Monday, December 09, 2013

Gandhi, King, Mandela, and the Law

By Mike Dorf

The death of Nelson Mandela has understandably led to a worldwide outpouring of grief and admiration for a true giant.  Here I want to add a lawyer's take on how to think about his place in history.

As the title of this post suggests, it is tempting to think about Mandela as one of the few Twentieth Century world-historical figures who successfully battled injustice for his people through the espousal of universalist principles and non-violence. I think that is broadly accurate but that it leaves out some nuance.

Gandhi is sometimes said to have been an absolute pacifist.  After all, he opposed violence even by Jews against Nazis, as in this 1938 essay, and if one thinks that satyagraha is the right strategy in response to Nazis it's hard to see when one would advocate the use of force.  Still, the point is somewhat murky.  In Martin Buber's 1939 reply to Gandhi, Buber quoted a 1922 speech in which Gandhi said that he would prefer that India become free "even by violence rather than that she remain in bondage." Buber's point was that Gandhi himself recognized the need for political violence as a last resort in extremis and that therefore Gandhi's advice to Jews in Europe was inconsistent with Gandhi's own prior positions. (There is also a great deal of discussion of the role of Jews and Arabs in British Mandatory Palestine, which I treat as tangential here.) So it's possible that Gandhi's views evolved towards absolute nonviolence between 1922 and 1938, or perhaps that notwithstanding his 1938 statement with regard to the Nazis, Gandhi remained committed to the possibility that sometimes it would be acceptable to employ political violence.

Dr. King quite self-consciously traced his commitment to non-violence to the influence of Gandhi. His 1958 essay, My Pilgrimage to Nonviolence, is both a stunning demonstration of how, not that long ago, a great public figure could also unashamedly be a great intellectual, and the best defense of Gandhi's near-absolutism. King confronts the challenge that Buber laid down for Gandhi in the form of a similar challenge from Reinhold Niebuhr, who, echoing Buber, contended that satyagraha--as an appeal to the heart of the oppressor--can only work when the oppressor has a heart, as was true of British imperialists but not of Nazis. King's answer was that Niebuhr conceived of satyagraha as submission rather than as nonviolent resistance--an answer that I confess that I find unsatisfactory.  I think Niebuhr and Buber understood that nonviolent resistance can sometimes be a powerful and active tool, but that even aggressive nonviolence is sometimes insufficient to combat very great evils. King gave what I think was a better answer in his 1968 speech, Remaining Awake Through a Great Revolution, when he said that, in light of nuclear weapons, the choice is no longer "between violence and nonviolence. It is either nonviolence or nonexistence." And to be fair to King, perhaps he already had that idea in mind when, in the 1958 essay, he described "the pacifist position not as sinless but as the lesser evil . . . ."

Mandela's career makes the case that a principled commitment to nonviolence as a first, second and third choice nonetheless leaves room for the possibility that resort to violence may be justified as a last resort. In the last several days, numerous pundits have referred to Mandela as a "pragmatist," by which they tend to mean that Mandela did not elevate abstract principles over concrete results, even if it meant compromising with those whose beliefs and values he did not entirely share.  That's accurate and fair enough, but I would suggest that the characterization mistakenly opposes pragmatism to principle.  There are times when one rightly eschews compromise because to compromise would be to abandon a fundamental principle.  But there are many circumstances in which principle and pragmatism are compatible.

In his autobiography, The Long Walk to Freedom, Mandela explained that he came to advocate armed struggle by the ANC for two main reasons.  First, nonviolence was no longer working against a state that itself had become increasingly violent in cracking down on peaceful efforts to end apartheid. He wrote: "I used an old African expression: Sebatana ha se bokwe ka diatla (The attacks of the wild beast cannot be averted with only bare hands.)" And second, Mandela saw that some black, colored and anti-apartheid white South Africans were already taking up arms; he thought that the use of force would be both more effective and better calibrated (by targeting the government's physical assets rather than people) if coordinated by the ANC than if left to rogue individuals.

