Wednesday, July 29, 2009

An Alternative to Senator Specter's Notice Pleading Bill

In my latest FindLaw column, I examine Senator Specter's proposal to restore notice pleading in the federal courts. I describe the pros and cons of the proposal in general, and then point to a few drafting flaws. Here I'll put my money where my mouth is. With thanks to my fellow proceduralists in the legal academy and on the civil procedure listserve, and a special nod to Kevin Clermont (my colleague) and David Shapiro (who taught me civil procedure when I was a law student 22 years ago), below is my proposal:


To restore notice pleading in the federal courts.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

This Act may be cited as the ‘‘Notice Pleading Restoration Act of 2009’’.

Except as otherwise expressly provided by an Act of Congress or by an amendment to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure which takes effect after the date of enactment of this Act, a Federal court shall not deem a pleading inadequate under rule 8(a)(2) or rule 8(b)(1)(A) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, on the ground that such pleading is conclusory or implausible, except that a court may take judicial notice of the implausibility of a factual allegation. So long as the pleaded claim or defense provides fair notice of the nature of the claim or defense, and the allegations, if taken to be true, would support a legally sufficient claim or defense, a pleading satisfies the requirements of rule 8.

Posted by Mike Dorf


Joe said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Michael C. Dorf said...

In an earlier version of this post, I noted the incorrect link. In any event, it is now fixed.

AF said...

Would this statute preclude the following reasoning:

The complaint alleges X, which is not a valid claim under the applicable legal standard. While there may be a set of facts Y consistent with the complaint that would constitute a valid claim, that is not the most natural reading of the complaint. Hence the complaint is dismissed.

That strikes me as the basic reasoning of Twombly, though instead "not the most natural reading of the complaint" the Court said that the set of facts Y were "implausible."

Unknown said...

I assume the "implausibility" clause is intended to preserve the rule in Tyler v. Carter. I'm a bit concerned that as drafted, this language may be prone to abuse, but I can't think of anything that could substitute by "frivolity."

Anonymous said...




Trip Advisor said...

thanks for the link sir good work

jet said...

The issue claims X, which is not a real declare under the appropriate lawful conventional. While there may be a set of information Y constant with the issue that would represent a real declare, that is not the most organic studying of the issue. Hence the issue is ignored.

Unknown said...


Anonymous said...

I really think that one of the best articles is this one. It has everything. I needed this information to prove wrong my teacher. I knew this was happening. But my teacher did not agree with me. Now, he'll know I was right! Thank you!
family-estate |

Unknown said...

Wow, this post is pleasant, my younger sister is analyzing these things, so I am going to tell her. |

Unknown said...

coach outlet store online
michael kors outlet
jordan 4
prada shoes
louis vuitton handbags
timberland shoes
hollister pas cher
tod's sale
nhl jerseys wholesale
kate spade handbags
beats by dre
prada outlet
kate spade uk
prada handbags
ray ban
louis vuitton outlet
new balance shoes
burberry outlet
coach outlet
tods outlet
adidas wings
coach outlet online
toms shoes
foamposite gold
lacoste outlet
adidas shoes
christian louboutin
kate spade outlet
tiffany and co jewelry
michael kors canada
toms shoes outlet online
giuseppe zanotti outlet
kobe 9 elite
michael kors handbags
converse outlet
michael kors outlet
foamposite shoes
michael kors outlet

Unknown said...

cara mengobati penyakit wasir obat wasir herbal denature obat wasir ambeien herpes kelamin denature

Unknown said...

cara mengobati penyakit wasir obat wasir herbal denature obat wasir ambeien herpes kelamin denature

Unknown said...

Must say that overall I am really impressed with this blog. It is easy to see that you are passionate about your writing. If only I had your writing ability I look forward to more updates and will be returning. |

Unknown said...

kutil pada batang penis Pusat Obat herbal cara mengobati bintik kutil pada kelamin mengapa muncul bintik kutil pada kelamin cara mengobati kutil di sekitar penis kutil di sekitar alat kelamin pria obat kutil kelamin priacara mengobati kutil kelamin

Arjunane Denature said...

Obat kencing Nanah De Nature Obat Herbal obat Kutil Kelaminobat kanker payudara stadium 3 kanker serviks obat kanker serviks obat herbal kanker