Wednesday, July 10, 2013

Can the Sixth Amendment Protect With the Jury in the Dark About Sentences?

By Sherry F. Colb

In my Verdict column for this week, I discuss the case of Alleyne v. United States. In Alleyne, the Supreme Court recently held that under the Sixth Amendment right to jury trial, a criminal statute may not raise the mandatory minimum sentence on the basis of a fact-findings by the judge in the case.  In my column, I discuss the appealing features of Justice Thomas's majority opinion so holding, but I ultimately conclude (spoiler alert!) that Chief Justice Roberts's dissenting opinion is more compelling.

In this post, I want to explore an assumed feature of the Sixth Amendment jury trial right jurisprudence -- that this right protects criminal defendants by requiring that juries rather than judges do the fact-finding that  exposes defendants to higher sentencing ranges, at both the high and low ends of the range.  Here is my question about this assumption:  Might it be difficult for the jury to really do this protective job without knowing what punishment (or sentencing range) is associated with a particular crime?

This question is inspired, somewhat indirectly, by a case from more than ten years ago in which a man named Ed Rosenthal stood trial in federal court for cultivating marijuana.  Then, like now, federal law prohibited the cultivation of marijuana, even when the purpose of such cultivation was to provide medicine for people suffering from nausea, wasting, glaucoma, and other conditions for which mairjuana provides some relief.  In California at the time, also like now, California state law authorized the cultivation and sale of marijuana for medicinal purposes.  This state law regime, however, did not and does not alter the federal ban.  Essentially, what we had then and have now is an activity that is legal and regulated under state law in California but which is a criminal offense under federal law.

At his federal criminal trial, the jury found Rosenthal guilty of offenses surrounding his cultivation of marijuana, crimes that carried a mandatory minimum sentence of five years imprisonment.  The jury had no idea when it found Rosenthal guilty that his marijuana cultivation had occurred for medicinal purposes and that he had acted as an agent of Oakland under California's own regulation of medical marijuana production.  After the trial, when  the jury learned of these facts, its members expressed outrage.  Had they known these facts, they said, they never would have convicted.

I wrote about the Rosenthal case here, and I have also written about jury nullification, here (among other places).  Nullification was at issue in Rosenthal's case because under federal law, the fact that someone was growing marijuana for medicinal purposes is legally irrelevant, since there is no such recognized federal defense for cultivating marijuana.  Therefore, if the jury had acquitted on the basis of this fact -- as various members suggested they would have done -- they would have been engaged in jury nullification, the practice of finding a criminal defendant not guilty of an offense despite the jury's belief that there was proof beyond a reasonable doubt of each fact making up a legal element of that offense.

Rosenthal's case came to my mind here because the jury was fully empowered to find every fact that made up a component of the offense at issue under federal law, and it did so before the judge was in a position to impose the corresponding sentence on the basis of those factual findings.  Nonetheless, members of the jury were in the dark about facts that -- were they known to the jury -- might have altered its choice of verdict.

One response to this concern is to say that the jury has no right to information that is legally irrelevant to an offense.  Were we discussing a different sort of criminal case, moreover, a person quite sympathetic to Rosenthal's plight might appreciate the irrelevance of some facts that the jury would like to know.  Imagine, for example, that we were living in earlier times when white juries were unwilling to convict a white defendant of the murder of an African American victim.  Imagine further that the jury in a particular case was somehow kept ignorant of the fact that the victim in a given case was African American, an unlikely state of affairs, to be sure, but bear with me.  The jury convicts but then learns that the victim was African American and expresses outrage at the concealment of this information, indicating that had it known of the victim's race, it would have acquitted.  Clearly, few of us would feel much sympathy for the defendant's right to be protected from a criminal law that holds a victim's race to be legally irrelevant, right?

But sentences seem potentially different from legally irrelevant facts.  If federal law holds, for example, that medical marijuana is legally equivalent to recreational marijuana, then perhaps it is fair to have kept Rosenthal's reason for growing marijauana from the jury.  What is wrong is not so much what the jury knows but, rather, the substantive content of federal criminal law here.  But can the same be said about the penalty?