Is that a principled or a purely pragmatic stand? Mandela distinguished his own position from that of ANC President Albert Luthuli who had, in Mandela's words "a moral commitment to nonviolence." Reading those words, it is easy to think that Luthuli lived by the moral principle espoused by Gandhi and King, whereas Mandela only favored nonviolence opportunistically and situationally--that is, one can readily fall into the trap of contrasting pacifist principle with the supposed pragmatism of calibrated violence.

But I think the dichotomy is ultimately unfair, because Mandela's position was also very much a matter of moral principle.  Like Niebuhr, Buber and many others who reject pacifism but nonetheless generally aim at peace, Mandela thought that under certain circumstances, resort to violence was not only morally permissible but morally obligatory.

Looking back at Mandela's autobiography now, I am struck by how closely his views about the permissibility of violence track both the domestic law of self-defense and the international law of war. In both domains, force may be used in response to force, but only so long as it is necessary and proportionate--which seems to be the very principle that Mandela articulated in support of the ANC's resort to force.

I would like to say that Mandela took his principles from the law because he was a lawyer, but that would be too pat. Gandhi was also a lawyer (and, of course, during the formative years of his life, a resident of South Africa, albeit a full generation before Mandela), but as we have seen, Gandhi's views about violence and nonviolence differed substantially from those of Mandela.

Still, despite their differences, it is fair to say that legal training and experience practicing law honed the sense of justice that informed the life work of both Gandhi and Mandela.  And so, looking back, we lawyers have special reason to take inspiration from both of them. If I am right that two out of the last century's three greatest champions of civil rights were lawyers, we have at least the kernel of an answer to those who think the law an ignoble calling.


Patrick S. O'Donnell said...

Thanks for this clarificatory post Mike. You might be interested in my comments to two recent posts at Three Quarks Daily on this subject:


Michael C. Dorf said...

Patrick, thanks for the links, which I commend to readers interested in more detail about Mandela's sophisticated views and record with respect to violence.

Alexandria Skinner said...

Satyagraha depends for its effectiveness on the root of compassion that is shared by most humans. (I count compassion as a postulate in the equation, a given that comes as the result of being human.) It depends for its effectiveness on the existence of that factor. If it does not exist, nonviolence is futile because it is otherwise impossible to convert the heart of the oppressor -- it is impossible to make him confront the reality of his own evil if he is incapable of seeing it. If we fail to view the life of the "other" as having intrinsic value, we lack compassion for them. By way of illustration, I will state that this is why chickens are incapable of nonviolent direct action. We fail to value their lives or see them as equivalent in value to our own and, therefore, lack compassion for them no matter what they do to arouse it in us (for the most part). Mandela made the important point that the dominant culture dehumanized his people to the point that they were not considered as being equal in terms of humanity. To some extent, this dehumanization is a condition precedent of any oppressive system. But in some systems it is more deeply embedded than others.

Michael C. Dorf said...

Alexandria, thanks for your comment. I agree with much of what you say about how satyagraha works, but I disagree with your species criterion. Many non-human species exhibit behavior that, but for the human exceptionalist bias of many human observers , looks very much like compassion, both for their own kind and for members of other species. Obviously, the triggers vary.

I also think your chickens example is unhelpful or perhaps shows the opposite of what you intend. Chickens are incapable of nonviolent direct action because of the limits of their particular cognitive capacties. That doesn't make them ineligible for moral concern, although you are right that many people think it does. (Chickens are eligible for moral concern as moral patients, in much the same way that human infants and severely disabled humans are.)

Nonetheless, I imagine that if chickens were cognitively capable of organizing nonviolent direct action, that fact would so impress people that they would stop torturing and killing chickens, because people would then recognize their common capacities in chickens. The key is common capacities, not common species. (And I would argue that the relevant capacities are of the sort that most animals share, including the ability to suffer but not including the ability to engage in satyagraha.)

