Thursday, June 28, 2012

Obamacare Upheld Thanks to CJ Roberts: I'm Back to Thirty Percent

By Mike Dorf


When I was a law clerk for Justice Kennedy during the 1991-92 Term, I witnessed a substantial number of very fine oral arguments.  During that time, no advocate shone brighter than John Roberts, then at the Solicitor General's office.  He was particularly strong in an ideologically charged case involving the question whether laws restricting abortion were laws that discriminated against women.  Why?  Because he managed to make an argument for a very conservative result (favored by the Bush I Administration) in non-ideological terms.  Roberts impressed me as extremely smart and not an ideologue.  When President Bush II nominated him to the Court I was pleased.  I knew Roberts was not a liberal by any stretch of the imagination, but I expected him to be a thoughtful conservative.

Others who knew Roberts better than I did were less certain.  My then-colleague Tom Merrill had worked with Roberts in government and recalled that the one thing one could say for certain about Roberts was that he never expressed his own opinion.  This struck some people as the sort of caution that one who is "playing possum" might exhibit.  Perhaps Roberts was a deeply conservative ideologue who was hiding his real views so that he would maintain his confirmability one day.  One could find some evidence for that reading in the publicly released memos he wrote as a law clerk and as a young lawyer in the Reagan Administration.  And certainly many of his votes as Chief Justice would give one reason to think that he remained deeply conservative.

But through it all, it turns out, John Roberts remained a lawyer at heart, and a pragmatic one.  I haven't yet read the full opinion, but the very fact that he sustained the Act as a tax shows that he has a deeply anti-formalist streak.  That was apparent during the oral arguments, when he, more than anyone, expressed puzzlement over how one could even say that the law contained a "mandate" when its only enforcement mechanism was tax liability for some and nothing for others.  And in the end, it turns out that was enough for him.

I am sure that there will be much speculation about whether Roberts voted as he did to preserve his legacy or to prevent the Court from being perceived as a purely political institution, but I don't buy it.  If the Chief had gone the other way, all of the attention/blame for the result would have focused on Justice Kennedy.  Moreover, although the Chief cares about the legitimacy of the Court, it's easy for liberals like me and most of my readers to forget that, given the unpopularity of the mandate, a decision the other way would not have much damaged the Court's legitimacy.  I think that CJ Roberts was simply led by the ineluctable logic of the anti-formalist argument that labels don't matter.

I have been saying some variation of the following since the oral argument: "When I started as a constitutional lawyer, I was about 70% legal realist.  I thought that in the ideologically identifiable cases in the Supreme Court, law accounted for roughly 30% of the outcomes one saw.  After Bush v. Gore, I was at 99-1.  That last one percent is on the line in the ACA case."  Now thanks to John Roberts, I'm back to 30%.

166 comments:

WalterWX said...

Since you're being linked to by Scotusblog and hence you're getting joined by non-lawyers like me, it would be nice if you explained what 'anti-formalist' means or refers to in this case. My common sense, which apparently isn't good enough for legal matters, tells me that 'labels do not matter', purely on the merit, would actually be a formalist argument par excellence.

Also, it would be really helpful if you rewrote your last paragraph in more clear terms, since for the life of me I truly do not understand what point you're trying to make there.

michael a. livingston said...

I agree and disagree. It's possible the issue is form v. substance. But I don't think it's insignificant that Roberts is Chief Justice. I think the CJ historically has responsibility for the overall reputation of the Court. Perhaps he didn't want to be known as the leader of a conservative super-legislature that decided a lot of key cases on 5-4 votes . . . although on the last point perhaps he failed.

Blogger said...

Interesting background on Roberts. I thought his background explanation of the Commerce Clause was cogent and accessible to non-lawyers.

I haven't dissected the opinion, but I wonder if it's the quintessential example of the Tidewater problem: where there is no majority opinion on the rationale for the disposition of the case. So does this case essentially create no legal precedent?

egarber said...

So Roberts wrote that the mandate wasn't sustainable as a commerce clause matter. Does this serve as precedent that such a mandate fails the commerce clause test -- even though it was upheld as a tax here?

egarber said...

So Roberts wrote that the mandate wasn't sustainable as a commerce clause matter. Does this serve as precedent that such a mandate fails the commerce clause test -- even though it was upheld as a tax here?

Unknown said...

You nailed it:

"The joint dissenters argue that we cannot uphold §5000A as a tax because Congress did not 'frame' it as such. Post, at 17. In effect, they contend that even if the Constitution permits Congress to do exactly what we interpret this statute to do, the law must be struck down because Congress used the wrong labels. An example may help illustrate why labels should not control here. . . . Our precedent demonstrates that Congress had the power to impose the exaction in §5000A under the taxing power, and that §5000A need not be read to do more than impose a tax. That is sufficient to sustain it."—John Roberts

philosoph said...

Peter Fee:

The non-lawyer who asked you to explain yourself, should be responded to as he asked. This is because I do not see how you consider legally requiring people to buy something and consider that a tax, is realism. It appears to me to be formalism --and a reach-- to call this a tax. Roberts ignores the burden he (now) imposes on people to pay in one way or another --for a scheme. He ignores the realistic impact that this will have on insurance options per se that are available to people. He ignores that their was political deceit in calling this mandate --NOT A TAX--and the choices made made were made on that basis. Roberts' alleged realism actually subverts the political presentation prior to passage that this was not a tax, and then claims to be free of the mess he creates by saying he is not responsible for the people's "political choices". Roberts hides in formalism and mere labels. I am a lawyer and law took a big hit today --when maximum attention with the people's hopes and fears placed on the Court. Roberts did not save the Court today or its or his reputation. He disgraced himself and revealed himself as a tool, too fearful of the "elite" opinion of him. Or, to be the most charitable, too locked in an empty formalism to see what the Government was doing to the people and the States in the atrocity of the ACA.

Joseph Simmons said...

5 Justices rejected the Commerce Clause argument - a position that you and many professors initially thought frivolous and most continued to think it far-fetched.

Was the Court's rejection of that argument simply ideological, a reason to nonetheless lose faith, despite the holding?

The liberal wing of the Court was ideological, seeing virtually no end to federal power on any issues before it in the 2800 pages of the law.

I suppose it was Roberts' desperation to save that law that saves one's faith. I find his reasoning specious, but it certainly showed that he wasn't adhering to any ideology. I don't find his logic ineluctable on the tax issue. He is straightforward about his motivation to find a way to uphold the law. His discussion of the tax issue is lacking, in terms of being a direct tax and in distinguishing it from a penalty. I find it far from ineluctable.

He certainly does exhibit an anti-formalist streak - not because an ordered and logical consideration of the Constitutional issues take him there - but because of the principle of saving this law if at all possible. He bends over backward to do so.

I find the conservative dissent to be rather lifeless.

I'm mostly with Roberts on the Medicare issue. I do think invalidating the entire law as non-severable is not called for, though the argument is compelling.

Striking down the law might not align with one's preferences for constitutional interpretation, but calling it ideological seems inaccurate.

Can one Justice determine whether we have faith in the Court? Given the logic, or lack thereof, of his opinion, as well as the dissents, I'm not encouraged.

Matt said...

Uh, Roberts even said in the opinion that he was embracing a "functional approach" with regard to the Taxing Clause.

Roberts was anti-formalist in the sense that the labels don't matter -- while the "mandate" was labeled "penalty", it was still a tax in the way it operated. Form vs function is a quintessential distinction between formalism and anti-formalism.

And with regard to realism, Prof. Dorf wasn't saying that Roberts is a realist, but that he himself (Dorf) is a realist. And by that, I'm guessing he meant it in the classic, Holmes-Llewellyn-Frank sense.

Billy Rosen said...

Hi Professor Dorf,

I agree that the opinion shows C.J. Roberts' pragmatic side. But reading the four-justice dissent, it strikes me that their willingness to take down the entire ACA may have forced the Chief's hand.

Let's suppose that his main concern was to limit Congressional power under the Commerce Clause, and that his preferred outcome would have been to see the mandate fall under that rationale, but not take the more drastic step of invalidating all the other parts of the ACA, many of which have nothing to do with the mandate or the "creating commerce vs. regulating existing commerce" distinction.

The problem for this hypothetical version of the Chief is that all eight of his colleagues reached one of two conclusions, both of which eliminated the need to address severability and sort out exactly which other provisions would have to fall.

So perhaps C.J. Roberts was faced with two "middle" options: writing a controlling opinion in which he joined in striking down the mandate and then unilaterally rewrote a piece of legislation, or compromising and joining the four more liberal members of the Court.

It seems to me he may have chosen the latter course. Either way, it shows him to be practical and non-formalist, but maybe not quite for the reason you infer.

Of course, this is just my very preliminary hunch.

