Tuesday, May 12, 2015

Cheating, Loyalty, and Willful Blindness

by Neil H. Buchanan

Yesterday, the National Football League announced its decision regarding how to punish various members of the New England Patriots organization, who had been found "more likely than not" to have engaged in a scheme to break an obscure (but surprisingly important) rule regarding the air pressure in footballs.  Because this is the NFL we are talking about, it was big news.  It also meant that the entire affair was being handled on all sides by some of the highest-priced legal talent on offer in this country.

Is there anything interesting to say about the whole affair?  Maybe.  My take on this story, for what it is worth, is that provides especially interesting insights into people's unwillingness to face reality, even when doing so need not cost them anything.

For those readers who have been only minimally following this admittedly trivial story (or, as sometimes happens, if you find yourself reading this blog post a few years from now, when so-called Deflategate will be but a vague memory), here is the basic story arc: After the conference championship game, won 45-7 by the Patriots and thus qualifying them for this year's Super Bowl (which they won), news broke that the Patriots had been using under-inflated footballs when they were on offense.  The other team in that game (the Indianapolis Colts) had complained to the referees, and sure enough, the balls were too squishy.

Although I am no longer in the habit of watching sports news in the morning, I happened to turn on ESPN the day the story made news.  Everyone's first question was: Wait, what do you mean the Patriots -- and only the Patriots -- were gaining an advantage from under-inflated footballs?  Don't the refs just have an inventory of balls and put them in play, changing the ball only when it needs to be wiped off in wet weather and so on?  It turns out that, in fact, the NFL allows each team to use its own set of balls while on offense, and the quarterback is allowed to prepare the balls in various ways (eliminating slickness by rubbing the ball with oil, for example), and setting the air pressure within a narrow range.  This means that, if the balls are doctored in ways not allowed by the rules, one team truly can get an advantage.  The NFL thus created a strong incentive to cheat.

Next question: Can this really matter all that much?  Most people in the U.S. have at least held a regulation-sized football, and they know that the balls need to be inflated in order to be kick-able, and to be aerodynamic when thrown.  During the first hour of ESPN's coverage of the story, people wondered if there was truly an advantage to having a ball inflated to 11.0 or 10.5 pounds per square inch (psi), as some of the Patriots' balls were, as opposed to the league minimum of 12.5 psi.  After all, balls that look to be unusable are obviously severely under-inflated, but does a pound or two matter?

ESPN brought in Mark Brunell, a retired NFL quarterback who played for 19 seasons in the league.  They handed him a properly inflated ball.  He grabbed it in his big hands, and he said something like, "Yeah, that feels normal."  Then they handed him an under-inflated ball.  It looked the same, but the moment he touched it, he said, "Whoa!  I'd love to play with this ball," or words very much to that effect.  The look on his face said it all.  This was not a minor detail.  Before the day was over, no one was questioning whether deflated balls were advantageous to the Patriots.

The NFL went into its hyper-corporate damage-control mode, hiring a BigLaw partner to conduct an investigation into whether there was any way that the deflation was non-deliberate, and if it was deliberate, whether there was a way to prove who did what, and when.  The big questions were whether the Patriots quarterback, Tom Brady, was behind it.  Or maybe the coach, Bill Belichick.  Or was it merely a bunch of underlings?

That report was issued last week.  As the Associated Press put it, the report "stopped barely short of calling the Patriots star quarterback a cheater."  The report concluded that he had been "at least generally aware" that the balls were being doctored.  The report exonerated the coach(es), finding evidence of only two employees having engaged in wrongdoing.  Some of Brady's claims were labeled "implausible," and all of the scientific explanations were rejected by the report.  The investigator noted that he "was hindered by the quarterback's refusal to provide his own emails, texts or phone records."

In short, this was big.  The cheating happened in an important game (and the evidence shows that this might have been happening for a year or more before that game), it was deliberate, and the quarterback either directed it or made it clear what he wanted, while the underlings provided plausible deniability.  The league agrees that it was big.  They have announced a four-game suspension at the begining of next season for Brady, as well as rather severe punishments (including lost high-round draft picks) for the team.  Brady will appeal.