When the jury reviews the evidence, we trust the jury to make sure that a defendant is not convicted of an offense and then sentenced to the associated punishment for that offense unless and until the jury finds any and all facts that trigger application of the sentence or sentencing range that goes with the crime in question.  Yet one of the facts that just about every juror would be very interested in knowing at the time of bringing back a conviction for a crime is what will happen to the defendant if we say that he or she is guilty?

Unlike questions about legally irrelevant features of a criminal offense, moreover, the associated penalty is arguably a question to which that the jury ought to know the answer.  After all, what makes the jury's fact-finding more protective than a judge's is, presumably, that jurors are not part of the system and are able to be critical of the system in ways that a judge or the legislature might not be.  A judge, for example, might be so used to sentencing people to prison time that the question of proportionality seems barely to register, and the legislature may actually have a strong incentive to impose disproportionate penalties for crimes so they can say they are "tough on crime" at election time.  But the jury may be able to see the defendant as an individual and thus to protect him or her from an overreaching government.

One sort of overreaching, of course, is the failure to mount a sufficiently strong case to prove guilt beyond any reasonable doubt, and the Sixth Amendment properly aims at addressing that concern.  But another sort of overreaching is in the imposition of draconian penalties.  And without having any idea what those penalties (or what the lower or upper end of the ranges of those penalties) might be, it can perhaps be said that the jury is trying the facts in something of a factual vacuum.

Now the predictable response may be that there is little difference between the nullification that I condemn above and the penalty nullification that I seem to be praising as a potentially valuable feature of the Sixth Amendment jury trial right.  After all, just as the legislature gets to decide what is a crime and what is not (and whether some particular fact does or does not qualify as a defense for that crime), so then does the legislature get to decide what penalties (or ranges of penalties) attach to those crimes:  these judgments, in other words, are legal rather than factual judgments, and the jury is not entitled to make legal judgments.

Yet I think, at least tentatively, that facts about the crime that are legally irrelevant are different from facts about the punishment that follows.  The legally irrelevant facts about the crime are facts that the legislature has decided are neither aggravating nor mitigating, and keeping them from the jury prevents the jury from second-guessing the definition of the crime.  Punishments, however, and punishment ranges, are not legally irrelevant per se -- after all, juries do sometimes play a role in sentencing (for example, in many capital cases).  It accordingly might better serve the Sixth Amendment right if juries were able not only to determine whether each factual predicate were properly met but also to at least opine on sentencing as well, maybe by letting the judge know that if the range is 2-10 years, that they believe she should err on the side of leniency.

29 comments:

Paul Scott said...

I could not find a dissenting opinion by Roberts. Are you referring to Alito's or Kennedy's dissent?
Thanks.

Paul Scott said...

Nevermind. The dissent listed as Kennedy's by Justicia is, in fact, Roberts'

pvineman1 said...

The Zimmerman trial might provide further support for your argument that the jury should be advised of the potential sentence faced by a defendant.

If the jurors in that case were aware that Zimmerman would be sentenced to decades in prison if they convicted him of the lesser included offense of manslaughter, I doubt that they would return a guilty verdict.



lylejones said...

It's a shame that juries are not informed about potential sentences--however, the prosecutor lobby will never allow it. They know good and well that a jury would acquit rather than send someone to prison for years over enough cocaine for themselves and a date.

Shalaka Vaidya said...

Thank you for giving the information. Really this blog is very informative.
florida criminal lawyer

Camelia Alyka said...

The jury had no idea when it found Rosenthal guilty that his marijuana cultivation had occurred for guilty of offenses surrounding his cultivation of marijuana, crimes that carried a mandatory minimum sentence of five years imprisonment. cream walet crystal x dhc eyelash tonic pembesar payudara medicinal purposes and that he had acted as an agent of Oakland under California's own regulation of medical marijuana production.

Frank Harper said...

I agree with your Blog and I will be back to analyze it more in the future so please keep up your work. Assar Poker : Number One Slot : Pixar Casino

DANNY JACKMAN said...

You have to start giving us those recipes because I'm totally drooling all over the place here. Sub Poker : Panthar Poker : King Poker Choice : Groom Poker : Pro Poker Mania : Luxury Slot : Summer Slot : Temple Slot : Golden Night Casino : Lucky One Casino : Stud Casino Room : Typical Gambling

jorden jems said...