Best,
Billy

P.S. It was nice running into you with Antonio at Aladdin's last week.

philosoph said...

Peter Fee:

This Link to Richard A. Epstein's post on Scotusblog accords with my earlier post here:

http://www.scotusblog.com/2012/06/taxation-and-regulation-under-the-health-care-act/

Professor Richard A. Epstein:

Taxation and regulation under the health care Act


Chief Justice Roberts’ decision that sustains the individual mandate under the taxing power of the United States is filled with twists and turns that requires some words of protest. In the section of his opinion that deals with the Commerce Power, the Chief Justice accepts the view that Congress cannot regulate individuals unless and until they engage in some form of economic activity. He therefore accepts in full the arguments against the expanded reading of the Commerce Clause that were made by conservative commentators. He did so, as is his habit, without stopping a moment to analyze the enormous expansion in federal power that was ratified in Wickard v. Filburn, which authorized Congress to regulate under the Commerce Clause of the amount of wheat that a farmer could produce for home consumption. Big government, we shall have, but not that big, after all.

But when it comes to the taxing power all bets are off. Here the key statement that he makes is this: “it makes going without insurance just another thing the Government taxes, like buying gasoline or earning income.” With all respect, the point is little short of absurd. The earlier portion of the Chief Justice’s opinion noted the huge expansion in federal power that could arise if the government were permitted to regulate various forms of inactivity. What possible argument then could be put forward to say that the same risks do not apply to the expansion of the taxing authority to those same forms of inactivity, in ways that it has never been exercised before. The two examples that the Chief Justice gives are the tax on buying gasoline or earning income. Both of those are obvious activities that have long been regarded as acceptable bases for taxation. But not buying health insurance is not an activity. I am not aware of any tax imposed on individuals for not buying gasoline and not earning income, or not taking a bath or not working in a home office. To allow this to stand as a tax is to accept the same kind of absurdity that was rejected in connection with the taxing power. Intellectually shabby, to say the least.

Matt said...

philosoph:

Well, the activity-inactivity distinction applies only to the Commerce Clause, and not to the Taxing Clause. (Personally, I see no convincing reason why it should apply to either.)

More to your point, however, just because there is constitutional potential for big government doesn't license the Supreme Court to create distinctions and tests out of thin air. This, of course, is my problem with the activity-inactivity distinction in the first place. Roberts only seems to have two arguments: (1) we've used the word "activity" in our previous cases, and (2) the language of the Constitution seems to presuppose activity.

However, if we accept those arguments to be correct, then it's pretty easy to see why the activity-inactivity distinction applies to the Commerce Clause and not the Taxing Clause. Just compare the language: "To regulate commerce" and "to lay and collect taxes". The latter doesn't presuppose activity in the way the former does.

Another reason, more importantly, is that the Taxing Clause is already subject to many limitations, as Roberts noted in his opinion.

Matt said...

philosoph:

I think it is a pretty basic precept, at least in American law, that the nature of the written constitution requires that general principles be hemmed in by the express language of the document.

meads said...

Prof Dorf you are being much to kind to CJ Roberts. His decision was purely conservative politics. He and the rest of the Conservatives got what they wanted; limitations of the Federal Government's power to attach strings to Federal grants (in this case Medicaid) under a novel theory, limitation on the Commerce Clause and the Necessary and Proper Clause( under another novel theory that appear no where in the Constitution or under SCT precedents) , preventing a Constitutional confrontation with the President and painting the mandate in an unfavorable political light as a tax ( which of course it was ). What is also remarkable was how conservative Justice Kennedy has become in his old age. The Mainstream Media can stop calling him a swing vote; he is reliably a Conservative as Justice Alito, Thomas or Scalia. It is scary that the majority of Justices are so blatantly political as there is no other reasonable basis for this decision on the Commerce Clause and the Necessary and Proper Clause versus their decision in Raich and Comstock.

Blogger said...

As I read it, Roberts' opinion on the Commerce power was not the opinion of the Court, and in any event it was dicta. Right?

So it seems to me that conservatives are wrong to claim that this will stand as precedent to bind future cases on the commerce clause.

The question answered was whether Congress had the power to enact the individual mandate. The answer was yes. The reason was that it is a tax and Congress may enact such taxes. The aside from Roberts about the Commerce Clause is nonbinding.

Anyone disagree?

Crispian said...

Blogger, there was a good article, either on Volokh or ScotusBlog (I believe) addressing this point - though I've misplaced the article.

Roberts is quite clear that he would not reach the tax issue without first running headlong into the Commerce Clause.

It is only after finding that the Commerce Clause doesn't permit the mandate does Roberts express a compulsion to find any other rational means of upholding the law. And he tries mightily to make the mandate fit the definition of a tax.

The liberal justices might not think that approach necessary - but Roberts' decision is the decision of the Court and he does have 4 other justices agreeing with him on that point.

Another important consideration is that Roberts doesn't just find the mandate unsupported by the Commerce Clause, in the agnostic way that the mandate is also unsupported by the War Powers Clause or any number of various other clauses, but he finds the mandate violative of the constitutional order.

What is astounding is that Roberts nonetheless forges ahead to find it constitutional in some way. In light of all this, I think it disingenuous to say the Commerce Clause part is mere dicta. Without that holding, it is clear there would not be a 5th vote to uphold the mandate.

Similarly, it would be disingenuous to ignore Roberts' discussion of the Anti-Injunction Act as mere dicta on the basis that it didn't ultimately relate to upholding the mandate as a tax. Reducing Supreme Court decisions to a "yes" or "no" answer and ignoring the reasoning necessary to get there strikes me as improper. Should it only be important that law is upheld? Or is it also important that a law is found unconstitutional in a sense? In essence (though something of a fiction) Roberts struck down the mandate but preserved the "tax." Roberts is saying it can only really be a tax.

As some conservative commentators are arguing, I do think it has a Marbury v. Madison quality to it.

Liberal jurists will push the argument you present and it's not totally off the wall, but for the reasons above I think it should be a losing argument.

-I apologize for the length of the post!

Blogger said...

Thanks for your response, Crispian.

But the Roberts opinion on the Commerce Clause was NOT the opinion of the Court:

"CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS announced the judgment of the Court and delivered the opinion of the Court with respect to Parts I, II, and III–C . . ."

The opinion of the Court held only that the ACA was a constitutional exercise of Congress's tax power. Roberts wrote an introduction that was his own opinion, then wrote Parts I (giving a procedural background on the case), II (holding that the Anti-Injunction Act did not prevent consideration of the tax issue), and III-C (holding that the ACA mandate was a valid exercise of the tax power).

His other opinions are his own and were not joined by others. Therefore, as the opinion of a single justice, they bind no court. Disagree?

Also, on the Anti-Injunction point, that is certainly NOT dicta. You offer the straw man that one might view it as "mere dicta on the basis that it didn't ultimately relate to upholding the mandate as a tax." But not only did the opinion "relate" to upholding the mandate as a tax, it was necessary to deciding the issue -- the Anti-Injuncion Act presented a threshold issue about whether the Court could consider the merits. And, a single justice's assertion that he would have not reached one issue before considering another is not binding. Disagree?

This is not to say that Roberts' opinion wouldn't be cited as persuasive authority. But it is not law. Neither SCOTUS nor any other court is bound to adhere to the opinion of a sole Justice, even if it is that of the Chief Justice.

I'd love to hear any differing opinions on this point.

Crispian said...

Blogger,

I do hope Professor Dorf gives his views on the significance of the formal designation of the Court's opinion and the rest of the questions you raise.

But here is something to consider: according to the formal designation of who joined Roberts in the Medicaid part of his opinion, there were only 3 Justices (including himself). As for Roberts reformation of that part of the statute, there were 5 Justices who supported his reading (including himself), 2 of who dissented on the Medicaid issue. The 4 conservative dissenters obviously agreed with Roberts, but did not "join" his opinion and they did not think reformation appropriate.

So in that tangled mess, might we say Ginsburg and Sotomayor's views on reforming the Medicaid statute were mere dicta, since they thought the statute constitutional and do not properly reach that issue? Or do we count their votes for the sole purpose of resolution. If so, who is the majority on that issue? Are the conservative dissenters being counted, even if not formally recognized? Do we merely abide the announcement that it's the "opinion of the Court" notwithstanding the arguments, logic, and number of votes contained therein?

I admit to being a little crafty in my argument about the Anti-Injunction Act. My point is that if we only care about the disposition and take from the opinion only enough to support that disposition, and not how the Court got there, we are ignoring the logic of the opinion, such as it is.

You ask: "a single justice's assertion that he would have not reached one issue before considering another is not binding. Disagree?"

