Saturday, July 06, 2013

When Should Whistle-Blowers Be Entitled to Asylum? Snowden and Beyond

By Mike Dorf

The news that Venezuela and Bolivia have offered Edward Snowden asylum could moot the question of whether Snowden is legally entitled to asylum under international law.  If Snowden accepts one of the offers and manages to get himself to Venezuela or Bolivia (or perhaps Nicaragua, which is also apparently toying with an asylum offer), then it will be up to the Venezuelan or Bolivian authorities to determine whether he is actually legally entitled to it--and presumably the offer of asylum reflects the conclusion by the respective governments either that Snowden is entitled to asylum or that they don't care whether he is entitled to asylum because granting it is a way to poke the Yankee imperialists in the eye (or perhaps both).

The legal issues raised by Snowden's asylum requests are quite interesting and have implications beyond his case.  Various signatories to the UN Convention and Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees implement the treaty in slightly different ways, but American law is fairly typical.  It treats an asylum applicant as eligible if he or she establishes that he or she has a "well-founded fear of persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion."

A Washington Post article that appeared last month does a generally excellent job of running down the arguments for and against refugee status for Snowden but, in my view, takes a wrong turn in suggesting that his best argument would develop a claim that whistleblowers count as a "particular social group" that is subject to persecution.  As I read the case law in the U.S. and elsewhere, the "particular social group" category applies to groups that are analogous to racial, religious and nationality-based groups.  For example, people fleeing countries where gay people are persecuted can argue that sexual orientation defines a particular social group.  Whistle-blowers, by contrast, are people who have engaged in a particular form of conduct, although I acknowledge that conduct can be linked to social group membership, as with sexual orientation and religion.

In any event, the better argument, it seems to me, is that prosecution for whistle-blowing is--at least sometimes--"persecution on account of . . . political opinion."  But don't take my word for it.  The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has a long line of cases--typefied by Baghdasaryan v. Holder--in which people who were persecuted by government authorities in retaliation for their exposure of government corruption or other vices were found eligible for asylum.  In none of these cases was it necessary for the asylum seeker to establish that whistle-blowers are a particular social group within the meaning of the asylum statute.

To be sure, whistle-blowers must prove that they are being persecuted, and prosecution for revelation of classified information is not per se persecution.  But distinguishing between a prosecution motivated by legitimate government interests in maintaining state secrets and one that simply seeks to retaliate against someone who has exposed wrongdoing is a normatively laden task.  Suppose that Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn faced charges in the Soviet Union for disclosing state secrets in his books on the gulag.  Even if his conduct clearly violated laws forbidding such disclosures by former prisoners, is there any doubt that he would have been entitled to refugee status if he managed to escape to the United States or some other sympathetic country?  Would the subjective intentions of Brezhnev and other Soviet officials have mattered?  Even if they really only were concerned about preserving state secrets rather than punishing Solzhenitsyn for the expression of his opinion, so what?  One might reasonably think that prosecution for revealing gross abuses of human rights is virtually per se persecution on the basis of political opinion.

And there's the rub.  To much of the world, the electronic eavesdropping programs that Snowden revealed do indeed look like a gross abuse of human rights, even if not an abuse in the same category as the Soviet gulag.  Accordingly, if one accepts the premise that Snowden brought to light some very serious government misconduct, then his asylum claim is non-frivolous.

10 comments:

奇堡比 said...

新女性徵信
外遇調查站
鴻海徵信
亞洲徵信
非凡徵信社
鳳凰徵信社
中華新女性徵信社
全國新女性徵信社
全省女人徵信有限公司
私家偵探超優網
女人感情會館-婚姻感情挽回徵信
女子偵探徵信網
女子國際徵信
外遇抓姦偵探社
女子徵信社
女人國際徵信
女子徵信社
台中縣徵信商業同業公會
成功科技器材
女人國際徵信社
女人國際徵信
三立徵信社-外遇
女人國際徵信
女人國際徵信
大同女人徵信聯盟
晚晴徵信

obat herbal said...

keluar nanah dari kemaluan wanita cara mengobati kemaluan keluar nanah mengobati kemaluan keluar nanah obat herbal kencing nanah

Guo Guo said...

