlines without stories, but ...) This was happening even as Scotusblog was accurately reporting the opposite result.

(Scotusblog, by the way, proved that it is at least possible not to embarrass oneself with real-time reporting. Even so, they were more careful, occasionally simply posting things like: "We're still here. It's a complicated opinion. Back with more as soon as possible." Even so, they did have to correct themselves on a more minor point, having originally written that people could refuse to pay the penalty AND not get insurance. They handled it well, but speed can still kill.)

CNN's online headline was changed after a few minutes to something like: "Court Rules on Health Care." Then, a few minutes after that, the headline became "UPHELD." I learned by watching The Daily Show last night (hilarious clip here) that this blunder was happening live on TV as well, at both CNN and Fox. Jon Stewart's people even managed to include the clip from "Airplane" in which the reporters in fedoras rush to the phone booths, knocking them over.

I realize that it is all too easy to mock news organizations these days. It was, however, pretty amazing to watch my prediction come true in real time. It was all so utterly predictable. After all, if some tax/econ professor can see it coming a mile away, how hard could it be for people with actual experience in the news business?

The problem, of course, is that major media have not gotten the "scoop mentality" out of their collective DNA. News producers apparently still have in mind the classic reporting on guilty-or-innocent verdicts (as in the old movies, with those guys in fedoras -- and occasionally Rosalind Russell -- shouting their copy into old-timey telephones). A multi-part Supreme Court decision does not fit that model.

The problem goes deeper than that, however. One problem, of course, is Fox itself. Beyond any scoop mentality, that network's insistence on getting facts wrong is nothing short of astonishing. For example, even after correcting their incorrect report that the ACA had been struck down, Fox (as I saw on Stephen Colbert's mocking coverage of the mock-worthy coverage) ran a banner across the bottom of the screen reading: "Supreme Court Rules Individual Mandate Will Become a Tax." What? That is not even close to what the Court said. The Court said that the mandate could pass constitutional muster, because it was in substance a tax for "taxing power" purposes. It is not even possible to imagine how to get from that to a statement that the mandate "will become a tax."

Facts-be-damned spin is Fox's calling card, of course. What is especially disturbing is that the journalists at the non-Fox outlets -- including print outlets -- are increasingly simply inept. For example, I gave an interview to a print reporter earlier this week, in anticipation of the ACA ruling. To his credit, he admitted that he had just been assigned to the story, and he knew nothing about the case. I suspected that he was being somewhat unduly modest, but I was happy to walk him through it. After more than an hour, however, having talked from various angles about the activity/inactivity distinction -- its absence in existing precedent, its susceptibility to "framing" differences, and so on -- it suddenly became clear that he honestly had never even heard of the activity/inactivity distinction. When I told him what the conservatives were trying to get the Supremes to adopt, the reporter suddenly perked up and said, "Oh, THAT makes sense to me. Now I get it!"

This was not, moreover, a reporter for some minor rag. I see no reason to name-and-shame a reporter or his news organization, because it is sufficient to say that this is a national news operation that is well-known to everyone who follows the news with any regularity. How could such a major organization put such an unprepared reporter on such an important case? One answer is that there are no longer many good journalists left doing these jobs. Staffs have been cut severely, pay is down, and the best reporters have been paid to take early retirements. (I do not know whether, to take but two examples, Linda Greenhouse or David Cay Johnston left The New York Times because they had become too expensive to keep on staff. Certainly, however, the Times has also been hollowed out.)

All of this is happening, moreover, to an industry that has never been as great as it sees itself. Nearly everyone I know has had experience with reporters simply getting stories wrong, even after the facts were explained patiently. There is a value in journalists being generalists (just as there is a value in law faculty remaining broadly informed enough to comment on each other's work), but a good generalist reporter must be capable of getting up to speed quickly. The people who are good at that -- and, much worse for the future, the young people who have the basic intelligence and skills to become good at that -- are not finding jobs in journalism.

I have been worried about how the Great Recession is being used as an excuse to squeeze the last breath of life out of labor unions, to hollow out public spending on social welfare agencies, to justify privatization of government services, and (most worrisome from my personal standpoint) to destroy America's still-pretty-great system of higher education. The problems with American journalism began before the Great Recession, but it is difficult not to see an acceleration in the decline of journalism. Ultimately, such a decline serves the powerful and the ruthless, who are glad not to have prying reporters exposing their activities.