I thought it was going to be some boring old post, but it really compensated for my time. I will post a link to this page on my blog. 7game slot : Lenny casino game : palace casino wheel : Maxino casino games : 77vegas casino : 88poker games : sky pokernet : silver poker news : online poker kings : free win pokies : casino memory : ezine poker

奇堡比 said...

新女性徵信
外遇調查站
鴻海徵信
亞洲徵信
非凡徵信社
鳳凰徵信社
中華新女性徵信社
全國新女性徵信社
全省女人徵信有限公司
私家偵探超優網
女人感情會館-婚姻感情挽回徵信
女子偵探徵信網
女子國際徵信
外遇抓姦偵探社
女子徵信社
女人國際徵信
女子徵信社
台中縣徵信商業同業公會
成功科技器材
女人國際徵信社
女人國際徵信
三立徵信社-外遇
女人國際徵信
女人國際徵信
大同女人徵信聯盟
晚晴徵信

Helena Franciska said...

I recently found the application well written and then quickly logical. I must personally we understand the time you devote to create the application. This is also important to talk about the facts on legitimate numbers. produk kecantikan korea | perawatan wajah murah | agen produk kecantikan | obat herbal asma | happy call asli lejel | lulur susu domba asli | masker rambut emas | minuman pelangsing wmp | kaminomoto shampoo |

Camelia Alyka said...

It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. kadounikmurah | Pembesar Payudara Herbal | Pembesar Payudara permanent | terapi anak autis | matahari bunda | crystal x asli | hiasan dinding | jam dinding unik | jam dinding minimalis

Toko Fashion Kita said...

Until I found this concept very useful and article. I was actually captured with the piece of resources you have got here. The your message is very special is a good factor to attract more visitors to read your site.
serum rambut
serum rambut rontok
kios cantik sehat
kosmetik
kosmetik online shop
kosmetik online
kios kitchen set
kitchen set murah
kitchen set murah jakarta

amine lahragui said...


thanks so much for that great blog and thanks also for accepting my links thanks
طريقة عمل الدونات طريقة عمل البان كيك طريقة عمل الكنافة طريقة عمل البسبوسة طريقة عمل الكيك طريقة عمل عجينة البيتزا فوائد القرفه
thanks so much i like very so much your post
فوائد الحلبة فوائد الزنجبيل فوائد الرمان فوائد زيت السمسم علاج البواسير فوائد البصل فوائد اليانسون فوائد الكركم فوائد الزعتر قصص جحا تعريف الحب علامات الحمل

Citra Beauty Shop said...

I recently found the application well written and then quickly logical. I must personally we understand the time you devote to create the application. This is also important to talk about the facts on legitimate numbers. http://creamwaletgold.arenshi.com/ http://creamtemulawak.arenshi.com/

aminos lahragui said...


thanks so much i like very so much your post
حلى الاوريو الفطر الهندي صور تورته حلى قهوه طريقة عمل السينابون طريقة عمل بلح الشام بيتزا هت كيكة الزبادي حلا سهل صور كيك عجينة العشر دقائق

lyla lubis said...

Such clever work and coverage! Keep up the superb works guys I've you guys to blogroll. buying instagram followers provides quality social services. it is possible to buy followers on instagram.
Kosmetik Online | Akbar | abayweb | toko online murah | Obat Pelangsing Herbal | Busana Muslimah | Percetakan | Cetak Brosur | Cetak Kalender | Cetak Undangan

Affiliate Marketing said...

Inspection causes 13 to miss Cup qualifying : Women MMA makes leap with top two fights on UFC 184 : Live: Aussies fight back after horror show : UFC 184 matchups : Aaron Hernandez sent urgent text to friend on night of murder : Browns, vet McCown agree to 3-year deal : Crash and burn: Aussies; worst ever ODI collapse : Stadium near LAX a terror risk, report says : Kiwi spin wizard destroys Oz : UK Free Online Casnio Slot

Peter Roil said...

sbo-casino : cyprusopenpoker : usonlinepokersites : panoramapoker : 4-casinos : fulltiltpokerreferralcode

obat herbal said...

penanganankutildibibirvagina bahayakutildivagina gejalakutilkelamindanpenanganannya pengobatandenatureindonesiakutilkelamin

jaring futsal dan rumput futsal said...