Funny Games said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Funny Games said...

Chickens are incapable of nonviolent direct action because of the limits of their particular cognitive capacties.LOL Elo Boost | FUT 14 Coins
That doesn't make them ineligible for moral concern, although you are right that many people think it does. (Chickens are eligible for moral concern as moral patients, in much the same way that human infants and severely disabled humans are.)

奇堡比 said...


奇堡比 said...


Coach Factory said...

canada goose outlet, canada goose outlet, moncler, ghd, gucci, cheap sunglasses, mcm handbags, bottega veneta, ugg boots, cheap oakley sunglasses, soccer jerseys, oakley sunglasses cheap, herve leger, soccer shoes, marc jacobs, moncler, canada goose, cheap oakley sunglasses, cheap oakley sunglasses, babyliss pro, insanity, oakley sunglasses cheap, moncler outlet, tn pas cher, oakley, cheap sunglasses, jimmy choo, oakley outlet, chi flat iron, valentino shoes, ugg, uggs on sale, moncler, ugg boots, p90x, oakley vault, canada goose, oakley sunglasses outlet, louboutin, asics, oakley outlet, canada goose, ralph lauren, canada goose, oakley sunglasses outlet, celine handbags, ugg boots, ray ban, oakley vault

Coach Factory said...

oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet online, prada outlet, coach factory, nike shoes, michael kors outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, ray ban, cheap michael kors, toms shoes, jordan shoes, tory burch outlet, ray ban sunglasses, longchamp handbags, true religion, true religion jeans, oakley sunglasses, coach outlet, kate spade handbags, longchamp handbags, michael kors handbags clearance, nike air max, michael kors outlet online, coach purses, nike air max, louboutin, true religion outlet, coach outlet store, polo ralph lauren outlet, nike free, air max, oakley sunglasses, air max, louboutin, michael kors, louis vuitton handbags, longchamp outlet, chanel handbags, tiffany and co, air jordan, gucci outlet, michael kors outlet online, michael kors, kate spade outlet, ray ban sunglasses, prada handbags, nike free, burberry outlet online

Kate Skye said...

Funding amount: automatically mean that costs as a loan, the existing credit score, repayment period, depend on payment.
It is important to the method of payment: a deposit is not very good, but it is necessary to be able to provide loans.
Consumer credit history can take advantage of these loans and automobile company bad credit prior to the events of the conditions, the amount of the loan for the improvement of its payment terms, will help to guide our consumers.
Application Process: Simply complete the online form and the loan is for you.
The duration of approval: these loans is to provide instant credit characteristics, and in most cases time is 2 hours.
A loan for the new car or 2 used cars: the use and new car loans can be applied for.
is designed to help consumers to take credit in simple steps. Wait for a very long time, with a loan is very difficult in a particular situation. This one point, there is a need to organize and express a point suitable for the budget of the Special Operations Group in a on a regular basis. The opinion of experts is a new increase in benefits, the best deal in any case.
If you read the headlines, or listen to political rhetoric inundates each and every one of us every day, you are in the United States or other parts of the middle class, all of these are issues that need to be addressed, you may think that a simple change of conviction, a new group, or have the responsibility.

amine lahragui said...

thanks so much for that great blog and thanks also for accepting my links thanks
طريقة عمل الدونات طريقة عمل البان كيك طريقة عمل الكنافة طريقة عمل البسبوسة طريقة عمل الكيك طريقة عمل عجينة البيتزا فوائد القرفه

Sara Richards said...

Now get away with all your worries and pay off all debts or customs may not be laying back as a burden, as a 6 month payday loans are easy solution that can help you to come out of the problem.

6 month payday loans
6 month loans
6 month loans for bad credit

maria lucia said...

short term 6 month loans  you may get the cash approved without any collateral. On the other side, there is no such need in unsecured loans but they are generally offered at slightly higher rate of interest. This is because of the risk the lender is bearing in granting you loan without any security.