What makes all of this interesting, of course, is that it brings the world back to the familiar overlap between law and sports, where regular people are suddenly confronted with the terms and standards that lawyers work with all the time.  People are now apparently confused about "more probable than not," for example, somehow imagining that this is a new or different category of not-really-culpable culpability.

It also puts front and center the notion of proportionality in sentencing, where people are debating the relative punishments of the Patriots compared to other examples of cheating in the NFL, as well as the much more serious cases of spousal abuse (Ray Rice of the Ravens) and child abuse (Adrian Peterson of the Vikings) that tarnished the NFL's image last season.

How does one compare punching one's fiancee in the face (and knocking her unconscious) to cheating in a championship game, in terms of the number of games that the offender should be suspended?  How do legislatures decide the relative punishments for battery versus fraud, or attempted murder versus identity theft?  Lawmakers are usually adrift when debating these matters, and so are football fans.

It should hardly be surprising that Patriots' fans immediately defended Brady.  If a reporter could find female Ravens fans willing to defend Rice after the horrifying video emerged of him punching his then-fiancee (with those fans relying on what amounted to an intuitive aversion to double jeopardy), it was not going to be difficult to find Patriots fans who would stand with Brady.  Jerry Seinfeld famously said that rooting interests in sports boil down to "cheering for laundry," where the guy who is wearing your team's laundry is a hero, even if he was a villain two games ago, when he wore the rival team's laundry.  I have a friend who absolutely hated Deion Sanders until Sanders played briefly for the 49ers, at which point Sanders became "actually not that bad a guy."  (No, he really is that bad.)

For some reason, I am not able to summon the blind loyalty that makes people "real fans."  Perhaps I am too embarrassed from having, in my youth, defended the infamous Ohio State coach Woody Hayes through thick and thin.  A few years after Hayes was gone, an academic scandal at Ohio State was so upsetting to me that I actually did the unthinkable, changing rooting interests from Ohio State to Michigan.

Which is why this whole Tom Brady thing is especially interesting to me.  Here is how much I like Tom Brady: He has caused me to root for a Boston-based team.  Brady's Michigan diploma (after what was, in fact, a rather average playing career for the Wolverines) caused me to love Tom Brady, and to love him so much that I was able to ignore the reality that his fan base is a bunch of people who love the Red Sox.

So, does that mean that I should (or, at least, would) deny that Brady did anything wrong?  Why not try a little Nixonian "Everyone does it, but he got caught" logic?  After all, in full pander mode, New Jersey governor Chris Christie has defended Brady, on the theory that people like to go after glamorous, rich people.  Yes, Christie's defense of Brady is uniquely delicious, because both he and Brady are guilty of -- at the very least -- setting up underlings to do their dirty work.  Surely, however, there are other ways to minimize what happened here.

At the beginning of this post, I referred to "people's unwillingness to face reality, even when doing so need not cost them anything."  In some sense, the Patriots fans who are defending Brady have something to lose by admitting that their hero is a cheater.  NFL fans (and sports fans in general) are known to find their identities in their loyalties to their teams, such that admitting anything bad is a personal betrayal.  That I happen no longer to be capable of empathizing with that type of emotional commitment does not make it any less important to those fans.

This, however, brings me to my major question: Why does the Patriots organization, in particular its owner Robert Kraft, not take this as an opportunity to finesse the public relations, so that they can take responsibility and come out looking like winners?  Initially, it looked like that was their plan.  When the punishments were announced, however, Kraft went nuts, saying (among other ridiculous things) that the "one-sided investigation" resulted in a punishment that "was based completely on circumstantial rather than hard or conclusive evidence."  Such circumstantial evidence involved, among other things, one of the low-level Patriots employees walking into a bathroom with the footballs, after they had been inspected, and then emerging only after enough time had elapsed to deflate the footballs.

