Wednesday, February 03, 2010

How Public Opinion Influences Judicial Decision Making

By Mike Dorf

As I noted last week, I recently attended a conference on The Judiciary and the Popular Will.  In my earlier post on the conference, I previewed my paper.  Here I'll say a little bit about some of the other papers.

The presenters included a fair number of political scientists and poli-sci-oriented law profs.  Both groups were interested in measuring the size of the effect of public opinion on Supreme Court decision making and the mechanism by which it is transmitted.  Supporting data will come eventually in the published papers, but a preliminary observation is in order: I was surprised by the degree to which the number crunchers found evidence of a direct effect of public opinion on Supreme Court decisions.  I had taken for granted that the chief mechanism by which public opinion influences the Court is judicial appointments: Presidents select and Senates confirm Justices who, broadly speaking, share the public's values.  Nothing I learned at the conference casts doubt on this phenomenon, but substantial evidence was also presented showing that individual Justices are responsive to public opinion over their careers.

Without posting the data and the regressions run, it's hard to make the point precisely.  It's also hard to distinguish between two phenomena: A) Justice X changes her mind on some question because she observes that public attitudes have changed; versus B) Justice Y, as a participant in the same culture as the population as a whole, changes his mind at roughly the same time that the public does.  With an important exception to which I'll return momentarily, rule-of-law values treat A) as highly questionable: judges are supposed to decide cases according to the law, not public opinion.  By contrast, anyone who is remotely realistic will acknowledge that B) is routine.

Now a word on the exception.  Some doctrines expressly take account of public opinion or something related to it.  For example, under the 8th Amendment, a punishment is impermissibly "cruel and unusual" if it offends "the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society."  Thus, we can explain the Supreme Court's decisions in the 1970s--first invalidating the death penalty in Furman v. Georgia and then validating new death penalty statutes in Gregg v. Georgia and companion cases--as a process of self-correction: The Justices thought that society had evolved away from the death penalty, but the legislative reaction to Furman showed that it hadn't, and so the Court adjusted in Gregg.

However, outside the context of legal tests that directly incorporate some notion of public opinion or widely shared values, Justices are quite reluctant to acknowledge a direct role for public opinion.  There may well be one--and some of the examples of quick retreats by the Court or individual Justices, without a change in personnel, strongly suggest that public opinion is directly playing such a role.  So too, a large-n study correlating the liberal-versus-conservative "public mood" with liberal or conservative outcomes tends to support the inference of direct impact on Justices' decisions.  But even there, one could hypothesize instead that the Justices are part of the same mood swing so that rather than reacting to the public change of heart, they simply share it.

Two nice test cases that show how hard it is to tease out the difference between Justices reacting to public opinion and Justices changing their own mind are the two living retired Justices: O'Connor and Souter.  Both Justices O'Connor and Souter became generally more liberal over the course of their respective time on the Court, even as the public mood yo-yo'ed a bit.  Moreover, in much of the same period, other Justices, such as Scalia and Thomas, did not become more liberal.  It is thus hard to attribute the ideological drift of either O'Connor or Souter to broad factors affecting the society as a whole or to micro-shifts in public opinion on particular issues.

At the same time, however, it is by now a commonplace that Justice O'Connor had a knack for reflecting public opinion better even than elected legislators.  Whether that was entirely due to her middle-of-the-road sensibility or a mixture of her own attitude and an eye on public opinion is extraordinarily difficult to figure out.  It's quite likely that Justice O'Connor herself doesn't know.

Thus, I came away from the conference thinking that there is a very large research agenda for someone interested in figuring out how public opinion gets translated into judicial decisions.  I also think that research agenda will be very challenging to pursue.  The political scientists' measures of decided cases--in order to produce statistically significant results--must wash out all sorts of legal and doctrinal nuances that make a large difference in particular cases.  A complete picture of the decision making process in the Supreme Court (or other courts) would require expertise in statistics, law, psychology, and likely several other disciplines.  Whether insights from these fields can be successfully synthesized remains to be seen.

28 comments:

徵信社 推薦 said...

徵信,徵信,徵信公司,徵信評鑑,徵信網,抓姦,外遇,討債公司,離婚,外遇,婚姻諮詢,離婚,離婚訴訟,捉姦,外遇,徵信社,徵信公司,徵信公司,外遇,尋人查址,外遇蒐證,徵信社,徵信社,徵信公司,台中徵信,台中徵信,台中徵信,台中徵信,台中徵信社,台中徵信社,台中徵信社,台中徵信社,台北徵信,台北徵信,台北徵信社,台北徵信,台北徵信社,台北徵信,台北徵信社,台北徵信社

徵信社 推薦 said...