Is it radically different than Ginsburg and Sotomayor's endorsement of Roberts' reformation of the Medicaid part of the law? Why should their votes be binding?

Imagine if Congress now passes a law jailing people for not buying insurance (as an exercise of the Commerce Clause). Do we say that even though 5 Justices held a mandate to be unconstitutional under the Commerce Clause, that it was not strictly required for the disposition of that particular case (according to 4 justices)?

Otherwise, we must implicitly endorse the view of 4 liberal justices that the mandate is simply a tax - when that's not what Roberts' wrote. I grant you that Roberts doesn't constitute a majority, but neither do the 4 liberal justices.

Roberts held the mandate constitutional IF read as a tax. In response to Ginsburg, Roberts writes, "Without deciding the Commerce Clause question, I would find no basis to adopt such a saving construction."

That Roberts would otherwise "find no basis" for upholding the mandate as a tax cannot be mere dicta. If you negate the Commerce Clause argument as mere dicta, that throws his saving construction interpretation into doubt. Especially when he is joined by 4 Justices who similarly reject the Commerce Clause argument that gets him to the consideration of the Tax power.

It is dicta that Commerce Clause consideration is a necessary predicate to the tax issue - since none of the other justices endorse that view - and I don't even think Roberts is presenting that as doctrine.

This is a bunch of fodder for thought. Maybe this decision is more like Bush v. Gore, having little relevance outside the singular case before the court. If Roberts thinks the mandate is only a tax as a saving construction, but that such taxes may otherwise be unconstitutional (granted I'm not sure where that could happen), then there isn't an absolute majority for the mandate as tax as a general rule.

I've been pondering hypotheticals like whether the government could tax us $1 for each coffeepot we do not own with a maximum $20 tax, exempting left-handed redheads (so that it's not a capitation).

Blogger said...

Crispian:

Yes, the opinion is unfortunately messy, but that's why it's important to do the work to parse it.

First point: whether an opinion is the opinion of the court and whether it is dicta are two separate issues. An opinion of the court may be dicta. Here, Roberts' opinion happens to be not that of the court AND it is dicta.

Second point: there was no opinion of the Court on the Medicare issue, but there was a judgment (as I read it -- let me know if I'm wrong). See pp. 58-59 for the judgment that Roberts announces. So as I read it, the judgment is binding on the parties and is precedent for factually similar cases, but the rationales expressed in the various opinions is not.

I don't mean to argue that one should ignore the various opinions when trying to decide what a future SCOTUS might decide by counting heads. But when those opinions are not that of the Court, they are not legally binding precedent.

Admittedly, the foregoing is my own quick analysis based on my basic understanding of a traditional interpretation of stare decisis. I'd be interested to know of any differing opinions that add more nuance.

Blogger said...

Just re-read my post and wanted to clarify: I think I was guilty of mixing up the issues of whether an opinion is dicta and whether it's not the opinion of the Court. I suppose that in order to be dicta, an opinion must be that of the Court. So strictly speaking, Roberts' Commerce Clause wasn't dicta (or holding) because it wasn't the opinion of the Court.

In any event, I don't think the Commerce Clause opinion is controlling because it wasn't the Court's opinion, but even if it were, it would be dicta.

Crispian said...

Blogger,

Good catch on what constitutes dicta - wish I had thought of that at first glance!

What continues to stick in my mind is that in this case, 5 justices felt it necessary to decide the Commerce Clause matter and held the mandate to be unconstitutional, under that rationale. I think that is indisputable.

But maybe it was a decision with relatively little in the way of binding precedent on the Commerce Clause issue.

On the Medicaid issue, there were 7 justices who held it unconstitutional. On the Medicaid issue, it is a plurality opinion, though I see little daylight between the conservative dissenters and Roberts on the Medicaid expansion's constitutionality (or the Commerce Clause). There is no apparent right way of treating plurality decisions as precedent, according to a law review (found in full on the school's website) : James A. Bloom, Plurality and Precedence: Judicial Reasoning, Lower Courts, and the Meaning of United States v. Winstar Corp., 85 Wash. U. L. Rev. 1373 (2008).

A fun (?) exercise might be in comparing this case to that of Coleman v. Court of Appeals of Maryland (2012). That case concerned the assertion of Commerce Clause authority and/or 14th Amendment power - though the latter contention was roundly rejected by ever Court of Appeals.

In that case, an ex-employee was suing the state for failure to provide sick leave, as required by federal law. The state claimed the federal law allowing suit was an unconstitutional breach of sovereign immunity.

4 justices, led by Kennedy, held that the law did not fit under the 14th Amendment (because the remedy of the statute was not "congruent" with violations of the 14th Amendment) and as an exercise of the Commerce Clause was invalid.

Scalia concurred with Kennedy's opinion, but rejected the congruency test, instead relying on the text of the 14th Amendment to decide that protection of sick leave is not in its ambit.

4 justices, led by Ginsburg, dissented that the law was congruent under the 14th Amendment and should be constitutional. Ginsburg and Breyer additionally believed sovereign immunity could be abrogated under the Commerce Clause.

Scalia wrote: "The plurality’s opinion seems to me a faithful application of our 'congruence and proportionality' jurisprudence. So does the opinion of the dissent."

I would think that the opinions are good precedent for applying the congruency test because 8 justices endorsed that view - even if 4 of those justices were dissenting based on their understanding of the precise law before them. To me, the principles and doctrines endorsed by a majority of the Court are more important as precedent for later cases than resolution of the nature of the single law before them. I may well be mistaken in this. Or maybe there is not a clear line, except to say that an opinion explicitly endorsed by a majority is unquestionably good precedent.

Cristiero Rola said...

I don't mean to argue that one should ignore the various opinions when trying to decide what a future SCOTUS might decide by counting heads. But when those opinions are not that of the Court, they are not legally binding precedent.

Admittedly, the foregoing is my own quick analysis based on my basic understanding of a traditional interpretation of stare decisis. I'd be interested to know of any differing opinions that add more nuance. Windows 7 ultimate Key
Windows 7 ultimate product Key
Buy Cheap Windows 7 Key

Jet Li said...

I acknowledge along with disagree. Possibly the thing is type /. compound. However don't believe it can be trivial in which Roberts can be Chief Justice. I believe the CJ historically provides obligation for www.d3face.com/
that total trustworthiness of the judge. Maybe they don't wish to be called the head of your conventional super-legislature that will determined a lot of key instances upon 5-4 ballots . . . even though around the very last stage maybe he unsuccessful.

Winter's Web said...

In a court opinion, dicta is whatever is logically unnecessary in order for the ultimate decision on an issue to stand. Lisa M. Durham Taylor, Parsing Supreme Court Dicta to Adjudicate Non-Workplace Harms, 57 DRAKE L. REV. 75, Part III-A (2008); Broadwater v. State, 909 A.2d 1112, 1123 (2006), 931 A.2d 1098 (2007): "Most significantly, the observations in the dicta are not in any way important to the actual decision in the case. The holding would not have been affected in any way if the dicta had been totally excised from the opinion. Three weeks of law school should teach us that such gratuitous dicta does not take on the mantle of binding precedent. Some dicta, of course, may turn out to be a harbinger of future change, but it does not, in and of itself, become a part of stare decisis." By definition, dicta is not binding precedent; only the holding is.

In my opinion, Justice Roberts' entire Commerce Clause analysis is dicta, even though four other justices--the dissenters--essentially agreed with it.

(And yes, there is U.S. Supreme Court precedent that holds that if necessary we can look to dissenters to provide a majority on a particular issue before the court. Moses H. Cone Hosp. v. Mercury Constr. Corp., 460 U.S. 1, 17 (1983); see Marks v. United States, 430 U.S. 188, 193 (1977). )

So why is the entire Commerce Clause analysis dicta, even though five justices--Roberts and the dissenters--support it? Because in the words of the above Broadwater case, "The holding would not have been affected in any way if the dicta had been totally excised from the opinion."

Specifically, the 5-4 holding of the Supreme Court on the individual mandate (the requirement imposed upon the uninsured to buy minimum-coverage health insurance policies) is that the tax-penalty for ignoring it is authorized by the Constitution's Taxing Clause, which gives Congress the power "to lay and collect Taxes." U.S. Const., Art. I, § 8, cl. 1.

The above 5-4 holding--that the Taxing Clause makes the individual mandate's tax-penalty constitutional--is logically sufficient in and of itself to decide the constitutional issue before the court. That is, it needs no additional support from any other part of the Constitution to make logical sense. Therefore the entire discussion of the Commerce Clause is dicta.

It wouldn't matter if all nine justices had joined in Robert's discussion of the Commerce Clause. For the reasons just stated, the entire Commerce Clause would still have been dicta.

