Posts

Informing the Reasonable Observer

By Michael Dorf My latest Verdict column discusses the new SCOTUS case,  Walker v. Texas Division, Sons of Confederate Veterans (TSCV) . The case poses the question whether Texas violated the First Amendment when it refused to issue specialty license plates bearing the Conferedate battle flag as part of the logo. As I explain in the column, the outcome appears to turn on whether specialty plates are best conceived as government speech--in which case Texas wins--or private speech--in which case TSCV probably wins. I say "probably" because the state argues that even if the plates are private speech, its refusal to grant them is valid as viewpoint neutral. I explain in the column why I think that latter contention should (and probably will) be rejected. I also explore another possibility: University of Miami law professor Caroline Mala Corbin's argument, in a 2008  NYU Law Review article , that there ought to be an intermediate category of "mixed" private-gove...

How Will Democrats Play the Impeachment Trap Game?

-- Posted by Neil H. Buchanan Frequent readers of Dorf on Law know that Professor Dorf and I have written a long series of academic articles, Verdict columns, and blog posts about what the President would be constitutionally required to do if he is ever faced with a debt ceiling-related crisis.  As it happens, however, Republicans and Democrats alike -- most definitely including the White House -- have not adopted our approach.  As frustrating as that has been, it does have the liberating effect of allowing me to observe the political theater, knowing full well that everyone is ignoring us.  No responsibility, pure entertainment.  (Yes, the entertainment is sometimes more like a horror film, but that's still entertainment!)  It also makes it perversely interesting to speculate on what the parties might do, now that they are working within a box into which they have mistakenly placed themselves. Since early 2013, I have been using the term " impeachment tra...

Judge Harry Edwards Is Still Unimpressed With Legal Scholarship

by Michael Dorf Back in 2011, Chief Justice John Roberts made waves in the legal academy when he said this: "Pick up a copy of any law review that you see, and the first article is likely to be, you know, the influence of Immanuel Kant on evidentiary approaches in 18th Century Bulgaria, or something, which I’m sure was of great interest to the academic that wrote it, but isn’t of much help to the bar." The complaint that legal scholarship is not useful to practicing lawyers was roundly condemned (e.g.,  here ) on the ground that it's not true and that even if it were true, so what? The point of scholarship in political science is not to help politicians, so why should scholarship about the law have to help lawyers? Roberts' line was a throwaway--although I promise a laudatory blog post for anyone who gets a U.S. law review to publish an actual article on Kant's influence on 18th Century Bulgarian evidence law. Anyway, the view expressed by Roberts has been exp...

When the Public Hates Its Own Champions

-- Posted by Neil H. Buchanan In my Dorf on Law posts last Tuesday and Thursday , I described a fundamental conflict between two views of punitive damages in civil cases.  In one, drawn from a line of scholarship among economics-based legal thinkers, punitives can be used to bring justice to wrongdoers (especially companies who predictably injure some fraction of their customers, because reducing injuries fails a cost-benefit test) who otherwise would never be forced to pay the full measure of the damage that they inflict on society.  In the other, which is the world in which we actually live (for the most part), punitives exist only to punish wrongdoers who are especially depraved. It is well understood that there are three prongs to society's approach to controlling harmful behaviors in the commercial realm.  First, there is direct regulation, carried out by executive agencies of state and local governments as well as at the federal level.  The Consumer Produ...

Systematic "Rectal Feeding" is Systematic Rape, Which is a War Crime

by Michael Dorf The Senate Select Committee Report on Intelligence (i.e., CIA torture) is horrifying in numerous ways, so much so that it is easy to be overwhelmed by the details. Here I'll focus on one that has generated some considerable attention: the revelation that the CIA used "rectal feeding" on at least five detainees "without documented medical necessity." Rectal feeding is exactly what it sounds like. Food is forced into the prisoner's rectum. For example, the report states that one hunger striking prisoner's lunch "was 'pureed' and rectally infused. Additional sessions of rectal feeding and hydration followed." Rectal feeding was originally developed as a means of providing nutrition for people who could not eat regularly--either because they were incapable of doing so or refused to do so--but was largely replaced in medicine once intravenous drips and other methods became reliable. The CIA used rectal feeding and hydr...