護貝機,護貝機,碎紙機,護貝機維修,護貝膠膜,護貝問與答,台中徵信社,台中徵信,外遇,徵信,徵信社,尋人,尋人網,尋人網,徵信,外遇,抓姦,徵信社,徵信,徵信社,婚姻諮詢,私家偵探,偵探社,免費法律諮詢,徵信社,捉姦,抓姦,尋人,大陸徵信,徵信社,外遇,離婚,徵信社,離婚,分手,徵信協會,尋人查址,尋人,徵信公司,商業徵信

Sam Rickless said...

One thought about the differences between Scalia and O'Connor. One of the reasons why O'Connor's decisions are more likely to reflect the prevailing mores is that her judicial philosophy, inasmuch as she has one, is less moored in an inflexible and all-encompassing theory of constitutional interpretation that is itself militantly unresponsive to public opinion than is Scalia's.

goodsasa33 said...


監視器


監視器材


手機訊號強波器


亂剪
 雷門刺青

京王監視器
 大哥大訊號強波器  網站SEO

Stella亂剪旗艦店

網站排名首頁

برامج said...

i realist the differences now thanks
الاندرويد

Dolphin said...

CC
健康的身體和充實的人生^^
防水 抓漏 防水工程 抓漏工程 蛋糕 彌月蛋糕 塑膠棧板 棧板 棧板 塑膠棧板 棧板 塑膠棧板 棧板 塑膠棧板 熱水器 太陽能 整形 眼袋 隆鼻 隆乳 拉皮 抽脂 雙眼皮 玻尿酸 果凍矽膠 格子 格子王 格子舖 團購 公仔 公仔製作 公仔模型 公仔設計 SEO 關鍵字 關鍵字排名 網頁設計 網路行銷 網站排名 網頁優化 SEO

Dolphin said...

DD
最佳的社群網站就在這裡
老酒 老酒收購 老酒 老酒收購 樟芝 納豆 天麻 扭力板手 隔熱紙 大樓隔熱紙 回頭車 貨運公司 百達翡麗 勞力士 江詩丹頓 沛納海 IWC 歐米茄 高仿手錶 百達翡麗 勞力士 江詩丹頓 沛納海 IWC 歐米茄 高仿手錶 防水 抓漏 防水工程 抓漏工程 宜蘭民宿 民宿 植髮 雷射溶脂 瘦小腹 瘦小腿 自體脂肪隆乳 植睫毛 微針抽脂 SEO 關鍵字 關鍵字排名 網頁設計 網路行銷 網站排名 網頁優化

茉莉 said...

台灣美麗澎湖民宿西衛海推薦 合法徵信公司評鑑 澎湖民宿推薦,住在菊島最舒適的民宿裡.徵信社擁有強大的調查資源,徵信探員幫助你釐清工商真象.

生活中你有無法解決的問題?徵信社的幫助是屬於私力救濟範疇,是有償收費服務,主要是民事類和商務類事務的調查取證服務。徵信社滿足您徵信調查的需求。

茉莉 said...

Taiwan free law 080:0800-223-500 please visit 法律諮詢,提供免費法律諮詢,全國法律網

yantingwho said...

傷感,歡樂魚訊這兩個字,讓心突然的顫抖了一下,也許,外送茶坊說不清是那串音符觸動了我的靈魂,台南援-交line很想在此刻此時壹個人按摩個人工作室靜靜地品味傷感。傳播小姐內心的傷感是最真的流露,壹種情緒最一夜情網站自然最真實展示的別樣情懷,在孤立無援中更感孤獨和寂寞茶訊。於是,憂傷的心緒慢慢外出按摩占據了腦海,約砲社團浸潤心靈的深處……

yantingwho said...

不知從什麽時候開始台中援交妹,我習慣在靜靜的夜裏,想象著妳遙遠的笑容,新竹按摩全套感覺裏妳一夜情總會有壹種溫和儒雅的氣質,一夜情論壇妳應該是熱情洋溢的,妳應該是成熟內斂的,但妳有時可能也豪氣沖天。半套沒有人理解我們之間的那種感覺,舒壓按摩既遠又近,既深刻又平淡,台中按摩連我自己都不能理解自己的心約砲網

  每當,桃園茶訊夜深人靜時,思念就像是一種找炮友毒藥,越想戒掉,越是上癮,茶訊而我卻極力掩藏,台北一夜情逞強的想做隱君子,外約可是在思念裏越陷越深,越走越遠……台北援交思念就像是春天種下的種子,是等待其生長的援交妹漫長過程。

高合金鋼 said...

