Wednesday, May 21, 2014

Of Execution and Slaughter

by Sherry F. Colb

In my Verdict column for this week, I discuss the parallels between the concepts, respectively, of "humane execution" and "humane slaughter," in the wake of the botched execution of Clayton Lockett in Oklahoma last month.  In the column, I take up the question whether there is anything inherently paradoxical about the idea of "humane" killing and, if not, whether there is nonetheless tension inherent in executing a prisoner or slaughtering an animal in a purportedly "humane" way.  In this post, I want to discuss an important difference between the execution of prisoners and the slaughter of animals, a difference that has less to do with humaneness than with the underlying meaning of each practice and what meaning can teach us about the two practices.

Let me begin with a story.  When I was a law clerk for Justice Blackmun in the 1990's, I recall a debate that broke out over e-mail between a number of law clerks from the different chambers.  As I recall, the Justices were considering an application for a stay of execution from a petitioner who was challenging the particular method by which he was to be executed as cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment.  I do not believe that the challenge went anywhere at the time, but one of Justice O'Connor's clerks emailed all of us, marveling at the fact that we humanely kill dogs and cats at shelters all the time but seem unwilling or unable to extend the same mercy to an actual human being.

I was not a vegan yet at the time.  Indeed, other than loving dogs in general and my dog Scooter in particular, I had not remotely awakened to the contribution that my own daily consumption habits to the infliction of suffering and death on animals.  Yet I was nonetheless offended by what this law clerk had written about the purportedly "humane" killing of mere "animals" in shelters.  I should add here, before I say what my response to the email was, that I did not (and do not) support the death penalty.  Still, this is what I said (paraphrased, from memory):

"I agree that it is wrong to inflict pain on the condemned during an execution.  I am, however, offended by your suggestion that the condemned is necessarily entitled to a more humane death than the cats and dogs who die at animal shelters.  The condemned prisoner has been convicted beyond a reasonable doubt of murdering another human being and of doing so in a particularly cruel and sadistic fashion, a fashion which -- by the way (I was snarky back then) -- was far more lacking in humane considerations than anything that the State of Texas has planned for the petitioner.  By contrast, the dogs and cats who live in cages at animal shelters waiting to be killed have done nothing wrong and are utterly innocent creatures.  They deserve neither punishment nor death; they are dying only because no one wants to adopt them. I accordingly do not appreciate the implication in your email that there could no less deserving recipient of mercy than a mere "animal" in a shelter.

If I were to converse with the 26-year-old author of this email now, I would ask her why, given the position she takes on the killing of animals, she continues to consume the flesh and secretions of the sentient beings who are as innocent as dogs and cats and who die in far more gruesome ways at slaughterhouses, not because they are guilty of any wrongdoing, but because well-meaning people like [me at age 26] are largely oblivious of how their own demand for such products keeps the farms and slaughterhouses running.  I would encourage her to put her money where her mouth is and become vegan (and I would offer to support her in that process, as I have done for others in her shoes).

As a separate point, I think the exchange between the younger me and the other law clerk inadvertently highlights an important difference between execution and animal slaughter:  execution assumes about humans what animal slaughter denies about animals.  Executing someone for murder, in one sense, shows a profound respect for the human who is executed (and for humans more generally).  This may seem counter-intuitive, but we visit the death penalty upon a prisoner in recognition of the fact that he autonomously chose to act in a manner that made him deserving of death.  Indeed, some retributivists have argued that when an autonomous person kills another (without justification or excuse), then we owe it to that person to take his life.  To do otherwise would be to deny him the just consequences of his own choice.

One need not favor the death penalty, moreover, to understand that just punishment inherently recognizes the capacities of the person being punished to have done otherwise, to have chosen to do what is right.  By choosing to do what is wrong instead, this person selected his path, and that path rightly includes a reckoning, whether through capital punishment, imprisonment, shaming, or some other modality of penalty.

