Monday, July 09, 2012

Public Access to Private Property

By Mike Dorf


Back in February, the Northwestern University Law Review hosted a discussion with William & Mary Law Professor Tim Zick and me on the topic, "Free Speech and the Public Square After Occupy Wall Street."  Because of recording glitches, the audio file was not posted but we were able to put together a transcript, which has now been posted here.  We discuss a number of topics, especially the following question: To what extent, if any, does the First Amendment, entitle protesters access to private property over the objections of the owners of that private property?  The answer, on which Professor Zick and I both agree, is: very little.

That's as a descriptive matter.  Both of us would like to see more robust protection for speech, even on private property, at least when the speech is consistent with the purposes to which the private property has been put to use.  In other words, we prefer the approach of some states, which interpret their state constitutional protections for free speech to permit at least some access to private property.  In the Pruneyard case, the U.S. Supreme Court held that the federal Constitution's protection for property rights permits such expansive free speech rights, but the Court's state action doctrine does not require access to private property as a free speech matter.

Why should it?  One part of the answer might be that giving free speech such a "horizontal" effect (i.e., making it apply against private actors and not just the government) would mitigate a seeming paradox of current free speech doctrine.  The paradox is this: If the government designates some publicly-owned space as a park or a street or a sidewalk, then that public property will be treated as a "public forum" in which the public have a right to free speech, subject only to reasonable content-neutral time, place and manner restrictions; but if the government sells title to the property to a private landowner, the public's free speech right can be completely extinguished.  A rule that says that for some free speech purposes it doesn't matter who owns the property--the government or private parties--would mean that the public maintain the same rights, regardless of the formal owners of the property.

To be sure, giving some horizontal effect to free speech rights does not eliminate all difficulties.  Suppose the government takes what was once a public park and turns it into a government office building.  Under the Court's doctrine, the public forum doctrine will no longer apply; instead, now the property will be deemed a non-public forum.  Under the First Amendment, you have a right to hold a rally in a public park; you can't hold a rally in the office building that replaces the public park.  And while the government needs only so many office buildings, we could imagine a government determined to stifle rallies selling public parks to private developers to replace them with private homes and office buildings, rather than private parks. Those private buildings would also be off limits.

Nonetheless, I think that people will demand some substantial public space.  A government can privatize streets, sidewalks and parks, but it cannot completely eliminate them.  I suspect that people under-value the expressive functions of open spaces--they want streets to drive on, sidewalks to walk on, and parks to play in, but once those spaces exist, the First Amendment opens them up to marches and rallies.  And--I am suggesting--that should be true regardless of who owns the streets, sidewalks and parks.

There will still be hard cases, to be sure.  Is Disneyland the sort of park in which the public should have a right to hold a rally?  Even if such a rally would be inconsistent with the image and feel that the Disney Corporation is trying to foster (and which most patrons go to Disneyland to experience)?  My tentative answer has two parts.

First, this problem is not limited to private spaces like Disneyland.  Under the Court's public forum doctrine, there are hard cases about whether free speech is consistent with the use to which the government has put public property.  The leading case involves a public airport and the result is quite messy.

Second, it seems to me that the answer to the question whether the First Amendment requires Disneyland or a government-owned version of Disneyland (such as a state fairgrounds) to be open to public protest should depend not only on the use to which the property has been put, but also on whether there are sufficient alternative public spaces for protest.  Thus, I would not rely entirely on political forces to open up space for speech.  If a community virtually eliminates public and private spaces suitable for protest activities, then I would want the First Amendment to be interpreted to open up the next-most-suitable sorts of spaces.


New York City is arguably a test case.  Occupy Wall Street ended up in a technically private space in part because, at the time, Zuccotti Park had no curfew, whereas the city's public parks did.  To the extent that the First Amendment should be interpreted to protect camping as a form of political protest (and I think that's a harder question than the Supreme Court allowed in the Clark case), perhaps the First Amendment should be interpreted either to provide an exception to the curfew in the government-owned parks or to grant a right to camp in the private ones.

17 comments:

Joe said...

Cases involving airports, transportation hubs, malls akin to public markets of yore etc. raise stronger claims than "Disneyland" does, particularly if there is a price to admission.

Dewaite Houwad said...

There will still be hard cases, to be sure. Is Disneyland the sort of park in which the public should have a right to hold a rally? Even if such a rally would be inconsistent with the image and feel that the Disney Corporation is trying to foster (and which most patrons go to Disneyland to experience)? My tentative answer has two parts.Windows 7 professional product Key
Windows 7 ultimate activation Key

Jet Li said...

The perfect!These articles written too great,they rich contents and data accurately.they are help to me.I expect to see your new share.
-----------------
Runescape Gold Cheap Diablo 3 Gold WOW Gold

Chogavl Hong said...

