The Anti-Corruption Agenda and the Pro-American Tax Man
How can the newly ascendant Democrats show that they truly heard voters' cries against America's corrupt, hyperrich, oligarchic class? And how can they do so without triggering the uber-cautious (to the point of political malpractice) Democratic establishment players like Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer? One answer, perhaps surprisingly, is to make it clear that the days of unbridled tax evasion by billionaires will be over if Democrats win in 2028.
In this very short column, I want to lay down a marker for future columns. In those columns, I will expand on a simple argument: It is perhaps counterintuitive, but there is enormous value in a Democratic strategy of "fronting and centering" the deep injustice of Republicans' efforts to allow wealthy taxpayers to both evade and avoid taxes -- that is, to outright cheat and to game the political system to make cheating "legal in a technical sense."
In the midst of the attempts by all sides to spin the midterm results in whatever way necessary to confirm any particular commentator's priors, one of the few points of broad agreement has been that voters of all ideologies were expressing their disgust with corruption among America's elites -- both political elites and financial/business elites.
And the one thing that everyone understands down to their bones is that although almost all Americans might say that they hate paying taxes (while simultaneously understanding that "taxes are the price we pay for civilization"), cheating on taxes is nearly impossible for the vast majority of people with regular jobs, while we all correctly believe that the richest people in the world regularly and shamelessly game the tax system.
In his substack column today, Paul Krugman pointed out that Democrats should try to bring the IRS's decrepit and DOGE-incapacitated enforcement of high-end taxes into the 21st Century (or at least past the 1960's). He described what should be the most mundane of reasons that this is important, that is, that the Democrats have policy ideas (restoring health care and food aid supplements, among other important goals) that will cost at least a non-trivial amount of money to bring to life. Empowering the IRS at long last to be able to do its job will bring in the money that is needed to fund those essential policies. He also pointed out that if (emphasis to reflect my skepticism) there is a long-term budget deficit problem, simply collecting the taxes that we should already be collecting is the most straightforward way to come up with hundreds of billions of dollars of revenue every year.
Again, however, I think that the best political argument to support all of this is that simply enforcing the law without favor to the oligarchs is political gold. The closest Krugman came to making that point is to say that "there’s the moral rot caused by a system in which crime pays — because cheating on one’s taxes is a crime." He is right about that, and I have no reason to think that what he wrote in inconsistent with my point here. Again, however, I think that it is crucial to view this explicitly -- and to sell this politically -- as a key part of a broader anti-corruption agenda.
In today's headline, I used the phrase "pro-American tax man." I did so to emphasize that there is a simple way to sell the collection of money from tax cheats as the quintessential starting point for fighting corruption. Even without getting into the muck about increasing income taxes, imposing wealth taxes, or any of those (genuinely) important debates, we can begin by calling out Republicans for enabling outright tax fraud.
I will have much more to say about this topic, and I hope to expand on these issues in the very near future. Today, however, I will say simply that one of the most promising strategies that would allow Democrats to demonstrate that they trying to deliver on the voters' anti-oligarch, anti-corruption mandate is to highlight the tax man's role in reining in the hyperrich.
There is clearly more to say about this. Much more. But I will save all of that for a later date.
- Neil H. Buchanan