Wednesday, July 27, 2011

Fairness versus Utility and the Fourth Amendment Exclusionary Rule

By Sherry F. Colb

In my column this week, I discuss the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Davis v. United States, which held that if police conduct a search that is authorized under existing appellate precedent interpreting the Fourth Amendment, then the evidence that results from that search is admissible at trial, even if the High Court announces (after the search but before the conviction becomes final) that such searches actually violate the Fourth Amendment.  The Court takes the position that the exclusionary rule, under which a judge keeps illegally obtained evidence from the jury's consideration at trial, is a costly way of inducing police to comply with the Fourth Amendment.  Suppression ought therefore to be limited to cases where it will most effectively deter Fourth Amendment violations -- cases in which police have behaved culpably (i.e., deliberately, recklessly, or with gross negligence) in performing a search or seizure.  In my column I discuss the changing face of the exclusionary rule over the last century, and I challenge the Supreme Court's conclusion that effective deterrence requires police culpability.  The Court, I argue, confuses fairness (of punishing only those who do something culpable) with deterrent value.

In this post, I want to discuss the difficulty we have, on both sides of the aisle, in ignoring concepts of "fairness" when it comes to the exclusionary rule.  Quite apart from the Court's desire to limit exclusion to cases in which police deserve to have their efforts undermined and frustrated, it is common to think about the suppression of evidence in terms of what everyone deserves.

For opponents of the exclusionary rule (and for some supporters as well), it is clear that a person who commits a criminal act deserves to be punished.  The fact that police search the criminal's home without probable cause or without a warrant, moreover, does nothing to diminish this desert.  Say, for example, John Doe murders his wife.  By coincidence, then, police decide to search John Doe's home, without probable cause, because they smell donuts when they walk by and they feel an overwhelming craving for them.  They break into the house to look for donuts, in other words, and instead find the body of John's murdered wife.  The behavior of the police in this case was totally inappropriate.  They were searching a person's home to find donuts to steal.  Yet John Doe nonetheless deserves punishment for murder, just as much as he would deserve it if the police had received a call from a reliable informant and sought a warrant to look for the body that they found.  If John Doe escapes punishment because the police lacked probable cause, most people outside the A.C.L.U. will find this result unfair, to society, to the victim's family, and to justice itself, which requires that people pay for their crimes.

For strong defenders of the exclusionary rule, the introduction at trial of evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment is itself unfair.  By benefiting from evidence taken illegally, the police (and everyone represented by the State in wanting John Doe punished) unfairly benefits from having violated the Constitution.  John Doe, moreover, suffers the unfairness of landing in prison (or death row) only because the police violated his Fourth Amendment right to security against unreasonable searches.  Like a million-dollar lottery winner who stole his winning ticket, the government is cashing in on its own  unlawful conduct, thereby adding insult to injury.

A cooler-headed assessment of fairness suggests that once police perform an unreasonable search and seizure that turns up reliable incriminating evidence, it becomes impossible to achieve fairness for all parties.  Suppression unfairly protects someone who deserves to be punished, while introduction unfairly exploits a constitutional violation to yield benefits that would otherwise have eluded the violator.  And those who debate about the exclusionary rule have a difficult time avoiding the issue of fairness, even when they seem to be talking about something else (such as the marginal deterrent value of exclusion).  This reality suggests that most people would have an easier time if we were able to deter Fourth Amendment violations without suppressing evidence of wrongdoing, when the perpetrators of wrongdoing (whether the criminals or the police) are less salient and our appetite for just desserts less intense.  Utilizing the exclusionary rule to bring about an optimally efficient state of affairs seems inevitably to clash with the intuition that justice and fairness to the individual actors at issue are more important than the utility maximization that the exclusionary rule is currently tasked with achieving.

15 comments:

Paul Scott said...

"This reality suggests that most people would have an easier time if we were able to deter Fourth Amendment violations without suppressing evidence of wrongdoing"

I couldn't agree more with this. It is, in fact, I think the first thing I said when I took your Crim Pro class ages ago.

The solution has always seemed completely obvious to me - punish both wrongdoers. Excluding the evidence doesn't seem like a remedy for anything and certainly any concept that allowing the evidence is "unfair" is clearly wrong.

Punish the police through administrative boards and allowing civil actions - which also importantly would give a 4A remedy to those we most care about - people against whom the police have committed a 4A violating search or seizure but against whom the police found no evidence of any crime. I.e., the innocent.

Wei Jian said...