On page 37 (main text and footnote 12) of her concurrence/dissent, Justice Ginsburg finds the very existence of Chief Justice Roberts' Commerce Clause discussion "puzzling," because it is "not outcome determinative." This is just another way of saying that it is dicta and not a holding.

Roberts tries to get around this by stating that "[w]ithout deciding the Commerce Clause question, I would find no basis to adopt such a saving construction [of the individual mandate's penalty as a tax]." Roberts opinion, Part III-D, page 44. This doesn't work to transform the Commerce Clause dicta into a holding because no other justice joins Roberts in this (or in any portion of Roberts' Part III-D).

The rather eye-opening conclusion to be drawn from a serious study of the dicta-holding divide is that the large majority of what is written in judicial opinions is dicta, and not holdings--that is, not binding precedent. See Pierre N. Leval, Judging Under the Constitution: Dicta About Dicta, 81 N.Y.U. L. Rev. 1249, 1274–75 (2006).
=======================

Above comment written by me, George Zadorozny, Attorney-at-Law. I limit my practice to legal research, writing, and consulting for attorneys. More info at gzesq.wordpress.com and at www.georgezadorozny.com.

Muhammad Zahid Iqbal said...

think that CJ Roberts was simply led by the ineluctable logic of the anti-formalist argument that labels don't matter.www.effectivefa.com

beeple Bill said...

Along with frequently recognized feature dog collar single advantages to get puppies in addition to getting cost effective for any pet owners who actually make use of them. Working with a specific design, puppy crates and additionally pet carriers tend dog leashes to be valuable in addition to well-designed and can be flushed easily. They're just comfy in your puppy since they are manufactured working with at ease items such as 100 % cotton, which assists ones steadfast friend to remain seated tranquil no matter if outdoors or indoors.


Whenever this company on your family dog carrier pet in travels, then pet carriers really are lovelonglong.com a need to for carrying proper care the family pet.

J hui said...

I guess I'm lucky, life diablo 3 gold has always been like this. Hate to say it in these times but my Faith gets me through buy diablo 3 gold, it really does

fox diane said...

May you ncie day! Welcome to visit my Homepage and I wanna be your friend.

diablo 3 gold kaufen said...


good post beautifull

-----------------------------------------
runescape gold|wow gold kaufen|diablo 3 gold|Swtor Credits

soft said...

Uh, Roberts even said in the opinion that he was embracing a "functional approach" with regard to the Taxing Clause.

Roberts was anti-formalist in the sense that the labels don't matter -- while the "mandate" was labeled "penalty", it was still a tax in the way it operated. Form vs function is a quintessential distinction between formalism and anti-formalism.

And with regard to realism, Prof. Dorf wasn't saying that Roberts is a realist, but that he himself (Dorf) is a realist. And by that, I'm guessing he meant it in the classic, Holmes-Llewellyn-Frank sense.


buy cheap gw2 gold|GW2 Gold


johnson said...

One of the easiest ways to make a profit in rs gold is using the Cooking Profession. For all of players, cooking in WOW has always been one of the most satisfying professions. In this guide expose buy rs gold

Ellina Lee said...

Moreover, we must make sure that from your standpoint with the spectators can be quite exciting to observe the complete struggle Cheapest GW2 Gold, even though making sure that the particular narrator could be easy and user-friendly idea of your situation Diablo 3 Gold Farming, these more efficiently disseminated to the viewers.

mas jangkrik said...

Good work! Your post is an excellent example of why I keep coming back to read your excellent quality content. seo service indonesia

Upton said...

This week news buy rsgold broke that a California marriage had kept his two daughters locked up for three years in a caravan while devoted their lives to play World of Warcraft . Once again, critics of video games found a reason to buy runescape gold 2007 charge them, and if we add that as a game of 'rol'-yes, in quotes, many Spanish parricide remember the katana and the theme old school runescape accounts for sale will extend with eternal ramblings.

mas jangkrik said...

I really liked it. Keep sharing such excellent post like this in future too. pulau tidung

Ada Bush said...

Since I have studied this poems, I knowed that wirting a great poems is difficult. Also I Billige Handys ohne Vertrag online bestellen think the techology is so important~

shorry june said...

Wow, you are amazing! I android phone cheap love everything about this.

Timbaland said...

I believe that we are not real GW2 Gold Guide social workers. We may be doing social work in the Buy GW2 Gold Guide eyes of the people, but we are really contemplatives in the heart of Guild Wars 2 Guide the world.

Timbaland said...

Stray birds of summer come to my window to sing GW2 Gold Guide and fly away. And yellow leaves of autumn, which Buy GW2 Gold Guide have no songs, flutter and fall there Guild Wars 2 Guide with a sign.

Linda said...

Many Diablo III players have no problem understanding the mechanics of the game, have great builds, and have the buy diablo 3 gold knowledge to beat all the bosses in the game. However, what many players do not have is the money to purchase good gear cheap diablo 3 gold that will get diablo 3 gold them through inferno mode.The video game Star Wars: The Old Republic swtor credits was known as one of the most anticipated role playing games ever delivered onto the market. It is a massively multiplayer game that generated literally millions of buy swtor credits in sales within just a few weeks of being released.Star Wars was one of the most popular movies of all times and is considered cheap swtor credits a classic series which is loved by fans from all around the globe.

jone Smith said...

That’s been one of my mantras – focus and simplicity. Simple can be harder than complex: You have to work hard to get your thinking clean to make it simple. But it’s worth it in the end because once you get there, you can move mountains.dating sites

jone Smith said...

I found lots of interesting information here. The post was professionally written and I feel like the author has extensive knowledge in this subject.jailbreak ios 7 mac

steve7876 said...

These types of components is becoming essay writing author program making plan thus well-known by means of that may shops aren't able to pay out a lesser amount of determining to obtain as well as most likely the believed.

Lauren anderson said...

Reality that Cj Roberts was basically headed by the inequitable rationale of the opposition to formalist contention that names don't make a difference.
Exclusive Company Escorts

hannah william said...

it is nice to see CJ Roberts recieved from Obamacare Upheld.
You can get services of EssayAvenue.co.uk or you can simply buy online UK essays or just ask for college writing services or ask to write my essay for me right now.

Ahmad Subarjo said...

I have found very useful information over there, thanks for sharing this. likes facebook

Saha William said...

i was expecting that CJ Roberts will be thanked but not by Obamacare Upheld. anyhow good work.
logodivine.com

get rid of cellulite said...

I really be grateful for your blog, you have completed the great job. Thanks for the bunch of excellent resourceful site.
klebe bh

mas jangkrik said...

A very informative article and lots of really honest and forthright comments made ! Advertising agency Malaysia

Роджер Смит said...

How Much Does Homework Help Cost? We know the ansver!Essay rider

M RAZA ABBAS said...

I can not stop reading this. And 'so fresh, so full of information, I do not know. I'm glad that people actually write the smart way to show the different sides of him.
Plumber dublin 3

Jasmine Peyton said...

Good efforts, i was lot of enjoying along read this article thanks!
computer science dissertation help || law dissertation writing service

mas jangkrik said...

Thanks a lot for sharing such a wonderful post, it is a very nice site i really enjoyed to visit this site. www.vita-d-chlor.com

Joseph Patrick said...

Precious Information for those who are tired of writing and by means of you they will get good result because of your writing quality .
http://www.makemyessay.com/college-papers-for-sale/.

Jason Fernandez said...

I am delighted to find some more informationbuy an essay

get rid of cellulite said...

Sometimes when you innovate, you make mistakes. It is best to admit them quickly, and get on with improving your other innovations.
relatiegeschenk telefoon

get rid of cellulite said...

This post has helped me for an article which I am writing. Thank you for giving me another point of view on this topic. Now I can easily complete my article. Cheers
push up adhesif

M RAZA ABBAS said...

Thank you for posting this.You most absolutely have built this blog website into something special.
best bike computer

get rid of cellulite said...

We've take a look at your website publish and i a extremely helpful along with experienced
verhuisbedrijf leiden

get rid of cellulite said...

I have visited this blog first time and i got a lot of informative data from here which is quiet helpful for me indeed.
bra tape

Hafiz Muneef said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Alex Stitzer said...

The information you shared through your post is functional.I admire your work.place beyond the pines jacket

M RAZA ABBAS said...

I like this blog a lot and found it very interesting.vastgoed beleggen

Simon Thompson said...

Great job for publishing such a nice informative article.
http://www.absoluteessays.com/need-help-writing-an-essay/

David Peter said...

Thanks for sharing a sensible post.buy academic papers online

David Peter said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Michael Elijah said...

lot of informative data from here which is quiet helpful for me .
thank you for sharing.
essay writer

David James said...

really liked it. Keep sharing such excellent post like this in future too Buy custom paper

Joseph Patrick said...