guowenhao20150326
coach outlet store online
michael kors outlet
jordan 4
prada shoes
louis vuitton handbags
timberland shoes
hollister pas cher
tod's sale
nhl jerseys wholesale
kate spade handbags
beats by dre
prada outlet
kate spade uk
prada handbags
ray ban
louis vuitton outlet
abercrombie
new balance shoes
burberry outlet
coach outlet
tods outlet
adidas wings
coach outlet online
toms shoes
foamposite gold
lacoste outlet
adidas shoes
christian louboutin
kate spade outlet
tiffany and co jewelry
michael kors canada
toms shoes outlet online
lululemon
giuseppe zanotti outlet
kobe 9 elite
michael kors handbags
converse outlet
michael kors outlet
foamposite shoes
michael kors outlet

wasirdenature said...

Pusat Obat herbal mengapa ada bercak nanah di celana penis keluar cairan nanah cara mengobati penis keluar nanah kencing nanah denature nanah keluar dari kemaluan

herbal medicine said...

Pusat Obat herbal mengapa ada bercak nanah di celana penis keluar cairan nanah cara mengobati penis keluar nanah kencing nanah denature nanah keluar dari kemaluan

obat herbal said...

Pusat Obat herbal mengapa ada bercak nanah di celana penis keluar cairan nanah cara mengobati penis keluar nanah kencing nanah denature nanah keluar dari kemaluan

lionelmessi10 said...

alat kelamin pria keluar nanah obat penyakit gonore cairan nanah keluar dari alat kelamin obat gonore obat herbal kencing nanah obat kencing nanah di apotik apa penyebab penyakit herpes itu obat kencing nanah

Bambang Wisanggeni said...

OBAT AMBEIEN HERBAL DI APOTIK
OBAT HERBAL UNTUK GEJALA GEJALA SAKIT AMBEIEN
OBAT WASIR HERBAL YANG PALING MANJUR
OBAT AMBEIEN MANJUR OBAT AMBEIEN BIASA
OBAT WASIR HERBAL DI APOTIK
OBAT AMBEIEN HERBAL DI APOTIK
OBAT KENCING KELUAR NANAH
KENAPA KEnCING BERDARAH

Herbal de nature said...

BAGAIMANA CARA MENGOBATI KUTIL KELAMIN TANPA KE DOKTER
Obat kutil di sekitar kemaluan dan anus
obat ampuh untuk menghilangkan kutil
obat herbal untuk kutil pada kelamin
reseller produk de nature
obat kutil kelamin yang ampuh
obat alami untuk menyembuhkan kutil kelamin
obat herbal untuk kutil di kemaluan
cara mengobati kutil pada kemaluan
OBAT PENYAKIT GONORE
obat kutil kelamin tradisional
obat kutil kelamin tradisional
herbal penyakit kelamin
OBAT HERBAL UNTUK KENCING NANAH
BAGAIMANA MENGOBATI GONORE ATAU KENCING NANAH
OBAT HERBAL UNTUK KUTIL KELAMIN
OBAT KUTIL KELAMIN ATAU KONDILOMA AKUMINATA
obat herbal untuk bintik kutil di kemaluan
BAGAIMANA CARA MENGOBATI KUTIL DI KEMALUAN
gejala kutil kelamin dan cara mengobatinya
MENJUAL OBAT KENCING NANAH HERBAL YANG AMPUH
Obat Alami Ampuh Sipilis Paling Manjur
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tradisional
OBAT AMBEYEN HERBAL YANG AMAN UNTUK IBU HAMIL DAN IBU MENYUSUI
OBAT WASIR HERBAL YANG SUDAH TERBUKTI MANJUR DAN AMAN
OBAT KENCING NANAH HERBAL YANG SUDAH TERBUKTI MANJUR DAN AMAN
Bagaimana mengobati kutil di kemaluan dengan cara herbal

obat herbal said...

Obat kencing Nanah De Nature Obat Herbal obat Kutil Kelaminobat kutil kelamin dan kutil kelamin dan kutil di kemaluan dan kutil di sekitar kemaluan dan obat kutil di kemaluan dan obat kutil kelamin di apotik dan kutil pada kemaluan pria dan obat herbal kutil kelamin dan obat kutil di sekitar kemaluan dan muncul bintik kutil pada kelamin dan obat ampuh menghilangkan kutil kelamin dan obat kutil di kemaluan merupakan solusi pengobatan herbal dari denature indonesia