Surely, Kraft (or his lawyers) understand that circumstantial evidence can be damning.  Therefore, they must have consciously decided to respond to the punishment by saying things that are, by design, pure bluster.  But why?  To mollify their fans?  There is no way the fans will abandon the team.  To mollify Brady?  Why not just say, "The Patriots organization has great affection and loyalty to Tom Brady.  We believe him when he tells us that he is innocent, but the league's processes have played out, and we all agree to move forward together.  The important thing is to rededicate ourselves to the greatness that is the Patriots' tradition."  This is not rocket science.

There is surely a way to play this out publicly, in a way that does not make the Patriots look worse than they already look.  There have to be ways to say, "For the good of the game, we are taking our lumps and moving forward."  Kraft, instead, is going with the approach that guarantees that the Patriots' legacy will be tainted, and he is going to all but guarantee greater scrutiny and (should future cases of cheating arise) harsher penalties in the future.

Of course, in the recent past I have questioned the business prowess of NFL owners, so maybe I should not be surprised.  But while one expects willful blindness from fans, I would not have thought that public displays of loyalty from an NFL team and its owner would need to be so absurd.

12 comments:

Joe said...

I have seen people already treat this as if this was an action by the state or something, even bringing up Fifth Amendment rights.

I simply haven't spent the time to go into the weeds here though to the degree it matters lean toward thinking there is enough of a clear breach of the rules for punishment. And, especially since this is not the first time for the Pats at the breaking the rules rodeo, I have little sympathy.

Admit not to be a Pats fan, but Super Bowl champs and all, this sort of clown show activity really is distasteful. And, it is a bad symbol of conduct. Private actions often are important here. It sends a message and influences culture.

I think this case is of some importance (and if we want to talk about how the league might be treating it badly, fine -- PTB screw-ups matter too) and not just as a way to say "ball" a lot as if we are Beavis and Butthead.

ghkozen said...

I have to say, as a Bills fan, I love that we won't have to play against the man in week 2.

Besides that, this whole process and suspension seems like a joke to me. I remember reading the Rams and the Vikings violated the same section of the rules last year by heating balls, and all they got was a friendly reminder. I don't see why there was such vastly different punishments for violating the same provision.

Plus, lets be honest, it's not like the Colts would have won that game if the balls were fully inflated.

Shag from Brookline said...

Here's the part of the story that should get more attention:

"FOXBOROUGH, Mass., May 11 (UPI) — The New England Patriots announced that 'employees John Jastremski and James McNally have been indefinitely suspended without pay by the club, effective on May 6th,' ...."

Team loyalty?

And the story goes on to say that the NFL's position is that these employees cannot be reinstated by the Patriots without League approval.

The Patriots protect themselves with these suspensions and the NFL protects itself with its position on reinstatement. Who speaks for these employees? Did they deflate on their own? Maybe they should inflate by whistleblowing with some good legal advice - and perhaps a literary agent.

Joe said...

Yes, I am more concerned about those employees than Tom Brady, just like I am more concerned about the average convicted criminal than Barry Bonds. Even if the average criminal here had some sports in her background:

http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/i-team/beating-ped-rap-rich-famous-thomas-article-1.2206267

Shag from Brookline said...

The comedy continues with the response of the Patriots via their lawyers, which refers (inter alia, ha ha) to the meaning of "deflator" as used by the Patriots' middle aged ball boy as relating to his attempts at losing his weight, not that of the footballs' psi.

Perhaps the NFL should take "control" of the footballs used in a game. (In major league baseball, umpires can throw out balls that are scuffed, etc.) Otherwise, in televising a game there will be more shots following footballs on and off the field of play.

I wonder how the centers feel about the psi, especially with their long snaps. I understand a different set of footballs is used by a team for punting, field goals, etc. Surely centers' experiences could be relevant.

mr ayoub said...