The corporations that now own the major news organizations might not consciously wish to see their reporters humiliate themselves, especially in the way that happened so spectacularly yesterday. It is difficult to see, however, how the people who control those corporations do not gain in the long run (or even the medium-short run) from further public disrespect for the press. Underfunded news gathering is, it turns out, occasionally spectacularly entertaining. It is also, however, simply good news for those (in both politics and business) who always hated the media.

73 comments:

matt30 said...

Considering the activity/inactivity distinction is all but made up, it could be a case of over thinking the simple (especially if you're trying to explain the difference a frame of reference makes in determining what is and isn't activity).

As far as the TV media are concerned, I the importance of facts or getting things right is secondary to entertainment value. Watching reporters make fools of themselves on TV isn't really informative, but it is fun to watch and memorable.

Ian said...

I'm curious if you contacted the TV producer after the fact to point out what you worried about actually happened. Maybe they'll ask you to provide your two cents going forward.

Muhammad Zahid Iqbal said...

Thanks so much with this fantastic new web site. I’m very fired up to show it to anyone. It makes me so satisfied your vast understanding and wisdom have a new channel for trying into the world. personal injury attorney

Muhammad Zahid Iqbal said...

This is an interesting and so well maintained blog. Whole article is too good and well written. compare and contrast essay topics

Jason SantaMari said...

Thanks so much for sharing valuable information about this exiting topic. It´s really good news to hear what you´re been up too lately. click here

SEO said...

The post is written in very a good manner and it entails much useful information for me. I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.
Party Wear Embroidered Saree

hany pertiwi said...

thank you for this information, the above information is very useful for me, I will try to find other information on this web after this || kata mutiara indah || kata mutiara lucu|| mutiara kata dan gambar gambar

johny peterson said...

Thanks for the information appreciated been reading for awhile, and just wanted to let you know I continue to enjoy your writing.
Essay Writing | Buy Essays Online | Cheap Essay Writing | Custom Essay Writing | Urgent Essay | College Essay Writing

Anish Ahmad said...

I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoyed every little bit of it. I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff on your post.
does garcinia cambogia really work | does green coffee bean really work | raspberry ketones

jim carry said...

Good fill someone in on and this post helped me a lot in my college assignment. Say thank you you on your information.
Essay Writing

johny peterson said...

Great Blog! Very informative, I appreciate all the information that you just shared with me very much and I also bookmarked this on dig too. Take care and I'll be back to read more in the future.
Assignment Writing

steve7876 said...

This is a great post ! it was very informative. I look forward in reading more of your work. Also, I made sure to bookmark your website so I can come back later. I enjoyed every moment of reading it.Alexa

steve7876 said...

is one of the leading globally. Our Record and Reputation have proven that we are an expertise research and best essay help company offering high quality papers. All the papers are delivered within the time given, and may include:

steve7876 said...

Thanks so much with this fantastic new web site. I’m very fired up to show it to anyone. It makes me so satisfied your vast understanding and wisdom have a new channel for trying into the world. personal injury attorney
serviced apartments sydney

steve7876 said...

I'd like to thanks for that initiatives you get on paper this short article. My spouse and i look forward to more of your amazing blogs. for more info click here super foods

steve7876 said...

I'd like to thanks for that initiatives you get on paper this short article. My spouse and i look forward to more of your amazing blogs. for more info click here super foods

steve7876 said...


I'd like to thanks for that initiatives you get on paper this short article. My spouse and i look forward to more of your amazing blogs. for more info click here Dymo labels online free of cost

Felix Smith said...

I actually added your blog to my favourites and will look forward for more updates. Great Job, Keep it up. Cheap Essays

Felix Smith said...

Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have truly enjoyed browsing your weblog posts. Cheap Essay Writing

Felix Smith said...

This is a great article, I thoroughly enjoyed reading it. keep up the good work. Paper Writing Services

Timbaland said...

The exhibit, which will run from April 25 to June 28, will celebrate ro zeny works of individuality by approximately 25 designers.Several of Tai's pieces to be exhibited are part of her most recent collection called "Spring," which utilizes the plique-à-jour technique. The technique ragnarok online zeny is a style of enameling in which enamels are fused into the openings of a metal filigree network with no backing, producing an effect that resembles stained glass."Each piece is one-of-a-kind, and many offer built-in movement and flexibility," Tai said in a media release. "Aside from the fact that I enjoy the long and focused creation process, this technique gives a realistic edge to my pieces. Creating jewelry Ragnarok zeny as art objects that can be worn is my way of paying tribute to life and all creation."

