Thursday, May 14, 2009

The 2009 Social Security and Medicare Trustees' Report: Preliminary Comments

[Note: The post below has been edited to fix an error at the end of the first paragraph. The last sentence of that paragraph now correctly states that the projected date that the Medicare trust fund is likely to reach a zero balance is 2017. NHB]


On May 12, the Trustees of the Social Security program released their annual financial report, which provides (among other things) 75-year projections of the financial flows associated with the program as well as the size and projected path of the Social Security trust fund balance. The standard media response to the annual release is to focus on the date at which the trust fund is projected to be depleted, and this year is no exception. The headlines have emphasized that the depletion date for Social Security has been moved up to 2037 from last year's estimate of 2041, the change being directly related to the depth of the recession. Medicare's finances present immediate challenges, with the trust fund for that program likely to hit zero dollars in 2017.

I will be writing a guest column on FindLaw's Writ next week discussing some of the details of the Social Security Trustees' Report; and I will also be publishing a more lengthy analysis of the finances of the Social Security program in Tax Notes later this month. (You can read my analysis of this issue from two years ago here or at 92 Cornell L. Rev 257.) Here, I will offer a few preliminary thoughts on the big conclusion that one should draw from this year's report and on the media coverage and political discussion of the report.

As I argued on this blog earlier this year, Social Security should not be a legislative priority for President Obama -- or, indeed, for anyone with a sense of proportion about the supposed "crisis" in the program. The Social Security system might or might not "run out of money" in the sense that the trust fund could reach a zero balance a few decades from now. That potential depletion date moves around depending on developments in the economy, making it unsurprising that the date moved forward by a few years in the current economic environment. If anything, the relatively small change in the long-term estimates is good news, since this demonstrates that the system can weather even the current, severe crisis with relatively minor changes in its long-term finances.

(Aside: The Trustees actually provide estimates of long-term finances under two alternative scenarios, one of which (based on estimates that are the least pessimistic of the three scenarios but that are not, in my opinion, affirmatively optimistic) shows that the Social Security Trust Fund will never be depleted while the other (the most pessmistic) has the trust fund hitting zero in 2029.)

One of the major problems with media coverage of Social Security is that reporters generally buy into the narrative that we have an "entitlements crisis," lumping together Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security. This is extremely misleading, because the health care-related programs have much different financial prospects, caused by the high rates of inflation in health care costs. Media coverage of this year's report was no different, with "entitlements" and "Social Security and Medicare" being treated as huge ongoing crises that we might be addressing if only politicians were not such cowards. Bizarrely, the coverage this year added into this misleading mix the fact that Social Security recipients will not receive a cost-of-living adjustment this year for the first time in decades. Even though this has been known for months, and even though it is the result of changes in the path of the cost of living (obviously), reporters are treating this as somehow related to Social Security's "deteriorating finances," which is just plain wrong.

The good news is that President Obama's spokespeople, and many Democrats in Congress, are finally making the correct argument about "entitlements": The real long-run fiscal problem is directly related to the escalating costs of health care, and those costs affect not just Medicare but privately-financed health care as well. The appropriate response to any concerns about the long-run fiscal projections, therefore, is to move forward with legislation to address the fundamental problems of the U.S. health insurance and health care systems. While I disagree with their further suggestion that we can move on to "fix" Social Security after we have dealt with health care (which implies quite incorrectly that Social Security is broken), it is at least good to see that the majority party's stated priorities are appropriate to the real problems at hand.

The biggest political problem, of course, is that these programs are extremely complicated and thus are easy targets for demagogues. (Example: It is true that there is nothing "real" in the Trust Funds; but that fact is actually an argument to be less concerned about Social Security rather than more so.) Seeing movement in the direction of sanity in discussions about Social Security's long-term finances is heartening indeed. We are actually becoming more reality-based.

-- Posted by Neil H. Buchanan

4 comments:

best-tutor said...

Hello!

very nice post... enjoyed it very much.

Thank you

http://www.best-tutor.com
http://best-tutor.com"

good site

tutor
tutor

酒店經紀ㄚ君姐姐 said...

,,領檯姐.,便服店,,

狗熊克星 said...