人生短暫約砲,百年易逝,如白駒過隙。高雄外送茶看壹江春水向東去,滾滾兩岸留不住。時光似水,滾滾東流去,再無回首日魚訊。流走過後,外約按摩只剩下壹片靜謐,有待於炮友我們靜靜品味叫小姐

高合金鋼 said...

此刻,外送茶不再有浮躁不安的情緒援交,只留下了一片外送茶 靜美的時光一夜情聊天室 與心的距離更加貼近,茶訊 與愛的口味更加外送茶對口按摩全套 。靜靜的呼一口長氣傳播小姐 ,頓時春暖花開,阡陌相美。

高合金鋼 said...

思念不過是簡簡單單的台北魚訊兩個字而已,一夜情留言板然而它卻是愛的升華,我不知道起重量,但我卻知道其能量可以台北魚訊讓人無休止的等待、等待。思念,我唯壹能做的就是台北一夜情平靜的等待和思念,和妳在壹起,我真的很快樂,免費魚訊 我不想生氣,但有時卻不能自我,魚訊網站我是不是太計較了,還是……當我最無助最傷心援-交line的時候,免費魚訊我不想讓妳看到我的悲傷,在妳外送茶坊面前我要做快樂的自己。

工發給 said...

其實,外送茶在我們的生活裏,外送茶莊並不是因爲不快樂而台北一夜情憂傷,不是因爲不懂得珍惜和援-交line失去了才憂傷,指油壓全套也不是因爲不幸福才憂傷;或許,壹曲憂傷的音樂,壹段感人的文字,援-交line壹個傷感的畫面,魚訊都會讓人有淡淡的憂傷,援交妹讓人感受著外約其中的唯美,台中援交這也許台北援交就是壹種與一夜情留言板生具有的情緒吧!

哈哈哈 said...

直立約砲公寓行走,龐大的驚人,身高比肩外送茶坊山嶽,渾身沒有毛發,通體密布著外送茶坊金色的鱗片,熠熠生輝。面部很平,只有壹只豎眼,開合間像鐘點情人是壹道金色的閃電劃過,犀利懾人。整體血氣如海,應召站 宛如壹尊神魔!它路過此地,看了壹眼老柳木,稍作停留後,似乎急於叫小姐趕路,最終快速遠去,外約按摩許多山峰被其腳步震的轟鳴,山地劇烈顫抖。黎明,壹條十米長、水桶粗、銀光燦燦的蜈蚣在按摩山中蜿蜒而行,約砲像是白銀澆鑄而成,每壹節都鋥亮而猙獰, 劃過山石時鏗鏘作響,火星飛濺。但最終舒壓按摩它卻避過了石村,沒有侵入,所過之處黑霧約砲公寓翻騰,萬獸避退。壹根散發著瑩瑩綠霞的柔弱柳條在風中輕輕搖曳……

高合金鋼 said...

How Public援交 Opinion Influences Judicial Decision Making 外送茶莊By Mike Dorf As I noted last week, I recently一夜情聊天室 attended a conference on The Judiciary 援交and the Popular Will. In my earlier post 魚訊論壇on the conference, I previewed my paper.

高合金鋼 said...

美好一夜情桃園援交,桃園一夜情,一夜情桃園外送茶的忌憚的幾天,姚嵐豐韻的胴體指油壓和緊窄的嫩穴給我帶來的快樂讓人回味無窮,我外送茶也很渴望再次把我粗壯的指油壓肉棒深深的插入姚嵐緊窄潤滑的陰道,援交渴望再次把我積蓄已久的濃精重重的炮友射入姚嵐溫暖而充滿活力高雄援交的子宮。

高合金鋼 said...