Excellent post.The post is written in very a good manner and it entails many useful information for me. I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. buy essays for college

basma gaber said...

شركة تنظيف بيارات بالدمام

شركة تنظيف منازل بالمدينة

شركة تنظيف منازل بالدمام

نقل عفش بجدة

شركه نقل اثاث بمكة

شركة نقل اثاث بالدمام

شركة تنظيف منازل بالمدينة المنورة

شركات عزل مائي

شركة مكافحة حشرات جدة

تنظيف فلل بالدمام

شركات مكافحة الحشرات فى الرياض

افضل شركة تنظيف بالخرج




here

here

here

here

here

here

Harry morgan said...

I found this Information very interesting and informative! Keep sharing!essay

Jason Fernandez said...

Your post helps me to complete my assignment writing projects of university. Thanks for assisting me.. Essay writer

basma gaber said...

1شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض

شركة تنظيف مجالس بالرياض

شركة تنظيف موكيت بالرياض



شركة كشف تسربات بالرياض

تسليك مجارى بالرياض

تنظيف بيارات بالرياض

شركة تنظيف كنب بالرياض

شركة تنظيف مسابح بالرياض

شركة تنظيف مجالس بالرياض

شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض

شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض

basma gaber said...

2شركة تسليك مجارى بالرياض

شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض

شركة تنظيف كنب بالرياض

شركة تنظيف اثاث بالرياض

شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض

شركة عزل خزانات بالرياض

شركة عزل حراري

شركة عزل مائي

شركة تنظيف موكيت بالرياض

شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض

شركة تنظيف مجالس بالرياض

شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض

basma gaber said...

4شركة القمة لنقل العفش بالرياض

شركات نظافة بالرياض

كشف تسربات بالرياض

شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض

شركة البستان للتنظيف بالرياض

شركة تنظيف بالرياض

شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض

شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض

شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض

شركة تنظيف مسابح بالرياض

شركة عزل اسطح بالرياض

شركة نقل عفش بالرياض

شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض

basma gaber said...

5شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض

شركة عزل خزانات بالرياض

شركة القحطاني لرش المبيدات بالرياض

شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض

نقل اثاث

افضل شركة كشف تسربات بالرياض

شركة كشف تسربات بالرياض

شركة تسليك مجارى بالرياض

شركة الشامل مكافحة حشرات بالرياض

شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض

basma gaber said...

6شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض

شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالدمام

شركة رش مبيدات بالدمام

شركة تنظيف خزانات بالدمام

شركة تنظيف بيارات بالدمام

شركة تنظيف منازل بالمدينة

شركة تنظيف منازل بالدمام

basma gaber said...

8شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض

شركة نظافة بالرياض

شركة عزل خزانات

عزل اسطح بالرياض

شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض

شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض

شركة تنظيف موكيت بالرياض

شركة تنظيف بالرياض

شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض

شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض

شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض

شركة غسيل خزانات بالرياض

basma gaber said...

9شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض

شركة تنظيف كنب بالرياض

شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض

شركة جلي بلاط بالرياض

شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض

شركة تخزين عفش بالرياض

تخزين اثاث

شركة تنظيف بيارات بالرياض

شركة عزل اسطح بالرياض

شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض

basma gaber said...

11شركة عزل أسطح بالدمام

شركة عزل أسطح بالدمام

نقل عفش بالمدينة

شركة عزل أسطح بالرياض

شركة تنظيف بيوت بالرياض

اسعار نقل العفش بالرياض

شركة نقل اثاث بالمدينة المنورة

شركات تنظيف المنازل في جدة

شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض

شركة تسليك مجارى بالرياض

شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض

Mark Wright said...

I think it's helpful to have a lot of pre-packaged items that you created in your moments of
inspiration. In this way you can just sit down and write the details.

Essay Writing Service Uk

suzi cohen said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sheraz ajaz said...

Hi, Nice work, I've bookmarked this page and have a feeling I'll be returning to it regularly.Wasbak

Jacob John said...

You did nice work your post is awesome its increase my knowledge. coursework help service

Jordan Paul said...

I got a clean solution from here. Also I can refer to you all realtor el dorado hills here to get educational helps. affordable essay writing service

Jacob John said...

I’ve read your things before and you are just too awesome. help with assignment writing

aminos lahragui said...



you can check that aweome thread about ginger from here

فوائد الزنجبيل

فوائد الرمان

فوائد الحلبة

فوائد البصل


فوائد الزعتر

فوائد زيت السمسم

al3ab

obat penis said...

I am very happy with what you convey this in your web. And I want to share some specific information, may be received here. previous post and I thank you for her great.
Kami membawa sebuah informasi yang cukup menarik menurut kami, info ini berkaitan dengan apa yang di butuhkan kaum pria remaja maupun yang sudah berkeluarga. info tersebut sebagai berikut. Toko alat pembesar penis berupa vakum dan alat tarik otot.
Selain itu Kami juga menyediakan Obat pembesar penis yang mengutamakan kesehatan, maka dari itu yang kami bawa ini sebuah ramuan Memperbesar penis yang terbuat dari bahan2 herbal alami. klik disini.
http://goo.gl/lp6gSk

sandi said...

I am grateful for the information that I have seen this, with this content can make me grow my knowledge, once again I thank you wrong me kami jual alat bantu sex, sebuah alat bantu pria dan alat bantu wanita yang dapat untuk di gunakan memuaskan diri sendiri, pengetahuan kami ada disini http://goo.gl/lmqpmu

Paul Lewis said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
share seo said...

شركة ترميم منازل بالرياض
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض
شركة عزل مائى بالرياض
شركة نقل وتخزين اثاث بالرياض
شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض
شركة تخزين عفش بالرياض
شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض
شركة مكافحة الحشرات بالرياض
شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض
شركة ترميم منازل فى الرياض
شركة عزل مائى وحرارى بالرياض
-----
العاب بنات

social online
10 best mobile phones in the world

ali said...

Excellent and decent post. I found this much informative, as to what I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up.

Tom Alter said...

An amazing post. Loved it to the core. Marketing Assignment Help
law assignment help
finance assignment help
Accounting assignment help
Assignment help
Make My Assignment

Abo Omar said...

كشف تسربات المياه

شركة تسليك مجاري بالدمام

شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض

شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض

افضل شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض

شركة نظافة بالرياض

شركة تنظيف بالرياض

شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض

شركة تنظيف مجالس بالرياض

شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض

كشف تسربات المياه بجدة

شركة تنظيف شقق بجدة 

amine lahragui said...


thanks so much for that great blog and thanks also for accepting my links thanks
طريقة عمل الدونات طريقة عمل البان كيك طريقة عمل الكنافة طريقة عمل البسبوسة طريقة عمل الكيك طريقة عمل عجينة البيتزا فوائد القرفه
thanks so much i like very so much your post
فوائد الحلبة فوائد الزنجبيل فوائد الرمان فوائد زيت السمسم علاج البواسير فوائد البصل فوائد اليانسون فوائد الكركم فوائد الزعتر قصص جحا تعريف الحب علامات الحمل

Susan White said...

Great post with the detailed analysis. Loved your writing.

Thanks
Help with Marketing assignment
Law assignment help
Assignment Help
Assignment Help

Clement vanesha said...

ne thing that you might fix if you happe Tas Grosir Batam Model Baju Wanita Jual Rumah Anggrek Grosir Tas Murah Branded Harga Tas Supplier Baju Rumah Dijual Tas Branded Terbaru Tas Batam Murah Jual Rumah Di Bsd K Jual Rumah Bsd The Fashion Korea Tas Branded Kw 1 Dijual Rumah Di Bsd Jual Baju Korea Murah Rumah Dijual Alam S Rumah Dikontrakkan Jual Rumah Di Alam Jual Rumah Di Alam Grosirtas

aminos lahragui said...


thanks so much i like very so much your post
حلى الاوريو الفطر الهندي صور تورته حلى قهوه طريقة عمل السينابون طريقة عمل بلح الشام بيتزا هت كيكة الزبادي حلا سهل صور كيك عجينة العشر دقائق

Tom Alter said...

Marketing Assignment Help
law assignment help
finance assignment help
Accounting assignment help
Assignment help
Make My Assignment
Dissertation writing Service
Do my assignment
Nursing Assignment help
Best Marketing management assignment help service from MakeMyAssignments.com at affordable prices. Get 100% plagiarism free marketing homework help in UK, USA, and Australia.

Anuj kumar said...

Decide earlier that whether you will package your valuables yourself or use expert item packaging alternatives of shifting companies. If you have limited price range and are expert in item packaging job then you might like to package your valuables on yourself. Pack all your family members members effects accordingly a appropriate item packaging plan.

