Tuesday, September 08, 2009

Pres. Obama's Manifesto, and that Other One

Now that the White House has released the text of the President's speech welcoming America's youth back to school, the notion that it is some sort of socialist proclamation can be laid bare as utterly delusional. The speech extols hard work and individual responsibility as the patriotic duty of all Americans and a means towards individual self-advance that will have the side effect of improving the economy for all. It is, in essence, a bourgeois manifesto.

The irony here is head-spinning. The actual Communist Manifesto of Marx and Engels makes the opposite point. Though written over 160 years ago, the Manifesto remains a powerfully insightful document--and in its diagnostic if not its prescriptive elements--it is arguably more relevant to our times than President Obama's homey advice. Consider the core points of the opening (and to my mind most trenchant) chapter of the Manifesto:

On the economy: Capitalism, to succeed, requires ever-expanding markets, and thus globalization until it precipitates the collapse of global markets, in continual cycles of boom and bust.

On health care (and more): Under capitalism, the bourgeois imperative "has converted the physician, the lawyer, the priest, the poet, the man of science, into its paid wage laborers."

On the shrinking middle class and increasing wealth disparities: "entire sections of the ruling class are, by the advance of industry, precipitated into the proletariat, or are at least threatened in their conditions of existence."

And so on.

To be clear, Marx and Engels were wrong about some important things. To give just one example, their belief that global political struggle between the bourgeois and the proletariat would render irrelevant the prior divisions of nationality and religion has proved wildly and tragically inaccurate.

Likewise, the Manifesto's prescriptions were disastrous. There is a legitimate debate about the extent to which the totalitarian communist states of the 20th century were the logical culmination of the Marxist program or perversions of it by corrupt ruling elites that used the language of the proletarian vanguard to advance their own venal interests. I tend to take the former view, mostly because I think the test of any political idea is how it is actually implemented in the real world, but also because it is not difficult to see in the original Marxist programs the tendency towards totalitarianism. (Consider item number 6 in the Communist program as sketched by Marx and Engels: "Centralization of the means of communication and transport in the hands of the state.")

It is, therefore, understandable that many people--and especially those who themselves or whose family suffered the deprivations and persecutions of actual 20th century Communist regimes--would see in the record of Communism sufficient grounds for disdaining the Communist Manifesto as a source of any sort of wisdom. Understandable but regrettable, because Marx and Engels were in important respects astute observers of the actual functioning of capitalism. (To dissociate themselves from the Communists' affirmative political program, modern-day academic followers of Marx in the West often call themselves "Marxians" rather than "Marxists," though I suspect that the distinction is lost on Glenn Beck and his listeners.)

History has yet to prove Marx wrong in his core contention that capitalism would sow the seeds of its own destruction: For a couple of generations now, the advanced countries of the West have avoided class struggle by outsourcing proletarianism to the developing world, where wages that would be considered far below poverty level to us are regarded as a blessing. If Marx and Engels are right, this third world proletariat will eventually rise up. However, they may yet be proven wrong: Perhaps global prosperity can be achieved while bringing first-world living standards to all, although if so, it is hardly clear that the natural environment can sustain that level of consumption. Admittedly, that is more a Malthusian than a Marxian point, though one that Marx does not contradict.

As for our own politics, perhaps some good will come of the bizarre reaction against President Obama's speech: Provocative high school social studies teachers might ask students to compare and contrast Obama's message with that of the Communist Manifesto. But schoolteachers be forewarned: Doing so could get you into hot water with your principal and the parents in your district.

Posted by Mike Dorf

7 comments:

Paul Scott said...

This claim, like death panels and like the birth certificate "issue", just seems so absurd I don't know whether it is better to refute it or just ignore it. I guess swiftboat got legs even with Kerry ignoring it, so maybe it is best to refute, but even acknowledging the claim somehow seems wrong.

Ricky said...

I'm sure every single thing you say here is true, but I reckon you have to look at the criticism of Obama in phatic/illocutionary/performative terms rather than as reasoned discourse. The function of this criticism is to disrespect and delegitimize Obama publicly, which riles up disaffected mopes and makes them more likely to swallow policies that are manifestly against their actual self-interest and to support politicians who hold them in contempt. It actually *helps* that it makes no sense, because that quality tends to both immunize it from reasoned rejoinder and to give it an aura of virility and aggression, which of course draws weaklings in droves. I see it as a continuation of Bush the Younger's boundary-violating alpha-dog style of non-governance.

It also does a great job of moving the Overton window even further right. I think it's a very pure example of the emotional manipulation of resentful mopes.

michael a. livingston said...

I think the fear of an excessive liberal influence on education, as reflected in Obama's speech, are a good deal less irrational than your piece suggests. At my son's junior high school, the "problem solvers" were given the task of helping a valiant environmental organization develop a strategy for taming a rapacious, polluting corporation. What would be the response if, instead, their challenge was to help protect unborn children against a rapacious abortion provider? Liberal bias in education is not noticeable precisely because it is so pervasive.