From the big different collars for dogs these days, it consists of as a very special dog collars and leashes a particular.

So if you're to convert him or her inside high end family dog gift ideas, below are two of the most beneficial options around collars for dogs:

1. Moist cloth collars for dogs

A selection might possibly be elementary however formidable leather material collars for dogs. These kind of training collars are really tough but not just as a result of synthetic leather subject mattersmall dog collars alone but more from the a strong sewing.

cartier said...


But I think a better example might be business "speech," at least business "speech" including publicly-traded organizations to http://www.mmomesos.com/. I may have inventory in Acme Nutrients, but Acme Nutrients doesn't ask my authorization before purchasing an anti-environment ad. But my cash is being used to persuade conversation I discover undesirable.

The apparent difference is that there's something different between having a job and getting a organization with http://www.warcraftonlines.com/sitemap.xml
. But should there be? From a realistic viewpoint, it might be more complicated to stop your job and perform somewhere else, but it isn't possible; does the difference have any actual CONSTITUTIONAL significance?

Elizabeth J. Neal said...

To what extent, if any, does the First Amendment, entitle protesters access to private property over the objections of the owners of that private property? The answer, on which Professor Zick and I both agree, is: very little. Property Management Solutions

Rvice Seds said...

Buy cheap wow gold at myjoxgold.com, the trusted name in virtual currency for over ten years. We guarantee delivery, every time.

Aion Online uses a currency called "aion kinah", this exciting MMO developed by NCSoft, is centered in the ancient world of Atreia where players can engage in PvPvE or Player vs Player vs Environment. Aion Online (or Aion: The Tower of Eternity in Korea) vividly illustrates the fascinating lore of Atreia, an incredible world thousands of years old, filled with excitement and adventure.

Yuan Sui said...

Play there will be better compensated but you will not be able to convert this improved quantity of jewelry to $ in the property place shut RMAH.We must assume some way of RMAH multiboxing is possible: You will no query want to stage more than one coaching. I know I found something to really like in each of the Diablo III sessions. http://www.fifacoinfast.com
Buy Diablo 3 Gold
Buy Guild Wars 2 Gold

aminos lahragui said...


Very awesome post , i am really impressed with it a lot


فوائد الزنجبيل
فوائد الرمان فوائد الحلبة فوائد البصل فوائد الزعتر فوائد زيت السمسم علاج البواسير فوائد اليانسون فوائد الكركم قصص جحا صور يوم الجمعه علامات الحمل تعريف الحب حياة البرزخ فوائد الزبيب

amine lahragui said...

thanks so much for that great blog and thanks also for accepting my links thanks
طريقة عمل الدونات طريقة عمل البان كيك طريقة عمل الكنافة طريقة عمل البسبوسة طريقة عمل الكيك طريقة عمل عجينة البيتزا فوائد القرفه

aminos lahragui said...



thanks so much i like very so much your post
حلى الاوريو الفطر الهندي صور تورته حلى قهوه طريقة عمل السينابون طريقة عمل بلح الشام بيتزا هت كيكة الزبادي حلا سهل صور كيك عجينة العشر دقائق

umar kk said...

Real estate for sale and rental properties throughout Australia. Includes agent search, auction results and real estate news. administra proprietatea Bucuresti

jowdjbrown said...

I don't know what mechanism Jess is using to enable this.condos in raleigh nc

obat herbal said...

cara menghilngkan nanah dari kemluan pengobatan nanah keluar dari ujung kemaluan obat nanah keluar dari kemaluanapa itu penyakit wasir

wasirdenature said...

kutil di sekitar kelamin dan obat kutil di sekitar kelamin dan obat kutil kelamin pria dan obat kutil kelamin resep dokter obat kutil kelamin tradisional dan pengobatan kutil di sekitar kelamin dan pengobatan kutil kelamin dan obat kutil kelamin pada pria herbal ampuh kutil kelamin merupakan solusi pengobatan herbal dari denature indonesia

herbal medicine said...

kutil di sekitar kelamin dan obat kutil di sekitar kelamin dan obat kutil kelamin pria dan obat kutil kelamin resep dokter obat kutil kelamin tradisional dan pengobatan kutil di sekitar kelamin dan pengobatan kutil kelamin dan obat kutil kelamin pada pria herbal ampuh kutil kelamin merupakan solusi pengobatan herbal dari denature indonesia

obat herbal said...

Obat kencing Nanah De Nature Obat Herbal obat Kutil Kelaminobat penyakit sipilis pada wanita penyakit sipilis pada lelaki penyakit sipilis pada wanita mengobati penyakit sipilis secara alami