Packers and Movers India
Packers and Movers in Hyderabad
Packers and Movers in Mumbai
Packers and Movers in Pune

Anuj kumar said...

Pack factors on the room by room basis. Pack one room at some point. Use plenty of wrapping sheets and padding provides to protect your valuables within the containers and in transit. Place heavier items first and lighter items later within the box. Use sturdy containers always.

Packers and Movers in Chennai
Packers and Movers in Bangalore
Packers and Movers in Delhi
Gurgaon Packers and Movers

Joel Sjogren said...

Hi, I think u have posted the best article according to information. keep it up I will be glad to see such informative and helping article from u. very useful information.. thanks for sharing
assignment writing service uk

Leena Bisht said...


packers and movers in hyderabad
packers and movers gurgaon
packers and movers pune
packers and movers delhi
packers and movers bangalore
packers and movers in gurgaon

Kapil Mishra said...

packers and movers bangalore
packers and movers pune
packers and movers gurgaon
movers and packers in bangalore
movers and packers in mumbai
movers and packers hyderabad
movers and packers in delhi
packers and movers hyderabad

Sharron Issac said...

movers and packers in hyderabad @ http://top8th.in/packers-movers-hyderabad/
movers and packers in gurgaon @ http://top8th.in/packers-movers-gurgaon/
packers and movers delhi@ http://top8th.in/packers-movers-delhi/

saumya said...

Household shifting is often a time-consuming as well as intricate practice together with a great deal of headaches, unpleasant issues along with boring duties including taking, packing, transporting, unloading, unpacking along with puting in order connected with household products and also stuff. It might be probably the most tense and also daunting tasks of life-time. Yet it is usually made much easier in addition to less difficult through the use of companies of a single regarding expert packers as well as movers firms. There are many professional moving companies or even movers as well as packers in numerous key locations in addition to areas regarding Indian out there; that can supply you necessary providers and thorough option for ones home moving. Selecting the most appropriate one is crucial. You must timetable the go using a correct company that can go with your new house purchase needs, preferences as well as the spending budget you could have prepared. You must not get beyond your budget with home separation. Here are several tips pertaining to choosing the right packers along with movers with regard to home moving. Have a look at them.

Article Source: http://www.localpackersmoversinbangalore.in/

komal yadav said...

packers and movers hyderabad @ http://top8th.in/packers-movers-hyderabad/

packers and movers in gurgaon @ http://top8th.in/packers-movers-gurgaon/

packers and movers in delhi @ http://best5th.in/packers-movers-delhi/

packers and movers delhi @ http://top8th.in/packers-movers-delhi/

Sharron Issac said...

packers and movers in delhi
movers and packers in hyderabad
movers and packers in gurgaon

Mossad Eladawi said...


كشف تسربات المياه
مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بجدة
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة تخزين عفش بالرياض
شركة عزل خزانات بالرياض
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالدمام
شركة مكافحة حشرات بجدة
شركة تنظيف بالدمام
شركة نقل اثاث بالدمام
شركة تسليك مجاري بالدمام
شركة عزل خزانات بجدة
شركة نقل اثاث بالمدينة المنورة
شركة جلي بلاط بالرياض

suresh dwivedi said...

You should decide on a well-known and authentic shifting support organization which is having outstanding history too.
Packers and Movers Noida

Packers and Movers Navi Mumbai

Packers and Movers Thane

Packers and Movers Amritsar

suresh dwivedi said...

If you are seeing opinions which are offering bad feedback about a particular shifting support organization, then you can remove that name from your short-listed packers and mover’s titles.
Packers and Movers in Jalandhar @ http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-jalandhar/

Packers and Movers in Ghaziabad @ http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-ghaziabad/

Packers and Movers in Faridabad @ http://www.expert5th.in/packers-and-movers-faridabad/

suresh dwivedi said...

They always used to come in the first website of search engines as they are very well-known organizations and hence their website has been seen by individuals frequently.
Packers and Movers Jalandhar

Packers and Movers Ghaziabad

Packers and Movers Faridabad

Mark Taylor said...

Its magnificent website in truth very good site and blog facility every title is very nice and very unbelievable thought. Thanks for sharing the awesome information.

Visit : Online High School Diploma

neeraj mishra said...

So use services of one of suitable, good and experienced packers and movers agencies of your city with right planning and approaches; and make your move highly simple and easy.

packers and movers pune
packers and movers Bangalore
packers and movers gurgaon

obat herbal said...

cara menghilngkan nanah dari kemluan pengobatan nanah keluar dari ujung kemaluan obat nanah keluar dari kemaluanapa itu penyakit wasir

jaring futsal dan rumput futsal said...

great post i would like to tell you thanks for sharing
jaring futsal | jaring golf | jaring pengaman proyek |
jaring pengaman bangunan | jaring pengaman gedung

wasirdenature said...

"mengobati wasir

herbal medicine said...

"mengobati wasir

شركة قمة الخليج لنقل الأثاث والتنظيف بالرياض said...

شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض
شركة نقل عفش بالرياض
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض
شركة كشف تسربات بالرياض
شركة تنظيف بالرياض
شركة عزل خزانات بالرياض

raghu pandit said...

Thanks for all your information, Website is very nice and informative content.
Movers and Packers in Chennai
Movers and Packers in Pune
Movers and Packers in Mumbai
Movers and Packers in Gurgaon
Movers and Packers in Noida
Movers and Packers in Navi Mumbai

raghu pandit said...

Thanks for post this helpful post - Please visit for More information about -
Movers and Packers in Hyderabad
Movers and Packers in Bangalore
Movers and Packers in Delhi
Movers and Packers in Thane

Kajal Singh said...

Best Packers and Movers Pune Lists

Packers and Movers Pune

Packers and Movers Aundh Pune

Packers and Movers Hadapsar Pune

Packers and Movers Magarpatta Pune

Packers and Movers Pimple Saudagar Pune

Packers and Movers Viman Nagar Pune

Packers and Movers Wakad Pune

Packers and Movers Kharadi Pune

Packers and Movers Hinjewadi Pune

Packers and Movers Baner Pune

Packers and Movers Pashan Pune

Packers and Movers Fatima Nagar Pune

Packers and Movers Warje Pune

Packers and Movers Kothrud Pune

Packers and Movers Wagholi Pune





Kajal Singh said...

Best Packers and Movers Pune Lists

Packers and Movers Pune

Packers and Movers Aundh Pune

Packers and Movers Hadapsar Pune

Packers and Movers Magarpatta Pune

Packers and Movers Pimple Saudagar Pune

Packers and Movers Viman Nagar Pune

Packers and Movers Wakad Pune

Packers and Movers Kharadi Pune

Packers and Movers Hinjewadi Pune

Packers and Movers Baner Pune

Packers and Movers Pashan Pune

Packers and Movers Fatima Nagar Pune

Packers and Movers Warje Pune

Packers and Movers Kothrud Pune

Packers and Movers Wagholi Pune




Anton alfaruq said...

Thank you very much! My friends and family members will be happy after hearing about this
jam tangan online murah
jam tangan murah
jam tangan kw
jam tangan online

Anton alfaruq said...

Thanks a lot for sharing. Will check back later for more of your articles.
http://jam-tanganonline.org
http://grosir-bajuanak.net
http://tokotasbrandedonline.com
http://jamtangan-wanita.org

Anton alfaruq said...

Things are very open and intensely clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very beneficial.
http://www.glenncolton.com
http://www.prettysocial.net
http://penjualanjamtanganonline.com

Anton alfaruq said...

thanks for his articel can menembah my insight on the internet,
http://cintaakik.blogspot.com
http://gemstone-x.blogspot.com
http://portalbisnis-online.blogspot.com
http://kolektor-batuakik.blogspot.com
http://koleksibatu-akik.blogspot.com

Obat Hot said...


Obat Pembesar Penis Alat Pembesar Penis
Obat Pembesar
Obat Pembesar Alat Vital Pemanjang Penis
Jual Obat Pembesar Penis Toko Obat Penis
Pembesar Penis Vacum Pembesar Penis
Obat Pembesar Vimax Obat Vimax Asli
Obat Penis Pembesar Kelamin

Obat Perangsang Wanita Perangsang Wanita
Perangsang Wanita Perangsang
jual Obat Perangsang Wanita jual Obat Perangsang
jual Perangsang Wanita jual Perangsang
Toko Perangsang Wanita Toko Obat Perangsang Wanita
Obat Perangsang sex Obat Perangsang Wanita manjur

Alat Bantu Sex Alat Sex Alat Bantu
Toko Alat Bantu Sex Alat Sex Murah Alat Dildo
Alat Bantu Pria Alat Bantu Wanita Dildo Silikon
Mainan Dewasa Sex Mainan Sex

lionelmessi10 said...

