The Value of Getting Things Wrong: A Backhanded But Sincere Tribute to Richard Posner
Here on the blog on Monday, Professor Segall offered a moving tribute to Judge Richard Posner, who died last week. Professor Segall was personally close with Judge Posner, but I do not think that his affection biased him. Put differently, I agree with Professor Segall about the astoundingly impressive career of Judge Posner. As I have noted in several places, I regard Posner as one of the two most important U.S. judges never to sit on the U.S. Supreme Court, along with Judge Learned Hand. Given that Posner was also an incredibly prolific scholar, Posner might well be deemed to occupy the top spot. Having said that, in today's essay, I want to make what might seem like the critical point that Judge Posner was often wrong. I do so for the purpose of situating him as fundamentally a public intellectual. I'll begin with some illustrations. The first involves Posner's book Sex and Reason , which is probably best described as offering sociobiological explanations (the "reas...