6 Month Loans Bad Credit
instant loans for 6 months
6 month payday loans uk direct lenders

kim lawry said...

24 month loans for bad credit  are short term cash help and normally with a repayment term of about two to four weeks. These loans are planned to provide cash to assist you settle down your bills until your next payday.

36 month loans
60 month loans
72 month loans

aminos lahragui said...

thanks so much i like very so much your post
حلى الاوريو الفطر الهندي صور تورته حلى قهوه طريقة عمل السينابون طريقة عمل بلح الشام بيتزا هت كيكة الزبادي حلا سهل
صور كيك عجينة العشر دقائق

Addison Taylor said...

Loans for 12 months @ are best remedy for your monetary worries. It is not a tough task for a UK citizen to get these loans. Apply now.
For More Information: -
For More Information: -
Apply Here: -
loans for 6 months
6 month loans UK
6 month payday loans

holly milton said...

6 Month Loans a superb cash option that are offered to the applicant with poor credit ratings in order to accomplish their unforseen and uncalled expenses that come up in their without any prior notice in advance, Please visit

6 month payday loans
short term 6 month loans
6 month loans no credit check
12 month cash loans no credit check
Short Term Loans over 6 Months
payday loans for people on benefits
6 month loans bad credit

jacob landry said...

To sum up, loans for people with bad credit are easy and affordable loan schemes which give you comforts along with cash. Getting such timely monetary aids is the best way to meet all your sudden expenses without any hassle, Please visit

payday loans for homemakers
unsecured loans for people with bad credit
instant loans online
no credit check loans for unemployed people
unsecured business loans for people with bad credit
same day cash loans for people with bad credit

Moore Anderson said...

1000 pound till payday UK are the kind of developments that will make all your needs and demand come true with just one click of the button enters .

50 pound loans over 3 months
100 pound loans
150 pound payday loans
500 pound loans over 6 months
750 pound loans
1000 pound loans over 12 months
1500 pound installment loans
1000 pound till payday loans

Addison Taylor said...

Fast Cash Loans UK help individual in availing the fund that is 100 pound that will help the applicant in meeting their miniature needs that they are unable to do so due to the sacristy of funds in the mid of the month.

3 month payday loans uk
same day loans without debit card
payday loans no credit check no employment verification no faxing

karl simpsons said...

12 month loans no credit check is a quick source of cash without credit checks. You can repay the loan in installments easy in 12 months as per your convenience. You can borrow the money in the same day. Please visit

12 month direct lenders UK
1 year loans no credit check
1 year bad credit loans
12 month pay day loan
1000 pound loans
weekend loans

kim lawry said...

1 Month payday loans bad credit  in both secured and unsecured form of the loans. If you have bad credit score and looking for instant cash, cash is just a step away from you. For this, you need to fill out a simple application form. To fill the application form internet is the easiest medium of getting a bad credit same day cash loan.

48 month loans
cash loans for 2 months
best 3 month loans, immediate 3 month payday loans

Reuben Dean said...

Get the instant fiscal aid through six month loans lenders if you want to remove your financial conundrums with no trouble.

six month loans UK
6 month payday loans
6 month loans bad credit no brokers
500 pound loans over 6 months
6 month loans bad credit no credit check

sonya gupta said...

Messi Graff said...

Inside the contemporary moment funds loan providers are easily intended for pay for. undesirable credit financial loans in excess of 12 a few months Regardless of acquiring consequently critical personal problems we're acquiring so much convenience inside funds lending. 12 Month Loans You can take care of your current economical problems easily. dollars financial loans in excess of 12 a few months All fund connected work is finished easily once we will need quantity coming from these kinds of economical strategies.


brian massy said...