Informasi kesehatan dari kemaluan keluar nanah obat kemaluan keluar nanah kemaluan keluar nanah Informasi obat herbal obat penyakit sifilis obat penyakit sifilis penyakit sifilis raja singa penyakit sifilis raja singa

KAK DECO said...

I agree and disagree. It's possible the issue is form v. substance. But I don't think it's insignificant that Roberts is Chief Justice.Jam Tangan Online Murah I think the CJ historically has responsibility for the overall reputation of the Court. Perhaps he didn't want to be known as the leader of a conservative super-legislature that decided a lot of key cases on 5-4 votes . . . although on the last point perhaps he failed.

Anton alfaruq said...

Thanks for Nice and Informative Post. This article is really contains lot more information about This Topic. -
hidup sehat alamai

Sweta Singh said...

Hair Transplant in India
Visit for more details: -
Hair Transplant Kolkata @ http://www.hairtransplantkolkata.top5th.co.in/
Hair Transplant Mumbai @ http://www.hairtransplantmumbai.top5th.co.in/
Hair Transplant Delhi @ http://www.hairtransplantdelhi.top5th.co.in/
Hair Transplant Mumbai @ http://www.hairtransplantmumbai.top5th.co.in/
Hair Transplant Pune @ http://www.hairtransplantpune.top5th.co.in/
Hair Transplant Bangalore @ http://www.hairtransplantbangalore.top5th.co.in/
Hair Transplant Kolkata @ http://ad-vision.in/hair-transplant-kolkata/
Hair Transplant Delhi @ http://ad-vision.in/hair-transplant-delhi/
Hair Transplant Bangalore @ http://ad-vision.in/hair-transplant-Bangalore/
Hair Transplant Mumbai @ http://ad-vision.in/hair-transplant-mumbai/
Hair Transplant Pune @ http://ad-vision.in/hair-transplant-pune/
Hair Transplant Chennai @ http://ad-vision.in/hair-transplant-chennai/
Hair Transplant Hyderabad @ http://ad-vision.in/hair-transplant-hyderabad/

Sweta Singh said...

Additionally it is an opportunity giving a person by far the most manage.
Visit for more details: -
Packers and Movers Hyderabad @ Hyderabad Packers and Movers @ Movers and Packers Hyderabad @ http://www.top5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-hyderabad/
Packers and Movers Chennai @ Chennai Packers and Movers @ Movers and Packers Chennai @ http://www.top5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-chennai/
Packers and Movers Bangalore @ Bangalore Packers and Movers @ Movers and Packers Bangalore @ http://www.top5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-bangalore/
Packers and Movers Mumbai @ Mumbai Packers and Movers @ Movers and Packers Mumbai @ http://www.top5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-mumbai/
Packers and Movers Noida @ Noida Packers and Movers @ Movers and Packers Noida @ http://www.top5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-noida/
Packers and Movers Gurgaon @ Gurgaon Packers and Movers @ Movers and Packers Gurgaon @ http://www.top5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-gurgaon /
Packers and Movers Delhi @ Delhi Packers and Movers @ Movers and Packers Delhi @ http://www.top5th.co.in/packers-and-movers-delhi/

Sweta Singh said...

To save cash you will discover transferring bins from the local grocery stores as well as chemists. Should you have excellent carry out using grocery stores as well as chemists you are able to undoubtedly find bins freed from fees.
Visit for more details: -
Best Packers and Movers Delhi @ http://packersandmoversdelhi.best5th.co.in/
Best Packers and Movers Noida @ http://packersandmoversnoida.best5th.co.in/
Best Packers and Movers Gurgaon @ http://packersandmoversgurgaon.best5th.co.in/
Best Packers and Movers Hyderabad @ http://packersandmovershyderabad.best5th.co.in/
Best Packers and Movers Bangalore @ http://packersandmoversbangalore.best5th.co.in/
Best Packers and Movers Mumbai @ http://packersandmoversmumbai.best5th.co.in/
Best Packers and Movers Chennai @ http://packersandmoverschennai.best5th.co.in/
Best Packers and Movers Pune @ http://packersandmoverspune.best5th.co.in/
Packers and Movers Hyderabad @ http://packersandmovers-hydeabad.in/
Packers and Movers Bangalore @ http://packersandmovers-bangalore.in/
Packers and Movers Delhi @ http://packersandmovers-delhi.in/
Packers and Movers Pune @ http://packersandmovers-pune.in/

Sweta Singh said...

However picking a excellent transferring firm in Chennai gets to be also a big task in addition to tough activity.
Visit for more details: -
Packers and Movers Bangalore Or http://ad-vision.co.in/packersmoversbangalore.html
Packers and Movers Delhi Or http://ad-vision.co.in/packersmoversdelhi.html
Packers and Movers Gurgaon Or http://ad-vision.co.in/packersmoversgurgaon.html
Packers and Movers Hyderabad Or http://ad-vision.co.in/packersmovershyderabad.html
Packers and Movers Mumbai Or http://ad-vision.co.in/packersmoversmumbai.html
Packers and Movers Navi Mumbai Or http://ad-vision.co.in/packersmoversnavimumbai.html
Packers and Movers Noida Or http://ad-vision.co.in/packersmoversnoida.html
Packers and Movers Pune Or http://ad-vision.co.in/packersmoverspune.html
Top Packers and Movers Bangalore
Top Packers and Movers Chandigarh
Top Packers and Movers Chennai
Top Packers and Movers Delhi
Top Packers and Movers Gurgaon
Top Packers and Movers Hyderabad
Top Packers and Movers Kolkata
Top Packers and Movers Mumbai
Top Packers and Movers Noida
Top Packers and Movers Pune

Sweta Singh said...

The most significant issues in order to inquire is concerning the particular solutions conducted because of the movers.
Visit for more details: -
Top 5 Packers and Movers Bangalore Or http://www.packersandmoversbangalore.top5th.co.in/
Top 5 Packers and Movers Chandigarh Or http://www.packersandmoverschandigarh.top5th.co.in/
Top 5 Packers and Movers Chennai Or http://www.packersandmoverschennai.top5th.co.in/
Top 5 Packers and Movers Delhi Or http://www.packersandmoversdelhi.top5th.co.in/
Top 5 Packers and Movers Gurgaon Or http://www.packersandmoversgurgaon.top5th.co.in/
Top 5 Packers and Movers Hyderabad Or http://www.packersandmovershyderabad.top5th.co.in/
Top 5 Packers and Movers Kolkata Or http://www.packersandmoverskolkata.top5th.co.in/
Top 5 Packers and Movers Mumbai Or http://www.packersandmoversmumbai.top5th.co.in/
Top 5 Packers and Movers Noida Or http://www.packersandmoversnoida.top5th.co.in/
Top 5 Packers and Movers Pune Or http://www.packersandmoverspune.top5th.co.in/

arish h said...

Wow what a nice post thanks for sharing such a great information. Movers packers provides you best services according to your need and take care of your pocket. packers and movers in jaipur . packers and movers jaipur

Joseph Chilson said...

Good post

متولي رمضان said...


شركة نقل اثاث بالدمام
شركة نقل اثاث بجدة
شركة نقل اثاث بمكة
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض
شركة نقل اثاث بالمدينة
شركة مكافحة حشرات بجدة
شركة رش مبيدات بجدة
شركة مكافحة الحشرات بمكة
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة رش مبيدات بالدمام
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بجدة
شركة تسربات بالدمام
شركة تنظيف بجدة
شركة تنظيف فلل بالدمام شركة تنظيف شقق بالدمام
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض

متولي رمضان said...


شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض
شركة تنظيف بالخرج
شركة تنظيف فلل بجدة
شركة تنظيف شقق بجدة
شركة تنظيف خزانات بجدة
شركة تنظيف منازل بجدة
شركة تنظيف بالدمام
شركة تنظيف شقق بالدمام
شركة تنظيف فلل بالدمام
شركة تنظيف بمكة
شركة تنظيف بالطائف
شركة تنظيف وعزل خزانات بمكة
شركة تنظيف بمكة
شركة تنظيف وعزل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة
شركة تنظيف فلل بمكة
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالبخار بمكة
شركة تنظيف بالمدينة المنورة

hari sh said...

Thank you for posting this information and Very good looking blog. I share this post to all my friends. packers and movers Bangalore marathahalli . packers and movers in bangalore movers and packers hyderabad

Pusat Les Privat said...