True Threats, Motives, and Intentions

by Sherry F. Colb In my Verdict column this week, I discuss the recently argued case of Elonis v. United States , in which the U.S. Supreme Court faces the question whether federal statutory law and the First Amendment permit the prosecution of a man who made threats but whose jury was not asked to determine whether the defendant truly intended by his words to generate fear in the objects of those threats.  In my column, I analyze the constitutional question in terms of both the harm that threats inflict (harms that underlie the "true threats" exception to the First Amendment's protection for free speech) and the self-censorship (or "chilling effect") that different types of threat regimes might generate among people hoping to engage in legitimately protected expression. In this post, I want to focus on an issue that arose during the Elonis oral argument last week. In the course of his argument, the petitioner's attorney, John P. Elwood, seemingly mod...

Why Can't We Talk About Abortion?

by Eric Segall Many controversial issues divide Americans, such as how health care should be handled, the appropriate relationship between church and state, and the validity of affirmative action. Although these questions trigger strong views, public debate is often (or at least at times) respectful and bracketed by an awareness on the part of most people that some compromise is likely necessary. The same simply can’t be said about abortion. Those who believe that terminating a pregnancy is the moral equivalent of murder often characterize those in favor of that right as anti-life, anti-baby, and even anti-God.  Those who think women should have the right to decide for themselves whether to carry a fetus to term often characterize those opposed as anti-women, anti-sex, and anti-choice. The rhetoric on both sides is often extreme with hyperbolic charges hurled in both directions. Listening to the warring sides suggests that nothing short of a complete prohibition on all aborti...

NY Court Mishandles Misguided Lawsuit Seeking Personhood Status for Chimps

By Michael Dorf Earlier this year, I expressed misgivings about a state habeas corpus case filed by Steven Wise and the Nonhuman Rights Project on behalf of Tommy, a captive chimpanzee. I said there that, although I share many of Wise's long-term goals, his attempt to secure legal recognition for the personhood of chimps was misguided for two reasons: First, in emphasizing the ways in which chimps are very much like humans (due in no small part to the fact that chimps and bonobos are our closest surviving cousins), the legal strategy, if successful, would invite courts to draw a line that separates, on the one side, humans, great apes, and a few other kinds of animals (such as elephants, parrots, and sea mammals pictured on the Nonhuman Rights Project's website) from the billions of other animals (such as chickens, cows, fishes, and pigs) who suffer and die at the hands of humans. Second, I explained that Wise's common-law action would surely be dismissed for the very r...

Law, Economics, and Posner

by Michael Dorf On the Concurring Opinions  blog, Ron Collins has been running a fascinating series on and with Judge Dick Posner. You can find the first three installments here , here , and here . The fourth installment consists of questions from judges, a journalist, and a whole bunch of law professors, including me. I recommend the whole series but here I'll focus on the answer Posner gave to one of my questions. (Each of the 24 interviewers submitted two questions to Collins, who asked them of Posner.) Me: I detect in your academic work (and to a lesser extent your work as a judge) a gradual drift from an economic analysis of law to pragmatism more broadly. Do you agree with that assessment, and if so, what do you think accounts for it?  Judge Posner: You’re correct. It is partly a result of the inroads that psychology has made on economic analysis, partly a result of the economic profession’s failure to understand finance and monetary policy in the period leading ...

A "Rough Justice" Argument for Increased Civil Damages

-- Posted by Neil H. Buchanan In my Dorf on Law post on Tuesday , I used the example of the "punitive multiple" to illustrate a problem that can arise in a system that uses individualized legal proceedings to address (at least in part) broader social problems.  The basic logical conflict illustrated by the Michael Brown case in Ferguson, Missouri is that most people with even a semblance of awareness know that "cop on black" violence is a systemic problem, whereas we also know that there will be situations in which such deadly force was, as the police say, "a good shoot."  Even when a case is correctly not pursued, the individualized justice fails to address the larger social injustice that persists. The punitive multiple (which awards larger damages to individual plaintiffs, because of the "larger guilt" of the defendants) becomes relevant here because it shows just how odd it is to try to use a judicial proceeding to deal with a broader pr...