Am here to say good things about dr olori what this great spell caster done for me. My Name is ayoub Adam, i never believe in spell casting, until when i was was tempted to try it.. i and my wife have been having a lot of problem living together, he will always not make me happy because he have fallen in love with another man outside our relationship, i tried my best to make sure that my husband leave this woman but the more i talk to him the more he makes me fell sad, so my marriage was falling leading to divorce because he no longer gives me attention. so with all this pain and agony, i decided to contact this spell caster DR olori to see if things can work out between me and my wife again. this spell caster DR olori told me that my husband is really under a great spell that he have been charm by some magic, so he told me that he was going to make all things normal again. he went ahead and cast the the spell for me, after 2 days of casting the spell my husband changed completely he came apologizing saying the way he treated me that he was not himself, i really thank you DR olori for bringing back my wife to me i want you all to contact him for those who are having any problem related to marriage issue and relationship problem he will solve it for you. his mail here drolorispelltemple@outlook.com OR drolorispiritualtemple@gmail.com OR contact him through his website http://drolorispelltemple@outlook.com
you can call the great man on +2349036357575
He cast spells for different purposes like
(1) If you want your ex back.
(2) if you always have bad dream
(3) You want to be promoted in your office.
(4) If you want a child.
(5) You want to be rich.
(6) HIV/AIDS CURE
(7) You want to tie your husband/wife to be yours forever.

Nicholas Emily said...

Am here to testify what this great spell caster done for me. My Name is NICHOLAS EMILY, i never believe in spell casting, until when i was was tempted to try it.. i and my husband have been having a lot of problem living together, he will always not make me happy because he have fallen in love with another lady outside our relationship, i tried my best to make sure that my husband leave this woman but the more i talk to him the more he makes me fell sad, so my marriage was falling leading to divorce because he no longer gives me attention. so with all this pain and agony, i decided to contact this spell caster DR OGBIDI to see if things can work out between me and my husband again. this spell caster DR OGBIDI told me that my husband is really under a great spell that he have been charm by some magic, so he told me that he was going to make all things normal again. he went ahead and cast the the spell for me, after 2 days of casting the spell my husband changed completely he came apologizing saying the way he treated me that he was not himself, i really thank you DR OGBIDI for bringing back my husband to me i want you all to contact him for those who are having any problem related to marriage issue and relationship problem he will solve it for you. his mail here DROGBIDISOLUTIONHOME@GMAIL.COM OR DROGBIDISOLUTIONHOME@YAHOO.CO.UK OR contact him through his website http://drogbidisolutionhome.webs.com/
you can call the great man on +2347050203191.
He cast spells for different purposes like
(1) If you want your ex back.
(2) if you always have bad dream
(3) You want to be promoted in your office.
(4) If you want a child.
(5) You want to be rich.
(6) HIV/AIDS CURE
(7) You want to tie your husband/wife to be yours forever.

Stace Bruno said...

How i got my boyfriend back.Am Stacey Bruno by name I never believed in love spells or magic until I met this spell caster once when i went to see my friend in Indian this year on a business summit. I meant a man who's name is Dr ATILA he is really powerful and could help cast spells to bring back one's gone, lost, misbehaving lover and magic money spell or spell for a good job or luck spell .I'm now happy & a living testimony cos the man i had wanted to marry left me 5 weeks before our wedding and my life was upside down cos our relationship has been on for 3years. I really loved him, but his mother was against us and he had no good paying job. So when i met this spell caster, i told him what happened and explained the situation of things to him. At first i was undecided,skeptical and doubtful, but i just gave it a try. And in 7 days when i returned to Canada, my boyfriend (now husband) called me by himself and came to me apologizing that everything had been settled with his mom and family and he got a new job interview so we should get married. I didn't believe it cos the Dr ATILA only asked for my name and my boyfriends name and all i wanted him to do. Well we are happily married now and we are expecting our little kid, and my husband also got the new job and our lives became much better. His email is: atilahealinghome@yahoo.com

Jones Anna said...