This website is really wonderful . If you need this
guru Les privat di Surabaya
guru les privat ke rumah di Surabaya
Les privat guru ke rumah siswa di Jogja
rental mobil di Pare
ojek dan rental motor di Pare kampung inggris
rental motor dan ojek di Pare Kediri
Kursus Bahasa Inggris di Pare Kediri
guru les privat bahasa inggris ke rumah
Les privat Surabaya
Guru les privat TK di Surabaya
Les privat untuk SD di Surabaya
Les privat SMP/MTS di Surabaya
Les privat SMA/MA/SMK di Surabaya
Les privat TK,SD,SMP,SMA,Mahasiswa,Karyawan, dan Umum di Surabaya
Penyedia Guru les privat semua mata pelajaran di surabaya
Guru privat ke rumah siswa di Surabaya

jaring futsal dan rumput futsal said...

Nice article, thanks for the information. It's very complete information. I will bookmark for next reference
jaring futsal | jaring golf | jaring pengaman proyek |
jaring pengaman bangunan | jaring pengaman gedung
http://www.jual-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://www.agen-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://www.pancasamudera-safetynet.blogspot.com/
http://www.toko-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://www.pusat-jaring.blogspot.com/
http://jualjaringpengaman.blogspot.com/
https://pancasamudera.wordpress.com/
https://pasangjaringfutsal.wordpress.com/
https://jualtambangmurah.wordpress.com/
https://tokojaring.wordpress.com/
https://jualjaringfutsal.wordpress.com/
https://jaringfutsal.wordpress.com/

albaraak said...

شراء اثاث مستعمل بالرياض
شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بالرياض
ارقام اثاث مستعمل بالرياض
حقين اثاث مستعمل بالرياض
حقين الاثاث المستعمل
محلات شراء الاثاث المستعمل

albaraak said...

شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض
شركة تنظيف بيوت بالرياض
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض
شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض
شراء الاثاث المستعمل بالرياض
ارقام اثاث مستعمل بالرياض
شراء اثاث مستعمل بشمال الرياض
شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بالرياض
شراء الاثاث المستعمل
حقين اثاث مستعمل بالرياض
حقين الاثاث المستعمل
محلات شراء الاثاث المستعمل بالرياض

albaraak said...

شركة مكافحة حشرات بجده
مكافحة حشرات بجده
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة مكافحة حشرات ببريده
مكافحة حشرات ببريده
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالقصيم
مكافحة حشرات بالقصيم
شركة تنظيف بالرياض
شركة المستقبل
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض
مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض
شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض
شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض

albaraak said...

شركة مكافحة حشرات بجده
مكافحة حشرات بجده
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة مكافحة حشرات ببريده
مكافحة حشرات ببريده
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالقصيم
مكافحة حشرات بالقصيم
شركة تنظيف بالرياض
شركة المستقبل
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض
مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض
شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض
شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض

Maman Seo said...

information that is very valuable to me ! good luck and verygood website دانلود فیلتر شکن

Maman Seo said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Maman Seo said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Maman Seo said...

information that is very valuable to me ! good luck and verygood website دانلود فیلتر شکن

Lamiss Ibrahim said...

Hello! I just want to offer you a huge thumbs up for the excellent info you have right here on this post. I'll be returning to your blog for more soon.
Cheers,


http://www.prokr.com/blog/

http://www.albyaan.com/

http://www.elbassma.net/

http://www.prokr.com/furniture-moving-company-riyadh/

http://www.prokr.com/cleaning-company-riyadh/

http://www.prokr.com/water-leaks-detection-isolate-company-riyadh/

Lamiss Ibrahim said...

Hello! I just want to offer you a huge thumbs up for the excellent info you have right here on this post. I'll be returning to your blog for more soon.
Cheers,


http://www.prokr.com/blog/

http://www.albyaan.com/

http://www.elbassma.net/

http://www.prokr.com/furniture-moving-company-riyadh/

http://www.prokr.com/cleaning-company-riyadh/

http://www.prokr.com/water-leaks-detection-isolate-company-riyadh/

arr harish said...

Thanks for sharing good information about movers and packers this post.i appreciate your effort for do this work. packers and movers marathahalli bangalore

Anna Watson said...

A really impressive post and i loved it so much..You just have nailed it..Assignment writing service

albaraak said...

شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة رش مبيدات بالدمام
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالدمام
شركة مكافحة حشرات بجده
شركة رش مبيات بجدة
شركة تنظيف بالدمام
شركة تنظيف منازل بالدمام
شركة تنظيف فلل بالدمام
شركة تنظيف شقق بالدمام
شركة تنظيف بيوت بالدمام
شركة تسيلك مجاري بالدمام
شركة تنظيف بيارات بالدمام

albaraak said...

شركة مكافحة حشرات بالقصيم
شركة رش مبيدات بالقصيم
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالقصيم
شركة مكافحة حشرات ببريده
شركة رش مبيدات ببريده
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض ببريده
————————————————————————————
شركة مكافحة حشرات بحائل
شركة رش مبيدات بحائل
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بحائل

albaraak said...

شركة نقل اثاث بالمدينه
شركة نقل عفش بالمدينه
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالمدينه
شركة رش مبيدات بالمدينه
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالمدينه
شركة تنظيف بالمدينه
شركة تنظيف منازل بالمدينه
شركة تنظيف شقق بالمدينه
————————————————————————————
شركة نقل اثاث بمكة
شركة نقل عفش بمكه
شركة مكافحة حشرات بمكه
شركة رش مبيدات بمكه
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بمكه

albaraak said...

تنظيم المؤتمرات

شركات تنظيم الحفلات في جدة

شركات تنظيم مؤتمرات

تنظيم مناسبات رياضية

تنظيم مهرجانات

تنظيم مؤتمر ناجح

الحفلات والمناسبات

تجهيز المعارض

تنظيم حفل

شركات تنظيم الحفلات

شركات تنظيم المعارض

لتنظيم المعارض والمؤتمرات

تنظيم الحفلات والمناسبات والمؤتمرات

تنظيم مهرجانات بالرياض

تنظيم مهرجانات بجدة

تنظيم حفلات تخرج

شركة تنظيم مؤتمرات بالرياض

شركة تنظيم حفلات بالرياض

تنظيم حفلات تخرج

تنظيم معرض

تنظيم مؤتمرات

شركة تنظيم حفلات بجدة

شركة تنظيم مؤتمرات بجدة

تنظيم مؤتمرات بجدة

albaraak said...

شراء اثاث مستعمل بالرياض
شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بالرياض
ارقام الاثاث المستعمل بالرياض
محلات شراء الاثاث المستعمل بالرياض
حقين الاثاث المستعمل بالرياض
شركة تنظيف بالرياض
شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض
شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض
شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض

شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض

تخزين اثاث بالرياض

Bambang Wisanggeni said...

obat kanker payudara herbal
obat herbal untuk kanker payudara yang manjur
obat herbal untuk kanker paru-paru
obat herbal untuk kanker prostat
obat herbal yang manjur untuk kanker serviks/rahim
obat kanker serviks yang ampuh

احمد محمد said...

شركة تنظيف بالدمام
شركة تنظيف فلل بالدمام
شركة تنظيف شقق بالدمام
شركة تنظيف قصور بالدمام
شركة تنظيف منازل بالدمام
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالدمام
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة رش مبيدات بالدمام
شركة تسليك مجارى بالدمام
شركة تنظيف بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف فلل بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف قصور بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف شقق بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف منازل بالاحساء

احمد محمد said...

شركة تنظيف بالدمام
شركة تنظيف فلل بالدمام
شركة تنظيف شقق بالدمام
شركة تنظيف قصور بالدمام
شركة تنظيف منازل بالدمام
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالدمام
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة رش مبيدات بالدمام
شركة تسليك مجارى بالدمام
شركة تنظيف بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف فلل بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف قصور بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف شقق بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف منازل بالاحساء

obat herbal said...

Obat kencing Nanah De Nature Obat Herbal obat Kutil Kelaminobat penyakit sipilis pada wanita penyakit sipilis pada lelaki penyakit sipilis pada wanita mengobati penyakit sipilis secara alami

Hamza Najjar said...

شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض

شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض

شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض

شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض

شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض

شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض

شركة رش مبيدات بالدمام

شركة تنظيف فلل بالدمام

شركة تنظيف شقق بالدمام

شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض

deky ardita said...


very interesting topic. I really enjoi read. thank you for sharing
Financialnewss.com
|www.lagingetren.com
| http://seribu-manfaat.blogspot.com
| jualsepatuonlinemurah.com
| http://taswanitabrandedterbaru.com
| http://raja-akik.blogspot.com
| http://harga-batuakikterbaru.blogspot.com
| http://penggemarbatucincin.blogspot.com