Staunch defenders of the exclusionary rule, the introduction at trial of evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment itself is unfair. They benefit from the evidence gathered illegally, police (and the world represented by the state to punish John Doe) unfairly benefits of violating the Constitution. John Doe, however, suffers the injustice of landing in jail (or death row), only because the police violated his right to Fourth Amendment against unreasonable searches unreasonable safety. As a lottery winner a million dollar winning ticket was stolen, the government is collecting on its own wrongful conduct, which adds insult to injury.Cheap Tera Gold Tera Power Leveling Tera Account Tera Items RS Gold cheap tera goldRS Gold Buy RS Gold Eden Eternal Eden Eternal Gold Eden Eternal Review

Bill Walton said...

In this article, I want to examine the problems we have, on both factors of the section, in neglecting aspects of "fairness" when it comes to the exclusionary procedure. Quite apart from the Court's wish to control different to situations in which authorities should have to have their work compromised and discouraged, it is popular to think about the suppression of information with regards to what everyone warrants.
RS Gold WOW Gold Cheap Tera Gold

Funny Games said...

英文seo :The remedy has always seemed absolutely apparent to me - discipline both wrongdoers. Eliminating the information doesn't seem like a remedy for anything and certainly any strategy that enabling the information is "unfair" is clearly incorrect.

marly aaran said...

Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work. 
sddollhouse |

amine lahragui said...


thanks so much for that great blog and thanks also for accepting my links thanks
طريقة عمل الدونات طريقة عمل البان كيك طريقة عمل الكنافة طريقة عمل البسبوسة طريقة عمل الكيك طريقة عمل عجينة البيتزا فوائد القرفه
thanks so much i like very so much your post
فوائد الحلبة فوائد الزنجبيل فوائد الرمان فوائد زيت السمسم علاج البواسير فوائد البصل فوائد اليانسون فوائد الكركم فوائد الزعتر قصص جحا تعريف الحب علامات الحمل

abbi barclay said...

I think this is definitely an amazing project here. So much good will be coming from this project. The ideas and the work behind this will pay off so much.
www.businessanalysissummit.com |

aminos lahragui said...


thanks so much i like very so much your post
حلى الاوريو الفطر الهندي صور تورته حلى قهوه طريقة عمل السينابون طريقة عمل بلح الشام بيتزا هت كيكة الزبادي حلا سهل صور كيك عجينة العشر دقائق

Ruben said...

This post is really amazing! I really think that you might look into giving us more great posts like this. Please consider my request very carefully and try to come up with even more better posts like this in the future. Looking forward to hearing from you! http://great-term-paper.com/

wasirdenature said...

gejala penyakit gonore pada pria obat generik kencing nanah di apotik alat kelamin keluar nanah herbal denature nanah keluar dari kemaluan cara mengobati penyakit kencing nanah obat penyakit raja singa untuk pria keluar cairan nanah dari kemaluan

wasirdenature said...

mengapa alat kelamin mengeluarkan nanah gejala penyakit gonore pada pria nanah keluar dari kemaluan obat gonore kencing nanah ujung penis keluar cairan nanah kelamin keluar nanah penyebab kemaluan keluar nanah

herbal medicine said...

gejala penyakit gonore pada pria obat generik kencing nanah di apotik alat kelamin keluar nanah herbal denature nanah keluar dari kemaluan cara mengobati penyakit kencing nanah obat penyakit raja singa untuk pria keluar cairan nanah dari kemaluan

obat herbal said...

kutil kelamin pada ibu hamil dan cara mengobati kutil di kemaluan kutil di sekitar kelamin wanita dan kutil di sekitar kemaluan wanita dan cara mengobati kutil di sekitar kemaluan dab tumbuh kutil di sekitar kemaluan dan bahaya dan resiko penyakit kutil kelamin dan kutil di sekitar kelamin pria dan kutil di sekitar kemaluan merupakan solusi pengobatan herbal dari denature indonesia

Herbal de nature said...



obat kutil kelamin
Obat kutil di kemaluan
Obat kutil pada alat kelamin
Obat Kondiloma Akuminata
obat sipilis resep dokter
Obat yang ampuh mengobati kencing nanah
Obat kencing nanah atau gonore yang manjur
Mengobati penis keluar nanah
Obat yang manjur untuk kencing keluar nanah
Obat herbal yang manjur untuk ambeien atau wasir
Berbagai Gejala-Gejala Sipilis dan Pencegahannya
Jual obat kutil kelamin
Obat kutil di sekitar kelamin
obat miom dan kista
OBAT KUTIL DI KEMALUAN COWOK

obat herbal said...

Obat kencing Nanah De Nature Obat Herbal obat Kutil Kelamincara mengobati penyakit wasir obat wasir herbal denature obat wasir ambeien herpes kelamin denature