Nice article, thanks for the information. It's very complete information. I will bookmark for next reference
jaring futsal | jaring golf | jaring pengaman proyek |
jaring pengaman bangunan | jaring pengaman gedung

wasirdenature said...

obat kencing nanah pengobatan sipilis terbaik obat kencing nanah atau gonore cairan nanah dari kelamin pengobatan tradisional kemaluan keluar tips menyembuhkan kencing nanah ampuh penyebab kencing terasa perih

herbal medicine said...

obat kencing nanah pengobatan sipilis terbaik obat kencing nanah atau gonore cairan nanah dari kelamin pengobatan tradisional kemaluan keluar tips menyembuhkan kencing nanah ampuh penyebab kencing terasa perih

obat herbal said...

obat kencing nanah pengobatan sipilis terbaik obat kencing nanah atau gonore cairan nanah dari kelamin pengobatan tradisional kemaluan keluar tips menyembuhkan kencing nanah ampuh penyebab kencing terasa perih

lionelmessi10 said...

gejala kutil kelamin cara mengobati kutil di sekitar kemaluan herbal ampuh untuk kutil kelamin cara mengobati kutil di kelamin wanita obat kutil kelamin cara mengobati kutil di sekitar kelamin kutil di sekitar vagina

Bambang Wisanggeni said...

CARA MENGOBATI KENCING NANAH
KENCING TIDAK SAKIT TAPI KELUAR NANAH
BAGAIMANA CARA MENGOBATI KENCING KELUAR NANAH
KENAPA KENCING KELUAR NANAH
OBAT HERBAL UNTUK KENCING TERASA NGILU
KENAPA KENCING BERDARAH
MENGENALI GEJALA GONORE ATAU KENCING NANAH
KENAPA KENCING TERASA NGILU
KENAPA ADA NODA KUNING DI CELANA DALAM
OBAT HERBAL UNTUK PENYAKIT GONORE ATAU

Bambang Wisanggeni said...


obat kanker payudara herbal
obat herbal untuk kanker payudara yang manjur
obat herbal untuk kanker paru-paru
obat herbal untuk kanker prostat
obat herbal yang manjur untuk kanker serviks/rahim
obat kanker serviks yang ampuh

Herbal de nature said...

Apa itu Penyakit Ambeien ?
obat kutil kelamin di selangkangan
Obat alat kelamin keluar nanah | Obat Herbal
Obat yang paling manjur untuk mengobati kutil di kemaluan
Tips Merawat Vagina
Obat herbal yang manjur untuk kutil kelamin di penis
Tips Merawat Miss V
OBAT KUTIL KELAMIN TRADISIONAL
obat kutil di kemaluan
obat kanker payudara tradisional
obat kelamin keluar nanah
obat wasir yang manjur dan aman tanpa efek samping
obat kutil kelamin yang manjur untuk wanita
obat kutil kelamin pada wanita
Cara paling ampuh mengobati kutil kelamin di rumah tanpa ke dokter
CARA MENGOBATI KUTIL KELAMIN
Penyebab Keputihan Encer dan Pencegahan Keputihan | Obat Herbal
Obat alami untuk kemaluan bernanah dan bengkak | Obat herbal
OBAT YANG PALING MANJUR UNTUK SIPILIS DAN GONORE
OBAT KUTIL KELAMIN HERBAL
obat kutil kelamin di penis dan vagina

obat herbal said...

Obat kencing Nanah De Nature Obat Herbal obat Kutil Kelaminapa penyebab penyakit herpes itu herpes dan apa itu herpes simpleks penyakit herpes pada ibu hamil dan apa itu herpes genital dan gejala herpes genital dan cara menyembuhka herpes genitalis dan cara pencegahan penularan herpes dan bagaimana penyakit herpes bisa menular dan apa itu herpes simpleks dan penyakit herpes pada ibu hamil dan dan cara mengobati herpes secara tradisional dan obat herbal herpes merupakan solusi pengobatan herbal dari denature indonesia