Timbaland said...

At an exhibition of the world's best swordsman, the third-place fencer ROM Gold took the stage. A fly was released, and with an arc of his sword he cut the fly in half. The crowd cheered. Then the second-place man sliced a fly into quarters. A hush fell in anticipation Runes Of Magic Gold of the world's greatest swordsman. His blade came down in a mighty arc - but the insect ROM Gold continued on its way! The crowd was aghast. The greatest swordsman had missed his target completely, yet he continued to smile. "Why are you so happy?" someone yelled. "You missed!"

steve7876 said...

We are a while from a t shirt with the question to slip your ex benchmarks coming from all worth and also became spoken for one information regarding a large fan base. I'm sure contented or even thankful at the blogger for around by myself attempt crowned profitably or maybe an extensive searches. Fine I can continue to achieved check out what exactly is little in such a place, many thanks.zanzibar honeymoons

Protima K. said...

Thanks for sharing your good thoughts and idea here. Just continue on sharing your talent and creation to us readers. Keep on posting! real voodoo spells

aftab alam said...

I am always searching online for articles that can help me and this is one
cambogia garcinia side effects | garcinia cambogia where to buy | garcinia cambogia extract where to buy | review garcinia cambogia

shahbaz said...

It’s good to find out for our self why were traveling firstly; that therefore can shape the finances.most healthy food

Lauren anderson said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
steve7876 said...

Much obliged, We have additionally been looking for illumination about that subject for quite a while and additionally your own particular is the better We have uncovered until in the end at this point.yet, ponder the easier accumulation? Will you be certain as to the present? For more click on Merry Williams

shahbaz said...

Good post, well put together. Thanks. I will be back soon to check out for updates. Cheers..natural weight loss tips

steve7876 said...

All the contents you mentioned in post are too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind, thanks for sharing the information keep updating, looking forward for more posts. prepper survival kits

Ryan Reynold said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Best economical Dymo Labels said...

Yup! terribly usable and straightforward to use so. a giant facilitate in my college paper writing services at once.

Lorena Alice said...

am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. thesis proposal

shahbaz said...

Pretty adequate post. I merely stumbled aloft your web log and basic to say that I acquire extremely enjoyed annual your web log posts. Any methodology i will be 20s costumes

Elizabeth J. Neal said...

Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. http://www.gameiterator.com/

Ahmad Choirun Najib said...

nice post Sir. Thanks. This is useful for me :)

http://najibblog2010.blogspot.com

shahbaz said...

They may be taken in their all-natural raw variety, mainly because cooking pinto legumes damages many of the elements that assist in fat loss.Buy Wholesale Yacon Syrup Online

Florence Jessica said...

I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. I appreciate all the information that you just shared with me very much and I also bookmarked this on dig too. personal statement help

Sour Sdey said...

It's Useful For Me thanks ^^

http://sweettop10.com/

shahbaz said...

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.how to make money fast

steve7876 said...

am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept.digitaltickets.com

shahbaz said...

joy to read, I came across this site ages ago but I’ve only just decided to stop back and have a read of your articles.electronic cigarettes australia

Hamza Shahzad Shahzad said...

its really nice..

Tom Brian said...

I love it your ideas are great. Nice one good job..
Airport Taxi

Fiverr Work said...

Likes noticeably raise the stage of popularity of one's respective world-wide-web web page and together with the suitable variety depend; a lot of persons will probably be enthusiastic about your account. The corporations that deliver these expert expert services, will offer you with non-automated or robot likes and provide you with genuine Instagram likes. likes instagram The great depth relating to this is usually that they may be genuinely speedily transported toward your account therefore you do not have to have to show up at that noticeably. And when you are a small business, expanding your Instagram likes is going to be beneficial.

lelle sandy said...

I loved it really amazing thanks for the share.Hyp : cheap essays

zachray taylor said...

custom essays
I loved the way you discuss the topic great work thanks for the share.

shahbaz said...

It’s hard to find knowledgeable people on this topic, but you sound like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks living trust

sadia sulaman said...

grandstream gxp1100
I just thought it may be an idea to post incase anyone else was having problems researching but I am a little unsure if I am allowed to put names and addresses on here.

sadia sulaman said...