My Name is ANNA, From United state. I wish to share my testimonies with the general public about what this man called DR OGUDU has just done for me , this man has just brought back my lost Ex husband to me with his great spell, I was married to this man called Steven we were together for a long time and we loved our self’s but when I was unable to give him a child for 2 years he left me and told me he can’t continue anymore then I was now looking for ways to get him back until a friend of mine told me about this man and gave his contact email (OGUDUSPELLCAST@GMAIL.COM) then you won't believe this when I contacted this man on my problems he prepared this spell portion and bring my lost husband back, and after a month I miss my month and go for a test and the result stated am pregnant am happy today am a mother of a baby girl, thank you once again the great DR OGUDU for what you have done for me, if you are out there passing through any of this problems listed below:
1) If you want your ex back.
(2) if you always have bad dreams.
(3) You want to be promoted in your office.
(4) You want women/men to run after you.
(5) If you want a child.
(6) You want to be rich.
(7) You want to tie your husband/wife to be
yours forever.CALL HIS MOBILE LINE +2348106058254

Stace Bruno said...

How i got my boyfriend back.Am Stacey Bruno by name I never believed in love spells or magic until I met this spell caster once when i went to see my friend in Indian this year on a business summit. I meant a man who's name is Dr ATILA he is really powerful and could help cast spells to bring back one's gone, lost, misbehaving lover and magic money spell or spell for a good job or luck spell .I'm now happy & a living testimony cos the man i had wanted to marry left me 5 weeks before our wedding and my life was upside down cos our relationship has been on for 3years. I really loved him, but his mother was against us and he had no good paying job. So when i met this spell caster, i told him what happened and explained the situation of things to him. At first i was undecided,skeptical and doubtful, but i just gave it a try. And in 7 days when i returned to Canada, my boyfriend (now husband) called me by himself and came to me apologizing that everything had been settled with his mom and family and he got a new job interview so we should get married. I didn't believe it cos the Dr ATILA only asked for my name and my boyfriends name and all i wanted him to do. Well we are happily married now and we are expecting our little kid, and my husband also got the new job and our lives became much better. His email is: atilahealinghome@yahoo.com

Gift Eben said...

This is a very joyful day of my life because of the help Dr.Aikobaya has rendered to me by helping me get my ex husband back with his magic and love spell. i was married for 6 years and it was so terrible because my husband was really cheating on me and was seeking for a divorce but when i came across Dr.Aikobaya email on the internet on how he help so many people to get their ex back and help fixing relationship.and make people to be happy in their relationship. i explained my situation to him and then seek his help but to my greatest surprise he told me that he will help me with my case and here i am now celebrating because my Husband has change totally for good. He always want to be by me and can not do anything without my present. i am really enjoying my marriage, what a great celebration. i will keep on testifying on the internet because Dr.Aikobaya is truly a real spell caster. DO YOU NEED HELP THEN CONTACT DOCTOR Dr.Aikobaya NOW VIA EMAIL: aikobaya24hourslovespell@gmail.com

Lisa silvia said...


!!! “LOVE is the key to LIFE”. !!!

At last my happiness has been restored by a Man named Dr great ,, my name is Lisa Buckley I want every one on this site or forum to join me thank this Dr great for what he just did for me and my kids. my story goes like this I was married to my husband for 5 years we were living happily together for this years and not until he traveled to Italy for a business trip where he met this prostitute who be witched he to hate me and the kids and love her only so when my husband came back from the trip he said he does not want to see me and my kids again so he drove us out of the house and he was now going to Italy for to see that other woman. so I and my kids were now so frustrated and I was just staying with my mum and I was not be treating good because my mama got married to another man when my after my daddy death so the man she got married to was not treating I and my kids well so I was so confuse and I was searching for a way to get my husband back to me and my kids so one day as I was browsing on my computer I saw a testimony about this MAN Dr great of greatpowerspelltemple@gmail.com shared on the internet by a lady and it impress me too so I also think of give it a try at first a was scared by when I think of what me and my kids are passing through so I contact him and he told me to stay calm for just two days that my husband shall be restored to me and to my best surprise I received a call from my husband on the second day asking after the kids and I called Dr great and he said your problems are solved my child so this was how I get my family back after a long stress of brake up by an evil lady so with all this help from Dr great of greatpowerspelltemple@gmail.com I want you all on this forum to join me to say a huge thanks to Dr great and I will also advice for any one in such or similar problems or any kind of problems should also contact him for help.website address: http://greatpowerspelltemple...