Is it accurate to say that you are greatly tired of remaining in long lines? Wouldn't you be able to bear the cost of it any longer? Would you like to change your things? Is it true that you are ready to have some cash keeping in mind the end goal to deal with your some dire requests that have entered your life? You can run with same day advances online that have been expected for you and you can without much of a stretch pursue the issues no sweat. Don't feel timid as it is the right arrangement to catch and you can enhance your circumstance consummately. Everybody can acquire cash without going anyplace as it is offered for every and everybody.

Kanika Jaiswal said...

Packers and Movers Kolkata @
Packers and Movers Delhi @
Packers and Movers Hyderabad @
Packers and Movers Bangalore @
Packers and Movers Chandigarh @

Kanika Jaiswal said...

Packers and Movers Noida @
Packers and Movers Pune @
Packers and Movers Gurgaon @
Packers and Movers Chennai @
Packers and Movers Mumbai @

David Jonatan said...

There are some people who like to go online to find secured personal loans providers. Dealing with online lenders is quite beneficial as it not only saves time and efforts but reduces the documentation required for loan. Other advantages include quick application processing and 24 hour availability. Online lenders even provide expert financial advices to people through their online services program. Pennsylvania home equity loans or mortgages, whether within the form of a second mortgage or secured line of credit, are secondary mortgages. That is, when a home is sold home equity loans will position after the first, or main, mortgage which is on the property, and will be paid out only after the primary mortgage has been settled. When a mortgage or loan ranks lower in priority, the cost to the customer in terms of the rate of interest will except in times of wildly fluctuating interest rates be larger.

David Jonatan said...

Guaranteed loans are grants Offered by financial institutions and lenders did is guaranteed practically, as the name implies, for people did extra cash need to make it through Before They payday arrives, Regardless of Their credit history. bad credit payday loans in this context, guarantee instant loanslenders will simply Means did approve applications as long as the borrower meets just a couple of straightforward prerequisites. This is in contrast with a typical loan or credit where borrowers undergo a tedious process and meet high standards form finance payday loans canada agencies Before They can be approved. The set standards can include but not be limited to employment and length of tenure, amount of income and most importantly one's credit history and record. Many of synthesis standards make it impossible for the poor credit people to apply and get approved for loans When They need it the most.

shashi kumar said...

sohan ku said...

Select the Top Packers and Movers in affordable Rates:
Pune Packers and Movers @
Bangalore Packers and Movers @
Gurgaon Packers and Movers @

sohan ku said...

Mumbai Packers and Movers or

Noida Packers and Movers or or

Delhi Packers and Movers or

shashi kumar said...

Packers and Movers in Hyderabad @
Packers and Movers in Bangalore @
Packers and Movers in Chennai @
Packers and Movers in Pune @
Packers and Movers in Mumbai @
Packers and Movers in Delhi @
Packers and Movers in Gurgaon @

shashi kumar said...

Packers and Movers in Hyderabad @
Packers and Movers in Bangalore @
Packers and Movers in Chennai @
Packers and Movers in Pune @
Packers and Movers in Mumbai @
Packers and Movers in Delhi @
Packers and Movers in Gurgaon @

sohan ku said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sohan ku said...

Packers and Movers Chennai
Packers and Movers Hyderabad
Packers and Movers Bangalore

Aruna Raj said...

Packers and Movers Bangalore or
Packers and Movers Delhi or
Packers and Movers Noida or
Packers and Movers Faridabad or
Packers and Movers Ghaziabad or

Aruna Raj said...

Packers and Movers Pune or
Packers and Movers Mumbai or
Packers and Movers Navi Mumbai or
Packers and Movers Thane or
Packers and Movers Gurgaon or

hari sh said...

Nice post.....I really appreciate your way of writing that make the post attractive and make reader to hold longer to your site. packers and movers marathahalli . packers and movers bangalore packers and movers hyderabad

Shiwani Saini said...

Packers and Movers Mumbai @
Packers and Mover Thane @
Packers and Movers Gurgaon @

arr harish said...

I LOVE all your post . packers and movers in marathahalli .