This will make you feel more alluring, slimmer and better, which will thus make you need to work out all the more frequently. If interest to know more please visitwww.rhinomoto.co.uk |

www.ebayshopdesigner.co.uk |

www.vegan-candles.co.uk |

www.oxygenediving.co.uk |

www.montagupe.co.uk |

www.ne7es.co.uk |

www.happymondayscomedy.co.uk |

www.mmmmh.co.uk |

www.eskyhobby.co.uk |

www.crystalapartment.co.uk |

shahbaz said...

This content is very good, I like the item completely. In this article When i discovered a lot, i then can pay far more awareness of anyone. I will be pleased through the quality of information on this excellent website.For additional data click onrecuperar hd

david paul said...

Lovely piece of work thanks for shearing.
geoessay

shahbaz said...

omebody generally fortify develop considerably content We would discuss. This can be when ideal report delivering support in addition to dissertation support content materia surf camp Lanzarote

shahbaz said...

I did a survey about Jolanda's Cafe, and so far, most of them are positive. So maybe they only need improvement, and not major changes.treasure hunt

Tina brian said...

Awesome post this one realy helped me at my point of confusion :) Realy thanx alot for sharing :) Keep it up ;)
Billy Bishop Airport
YTZ Airport
Taxi to Billy Bishop Airport

Tina brian said...

Awesome post this one realy helped me at my point of confusion :) Realy thanx alot for sharing :) Keep it up ;)
Billy Bishop Airport
YTZ Airport
Taxi to Billy Bishop Airport

Tina brian said...

Awesome post this one realy helped me at my point of confusion :) Realy thanx alot for sharing :) Keep it up ;)
Billy Bishop Airport
YTZ Airport
Taxi to Billy Bishop Airport

Tina brian said...

Awesome post this one realy helped me at my point of confusion :) Realy thanx alot for sharing :) Keep it up ;)
Billy Bishop Airport
YTZ Airport
Taxi to Billy Bishop Airport

Tina brian said...

Awesome post this one realy helped me at my point of confusion :) Realy thanx alot for sharing :) Keep it up ;)
Billy Bishop Airport
YTZ Airport
Taxi to Billy Bishop Airport

Tina brian said...

Awesome post this one realy helped me at my point of confusion :) Realy thanx alot for sharing :) Keep it up ;)
Billy Bishop Airport
YTZ Airport
Taxi to Billy Bishop Airport

Tina brian said...

Awesome post this one realy helped me at my point of confusion :) Realy thanx alot for sharing :) Keep it up ;)
Billy Bishop Airport
YTZ Airport
Taxi to Billy Bishop Airport

shahbaz said...

I am able to view that you just are placing the a Aaron C. Meyer lot of initiatives in your blog site. Hold posting the nice function. Several definitely helpful information in there. Book-marked. Wonderful to determine your web site. Cheers!Tree Care

Best economical Dymo Labels said...

Thanks regarding discussing these local based marketing records. Reading just about any function in reside is absolutely fired up We are in person enjoy to see this hold undertaking additional posting.clover point of sale

sadia sulaman said...

I need to to thank you for ones time for this particularly fantastic read!! I definitely really liked every part of it and i also have you saved to fav to look at new information in your site. BlogHuts

Ayman said...

You described it very beautiful. your writing style grabbed my intentions,would love to read more about it… long frocks

shahbaz said...

Hello webmaster good day. Superb post. You have acquired a new fan. Please continue the good work and I look forward to more of your great posts.Watercolor real estate

sadia sulaman said...

Hay, really great blog. I think it is more informatics and useful site. All visitors are benefited to read this sit’s article. All article is Unique and relevant.Door Frames

shahbaz said...

I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.rumah dijual di batununggal bandung

steve7876 said...

Om in de moderne tijd onderscheidend te zijn is er dus wat meer nodig dan een foutloze website zonder lelijke plaatjes. Op het internet moet eigenlijk al duidelijk worden waar het bedrijf voor staat, sedotan plastik

sadia sulaman said...

It’s really a great and helpful piece of info. I am glad that you shared this helpful info with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing. Social Media Links

sadia sulaman said...

I might be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your rss feed which really should do the trick! Have a nice day!France VPN service

sadia sulaman said...

excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here. Streaming TV Box

steve7876 said...

This will enable significant broadband penetration at the rural and remotest areas and can be a boon in M2M adoption. custom website design orlando