鐘點情人優質外送茶莊最高級外約服務,援交妹本站擁有各式各樣的外送茶,我們依照您的需求指油壓外出提供全套服務,援交line陪您玩的開心,最平價的消費指油壓外出,卻讓您擁有六星級,帝王般的享受,外送茶坊給你不一樣的享受。按摩個人工作室茶訊論壇、魚訊論壇交易方式:台中茶訊免轉帳、免匯款、指油壓免受騙

amine lahragui said...


thanks so much for that great blog and thanks also for accepting my links thanks
طريقة عمل الدونات طريقة عمل البان كيك طريقة عمل الكنافة طريقة عمل البسبوسة طريقة عمل الكيك طريقة عمل عجينة البيتزا فوائد القرفه
thanks so much i like very so much your post
فوائد الحلبة فوائد الزنجبيل فوائد الرمان فوائد زيت السمسم علاج البواسير فوائد البصل فوائد اليانسون فوائد الكركم فوائد الزعتر قصص جحا تعريف الحب علامات الحمل

aminos lahragui said...


thanks so much i like very so much your post
حلى الاوريو الفطر الهندي صور تورته حلى قهوه طريقة عمل السينابون طريقة عمل بلح الشام بيتزا هت كيكة الزبادي حلا سهل صور كيك عجينة العشر دقائق

高合金鋼 said...

諫, 高雄援交舊時指對君主、台北援交尊長的言行提出批評或勸告:規諫、進諫。 1基本資訊一夜情 諫 拼音:jiàn 註音:ㄐㄧㄢˋ “諫”的3中篆書寫法(3張)外送茶 簡體部首:訁,部外筆畫:9,總筆畫:11 台北援交繁體部首:言 五筆86:YGLI 五筆98:YGLI 應召女倉頡:IVDWF 鄭碼:SFLK 看了這篇文章這些區域該如何做選擇? 避免畢生心血泡沫化,炮友懇請諫言 新北市:迴避淡水、林口,聚焦鶯歌、援交日記土城 黃琴雅 一夜情援交近幾年台北市房價高漲,應召女讓許多台北市民在新北市外送茶莊購屋。據房仲業統計,援交妹 每年約有五分之一外送茶莊的台北客往新北市搬援交妹,也因為外送茶莊

高合金鋼 said...

Q:你說全世界核能都是最貴茶訊,台灣不值得為它冒險,援-交line可是停掉核電,不會缺電嗎? A:台灣電太多了一夜情留言板,才會超過兩成機組發電是零。援魚且台電為省一個電壓器,採用open delta的變壓器系統,魚訊結果製造電壓不平衡,使馬達用戶浪費約砲立委補選國民黨再度失敗後,曾批評馬英九「叫小姐比崇禎皇帝還不如」的政論家南方朔,台北援交與經濟日報總主筆馬凱台中援交、前海基會董事長洪奇昌、外送茶環球經濟評論社社長台中援交林建山聯名提出「四野人萬言書」,台中援交對馬英九及金溥聰魚訊論壇的施政品質批得約砲社團

obat herbal said...

penyakit sipilis disebabkan oleh bakteri gejala penyakit sipilis raja singa pencegahan penyakit sifilis raja singa ciri ciri penyakit sipilis raja singa

wasirdenature said...

obat kemaluan keluar nanah dan obat kencing nanah wanita dan obat herbal gonore dan obat kemaluan keluar nanah dan obat herbal kencing nanah dan obat kencing nanah di apotik dan obat gonore resep dokter dan obat kencing nanah di apotik dan obat herbal gonore dan cara menyembuhkan wasir dan obat peyakit wasir dan obat herbal wasir dan obat wasir alami dan obat wasir atau ambeien merupakan solusi pengobatan herbal dari denature indonesia

herbal medicine said...

obat kemaluan keluar nanah dan obat kencing nanah wanita dan obat herbal gonore dan obat kemaluan keluar nanah dan obat herbal kencing nanah dan obat kencing nanah di apotik dan obat gonore resep dokter dan obat kencing nanah di apotik dan obat herbal gonore dan cara menyembuhkan wasir dan obat peyakit wasir dan obat herbal wasir dan obat wasir alami dan obat wasir atau ambeien merupakan solusi pengobatan herbal dari denature indonesia

obat herbal said...

cara membuat vagina rapat dan kencang cara membuat vagina tetap keset dan cara membuat vagina tetap keset gejala herpes genital herbal herpes kelamin cara mengobati penyakit herpes kelamin obat herpes di kemaluan obat herpes

Nay Denature said...

Obat kencing Nanah De Nature Obat Herbal obat Kutil Kelaminpengobatan penyakit herpes kelamin cara mengobati herpes kelamin obat kanker obat kanker payudara