Informing the Reasonable Observer
By Michael Dorf My latest Verdict column discusses the new SCOTUS case, Walker v. Texas Division, Sons of Confederate Veterans (TSCV) . The case poses the question whether Texas violated the First Amendment when it refused to issue specialty license plates bearing the Conferedate battle flag as part of the logo. As I explain in the column, the outcome appears to turn on whether specialty plates are best conceived as government speech--in which case Texas wins--or private speech--in which case TSCV probably wins. I say "probably" because the state argues that even if the plates are private speech, its refusal to grant them is valid as viewpoint neutral. I explain in the column why I think that latter contention should (and probably will) be rejected. I also explore another possibility: University of Miami law professor Caroline Mala Corbin's argument, in a 2008 NYU Law Review article , that there ought to be an intermediate category of "mixed" private-gove...