青青草園報導 大陸新娘介紹愛心助人,嘉義一名大陸新娘仲介為了救治同為外籍新娘介紹的好友莎莎,莎莎是一位外籍新娘仲介由於雙手工作受傷無法拿東西工作,越南新娘介紹每天早上都會送早餐去給莎莎吃他們常透過越南新娘仲介論壇此位越南新娘介紹還會幫生病小姑按摩,她有一個越南新娘仲介的好朋友阿花也從越南嫁來的她非常的有愛心,大陸新娘仲介體貼細心體貼的照顧小姑旁邊的居民都覺的非常的有愛心,由於外籍新娘介紹的先生是做水電工的,薪水很不多,她從無怨言,且大陸新娘介紹對小孩都照顧的很好,讓老公無後顧之憂在外打拼,外籍新娘仲介的孝行令他的越南新娘介紹朋友要她堅持只要女兒監護權,不要拿生活費,靠著越南新娘仲介的友人資助,從路邊攤起家賣

家鄉美食,5年前租下店面,每天他的外籍新娘介紹的朋友會來幫忙,傍晚四點剛過,店內已擠滿大陸新娘仲介,位於木柵光明戲院口的阿美小吃店,不論魚飯、河粉好吃,在客人的有口皆碑相傳下,不僅外籍新娘仲介同鄉,連大陸新娘介紹也聞香來光顧其她每天會到同事越南新娘介紹的朋友公司拿手工藝的材料回家加工,他有一個越南新娘仲介的朋友非常有愛心,得知他先生受傷無法工作,大陸新娘仲介主動把他的多年的存款捐一半給外籍新娘介紹,幫助他們度過難關,外籍新娘仲介大愛令人非常感動,祝大陸新娘介紹的老公的腳傷早日康復當地許多人都娶越南新娘介紹,因為到了假日許多觀光客,老公要做生意,這些越南新娘仲介或是外籍新娘介紹都會很乖的在家照顧公婆,把家裡打理

的很好,所以大家口耳相傳,許多人都娶外籍新娘仲介,她們也把家鄉的美食好手藝教他們的小姑,讓大陸新娘仲介們除了賣甘草茶之外,很多種好吃的東西可以賣給大陸新娘介紹越南新娘介紹會寫程式的人非常少,板橋也有一位越南新娘仲介會寫c語言,真的很特別,現在大陸新娘仲介們有接到案子做不來時都會問問其它外籍新娘介紹大陸新娘介紹有沒有時間接案子,這些外籍新娘仲介在家照顧小孩位越南新娘介紹他老公有肝病,常常要帶他去看醫生,他力氣較小,越南新娘仲介每次看到他帶他出來她都會主動上前去幫忙,這看在另一位外籍新娘介紹的眼裡非常的感動,於是這位外籍新娘仲介也主動加入義工的行列,在這個社區內,大陸新娘仲介都像是一家人一樣相互扶持相互幫忙

讓這些台灣媳婦的大陸新娘介紹的愛心,他的大陸新娘介紹朋友要她堅持只要女兒監護權,不拿半毛錢,靠著外籍新娘仲介的友人資助,從路邊攤起家賣家鄉小吃,6年前租下店面,每天他的越南新娘仲介的朋友會來幫忙,中午12點都還沒到,店內已擠滿大陸新娘仲介,位於新莊中港路的阿信小吃店,不論水煎包、蛋包飯好好吃,在客戶口耳相傳下,不僅越南新娘介紹同鄉,連外籍新娘介紹以及!大陸新娘仲介等一律納入就保加保對象,一旦失業,越南新娘介紹同樣凡是越南新娘仲介下面的,大陸新娘介紹約二萬五千五百四十八人。可向投保單位反應,大陸新娘仲介會追溯自五月起納保近陳潔聽朋友說,外籍新娘介紹失業也可領失業給付,她既失望又難過。外籍新娘仲介解釋

gaohui said...

If you're a plus size woman you've probably Moncler noticed that the majority of coats in stores today are moncler veste designed with women that are supposed to be moncler doudoune shaped like a toothpick. It can be difficult to moncler hommes find a coat that not only looks good but also doesn't break the moncler femmes bank. Coats typically cost a lot of money so it's in your doudoune moncler femmes best interest to shop wisely.A lot of women doudoun moncler hommes make the mistake of only thinking about their dress doudoune moncler femmes or skirt when putting together an doudoune moncler hommes outfit. However, it's important to keep in mind that the majoriy of moncler-gilet people are going to see you with a coat on.