Posts

Was Heller Based on an Inaccurate Quotation? Does it Matter?

On December 2, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Viramontes v. Cook County  on the following question: "Whether the Second and Fourteenth Amendments guarantee the right to possess AR-15 platform and similar semiautomatic rifles." The Seventh Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a challenge to Cook County Illinois's ban on assault rifles, relying on an earlier circuit court precedent that deemed such weapons indistinguishable from machine guns, which the Supreme Court declared proscribable in District of Columbia v. Heller . The Seventh Circuit decision is wobbly under SCOTUS precedent. Heller itself allows the outlawing of "weapons not typically possessed by law-abiding citizens for lawful purposes." The case appeared to use that language interchangeably with an inquiry into whether a class of weapons is "in common use" for those lawful purposes, and subsequent cases pretty clearly establish that "common use" is a threshold inquiry fo...

The Value of Getting Things Wrong: A Backhanded But Sincere Tribute to Richard Posner

Here on the blog on Monday, Professor Segall offered a moving tribute to Judge Richard Posner, who died last week. Professor Segall was personally close with Judge Posner, but I do not think that his affection biased him. Put differently, I agree with Professor Segall about the astoundingly impressive career of Judge Posner. As I have noted in several places, I regard Posner as one of the two most important U.S. judges never to sit on the U.S. Supreme Court, along with Judge Learned Hand. Given that Posner was also an incredibly prolific scholar, Posner might well be deemed to occupy the top spot. Having said that, in today's essay, I want to make what might seem like the critical point that Judge Posner was often wrong. I do so for the purpose of situating him as fundamentally a public intellectual. I'll begin with some illustrations. The first involves Posner's book Sex and Reason , which is probably best described as offering sociobiological explanations (the "reas...

The Anti-Corruption Agenda and the Pro-American Tax Man

How can the newly ascendant Democrats show that they truly heard voters' cries against America's corrupt, hyperrich, oligarchic class?  And how can they do so without triggering the uber-cautious (to the point of political malpractice ) Democratic establishment players like Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer?  One answer, perhaps surprisingly, is to make it clear that the days of unbridled tax evasion by billionaires will be over if Democrats win in 2028. In this very short column, I want to lay down a marker for future columns.  In those columns, I will expand on a simple argument: It is perhaps counterintuitive, but there is enormous value in a Democratic strategy of " fronting and centering " the deep injustice of Republicans' efforts to allow wealthy taxpayers to both evade and avoid taxes -- that is, to outright cheat and to game the political system to make cheating "legal in a technical sense." In the midst of the attempts by all sides to spin the...

There Will be Never Be Anyone Like Him Again: RIP Judge Richard Posner

An unusual thing happened on October 8, 2019, during the Supreme Court oral arguments in Bostock v. Clayton County and Altitude Express, Inc., v. Zarda . These cases raised the important questions whether sexual orientation discrimination and transgender discrimination were covered by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Neither case came from the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit but that did not stop Chief Justice Roberts from asking the plaintiffs’ attorney Pamela Karlan, a skilled litigator and Stanford Law Professor, the following question right out of the gate: How do you -- do you agree or disagree with Judge Posner's statement that the statute should be read to encompass sexual orientation discrimination 'to avoid placing the entire burden of updating old statutes on the legislative branch?' (quotation marks in the official Court transcript). The question was odd because Roberts was referring to an opinion Posner had written in a di...

Post-Stalinist Republicanism and the Urgent Need for Democrats to Be Bold

Six years ago today, it still seemed plausible that Donald Trump would soon get over his tantrum after losing his reelection bid and that he would in due course leave the White House without much more than a lot of grumbling and scores of failed lawsuits.  We know what did not happen next. I begin today's column with that walk down PTSD Lane to make clear that there is still the possibility of things going very much sideways between now and when the 120th Congress is scheduled to be sworn in at the beginning of January.  After a few days of unexpected docility last week, Trump has again started to make noises about election fraud.  Although those have thus far not caught fire even with his cultish supporters, recall that an unnamed Trump advisor in November 2020 assured everyone that Trump simply needed to process his grief and that all would be fine.  Things only grew worse from there.  There is also some possibility of House Republicans doing something crazy ...

Democratic Voters Deserve Leaders Who at a Bare Minimum Respect Them -- and Competence Would Also Be Nice

This week, the post-Blue Tsunami world launched with a resounding thud.  Fresh off a historic election that was driven in large part by the public's disgust with the Trump regime's incompetence and venality, along with a huge dose of anger about the war of choice in Iran that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth played a major role in starting -- and then botching miserably -- there was momentum at long last for Democrats to take action against a Trump minion by impeaching the testosterone-obsessed warmonger. But then eleven Democrats in the House failed to show up for a key vote to impeach Hegseth, allowing him to skate when only eight more votes would have prevented the impeachment from being shelved.  In my mind, I heard the unmistakable sound of sad trombones, soon drowned out by my anger at the Democratic leadership. Yes, people are not putting enough blame on the 211 Republicans who saved Hegseth (for now).  That there were not even a few Republicans (dozens of whom are ...

Incentivizing Running Up the Score

My latest Verdict column explains why it makes a difference whether Democrats win the Senate races in Alaska and Mississippi, even though the difference between 54, 55, and 56 Senate seats might seem inconsequential, given that 51 would get them a simple majority and any of those numbers is less than the 60 needed to break a filibuster and much less than the 67 needed to overcome a presidential veto. What I have to say also pertains to the importance of having won Michigan and thus undercuts the claim by future Dancing with the Stars performer Haley Stevens that the Democrats could have afforded to lose the Michigan Senate race. As I argue in the column, additional Senate votes matter for the Senate that will convene in January because they provide a cushion against Democratic defections and make it easier to form coalitions with defecting Republicans. Further, each additional Senate seat won in 2026 affects the number of Senators who assemble in January 2029 and January 2031, when o...

How Should SCOTUS Read one of the Few Provisions of Federal Law that Favors Habeas Petitioners?

Last week, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in  Guerrero v. Johnson . The case involves the proper interpretation of a provision of the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act (AEDPA), enacted in 1996, that limits the circumstances under which a person can successfully bring a federal court habeas corpus petition on the ground that their state court conviction or sentence was unconstitutional. This area of the law is maddeningly technical, but I shall try to make it accessible to non-specialists without dumbing it down too much. The relevant statutory provision ( 28 U.S.C. § 2244 ) generally forbids a person in state custody from bringing more than one federal habeas petition. Subsection (b)(2)(A) makes an exception if the petitioner brings a claim that wasn't the subject of a previous habeas petition if "the claim relies on a new rule of constitutional law, made retroactive to cases on collateral review by the Supreme Court, that was previously unavailable." T...

Does the Dobbs Leak Investigation Violate Separation of Powers?

Last week, The New York Times reported that the Department of Justice is aggressively investigating the 2022 leak of the Dobbs opinion, with subpoenas being issued to persons who worked at the Supreme Court at the relevant time (presumably including some people who still work there). The article includes the following passage: The Justice Department has the right to investigate any federal crime committed at the court, such as insider trading based on advance knowledge of a case outcome, said Michael C. Dorf, a constitutional law professor at Cornell. But if the leak does not amount to a crime, the investigation could violate the separation of powers that ensures the court’s independence, he said.  That could amount to “the executive branch harassing members of the judicial branch,” he said. Those quotations are accurate, and I stand by them, but they require a bit of elaboration. To begin, I do not see a separation of powers problem with a DOJ investigation of alleged conduct tha...