Michael C. Dorf said...

Okay, Michael, I'll bite: What part of the Obama speech, linked in my post, exhibits what you term "liberal bias," much less socialism? Or is it your claim that there is a pervasive liberal bias in those public schools where the Obama speech was most vigorously opposed, schools in, say, Texas, where the official state biology standards are written to strongly suggest that there is actual live controversy over whether complex life forms on Earth evolved from simpler forms?

michael a. livingston said...

I think the speech ended up being mostly vapid, although it did plug the President's resume pretty aggressively. But there was no way to know in advance what he'd say, or might have said if not for the intervening uproar. Overall, he is by a substantial margin the most liberal and probably most partisan president in recent history, so it is hardly absurd for conservatives to want to deny him more air time I discuss this and other matters in my own most recent post

freefun0616 said...

酒店經紀人,
菲梵酒店經紀,
酒店經紀,
禮服酒店上班,
酒店小姐兼職,
便服酒店經紀,
酒店打工經紀,
制服酒店工作,
專業酒店經紀,
合法酒店經紀,
酒店暑假打工,
酒店寒假打工,
酒店經紀人,
菲梵酒店經紀,
酒店經紀,
禮服酒店上班,
酒店經紀人,
菲梵酒店經紀,
酒店經紀,
禮服酒店上班,
酒店小姐兼職,
便服酒店工作,
酒店打工經紀,
制服酒店經紀,
專業酒店經紀,
合法酒店經紀,
酒店暑假打工,
酒店寒假打工,
酒店經紀人,
菲梵酒店經紀,
酒店經紀,
禮服酒店上班,
酒店小姐兼職,
便服酒店工作,
酒店打工經紀,
制服酒店經紀,
酒店經紀,

,

狗熊克星 said...

我們提供融資服務需要的人及工商融資週轉不靈的朋友們融資手續簡便資料保密工商融資撥款快速值得您的信賴催眠心靈探索課程,催眠前世今生以催眠探索問題根源,圓滿你的人生現在法拍屋正熱現在進場買法拍屋正是時候台大翻譯社是國內最久等台北寵物認養俱樂部提供迷你瑪爾濟斯狗狗認養及迷你紅貴賓狗狗認養全部只要補貼飼料費就可以您需要寵物買賣歡迎來電洽詢

他們老闆還開一家翻譯社他們利用催眠的方式讓瑪爾濟斯睡著後來因為怕吵到他請看護馬麗亞抱他到房間睡此時外勞阿力來找她說人力仲介公司老闆今天要請客問他要不要去老闆公司最近需要工商融資因為資金週轉不靈整個公司的運作都受影想所以需要融資服務公司的廣告業務也不太好於是也的工作真是屋漏偏逢連夜雨老闆生病他之前買遠雄人壽公司所出的無上線終身醫療險因為忘了繳費被停止保單服務了。

法拍網提供線上全國法拍屋法拍屋流程,法拍代標,法拍屋知識,代標等服務今日銀樓 黃金價格, 國際 黃金價格 查詢, 買 賣黃金 走勢, 銀樓 黃金回收舊金回收, 食用消化酵素高之水果,幫助消化,吃完粽子可立即食用消化酵素含量高的木瓜提供 白蟻消毒蟑螂, 老鼠..等各類害蟲驅除的專業 除蟲公司來幫你吧。
我們提供融資服務需要的人及工商融資週轉不靈的朋友們融資手續簡便資料保密工商融資撥款快速值得您的信賴催眠心靈探索課程,催眠前世今生以催眠探索問題根源,圓滿你的人生現在法拍屋正熱現在進場買法拍屋正是時候台大翻譯社是國內最久等台北寵物認養俱樂部提供迷你瑪爾濟斯狗狗認養及迷你紅貴賓狗狗認養全部只要補貼飼料費就可以您需要寵物買賣歡迎來電洽詢

他們老闆還開一家翻譯社他們利用催眠的方式讓瑪爾濟斯睡著後來因為怕吵到他請看護馬麗亞抱他到房間睡此時外勞阿力來找她說人力仲介公司老闆今天要請客問他要不要去老闆公司最近需要工商融資因為資金週轉不靈整個公司的運作都受影想所以需要融資服務公司的廣告業務也不太好於是也的工作真是屋漏偏逢連夜雨老闆生病他之前買遠雄人壽公司所出的無上線終身醫療險因為忘了繳費被停止保單服務了。

法拍網提供線上全國法拍屋法拍屋流程,法拍代標,法拍屋知識,代標等服務今日銀樓 黃金價格, 國際 黃金價格 查詢, 買 賣黃金 走勢, 銀樓 黃金回收舊金回收, 食用消化酵素高之水果,幫助消化,吃完粽子可立即食用消化酵素含量高的木瓜提供 白蟻消毒蟑螂, 老鼠..等各類害蟲驅除的專業 除蟲公司來幫你吧。