We see the truth of this observation in Supreme Court decisions that prohibit the execution of some classes of human individuals, in recognition of those individuals' lack of capacity.  People who are intellectually disabled, for example, may not be executed for their crimes, under Atkins v. Virginia,  because the Court regards them as categorically incapable of the sort of culpability that characterizes someone who can be deserving of the death penalty.  Similarly, a person who has become incompetent to be executed, in virtue of an inability to understand that he is being killed or why he is being killed, may not be executed either, as a matter of constitutional law, under Ford v. Wainwright.  Someone with these diminished capacities is not "qualified" for a penalty such as death, which requires a moral agent with a baseline level of cognitive functioning.  We do not, moreover, look at humans as a group to determine who may be executed for his crimes; we look very specifically at the individual who is to be killed and ask whether he in particular had (at the time of his crime) and has (now) what it takes.

Animal slaughter is very different.  The animals who are trucked to slaughterhouses to have their throats cut to satisfy the demand for flesh and other animal products are indisputably innocent of any wrongdoing.  They are innocent as individuals and as a group.  Indeed, their innocence is part of what people argue makes them appropriate for slaughter as "mere animals."  We do not look at the particular individuals (who number in the tens of billions) facing terror, pain, and death, and ask questions about what he or she is thinking or feeling relative to his or her fate.  On the contrary, we dismiss the individuality of animals and refer, as though to an undifferentiated substance, to "chicken," "beef," "pork," and "fish," rather than to chickens, cows, pigs, and fishes.  We do so in part because, we argue, these creatures purportedly lack some allegedly significant cognitive ability that would qualify them to be free of the indiscriminate violence they face at human hands. Unlike individual humans on trial for their lives, animals are classified by species DNA (as "not human") and accordingly dispatched instrumentally, for human consumption.

To say this differently, we circumscribe the death penalty -- in the United States -- and limit it to those individuals who are, among other things, (1) guilty of a heinous crime, (2) capable of understanding what is happening to them and why, and (3) capable, as a chronological and developmental matter, of intellectual performance that exceeds that of the population of humans who are intellectually disabled.  Thus, despite the moral difficulties that many of us (including me) have with the death penalty, it does make an effort to attend to a person's individuality and capacity in a way that shows respect for autonomy, life, and the abilities that typify "normal" humans who make the choice to do the wrong thing.  By contrast, we allow ourselves the "liberty" to slaughter all manner of living beings who think, who suffer, and bond with one another, and who experience fear just as we do, precisely because they lack the sorts of abilities that are a prerequisite to eligibility for the death penalty among humans.

This difference tells us something about an inconsistency in our thinking about "capacities."  When it comes to humans, a diminished capacity leads us to grant mercy and care, as a matter of law and -- for many of us -- as a matter of how we interact with people in the world.  We rightly regard as bullies those people who mock or otherwise inflict suffering on those humans among us who are intellectually disabled or otherwise lack some of the capacities that supposedly "raise" our species above all others in the world.  But when asked why we permit ourselves to cause great suffering and harm to animals, we say it is because "they" lack some special trait that distinguishes "us" from "them," a trait that is typically identified with our ability to use language (which many humans lack), our ability to make a life plan (which many humans lack), or some similar (and similarly irrelevant) capacity that those lucky among us have (for at least part of our lives).  Our mercy seems, in other words, to go in precisely opposite directions, depending on whether we are dealing with homo sapiens (where incapacity and vulnerability trigger mercy) or with our earthling relatives of other species (where incapacity and vulnerability trigger contempt, exploitation, and moral demotion)..

I believe we can learn something important from the moral growth that we have undergone when it comes to our thinking about the death penalty.  We correctly understand that rather than justifying cruelty and bullying, a human's lack of capacities rightly entitles that human to care and compassion and to freedom from violence and bullying.  We must come to understand that the same is true for the other animals.  I do not believe that other animals are "dumb," but to the extent that they lack some the abilities that have given humans power to decide their (and our own) fate, this vulnerability should lead us to grant them mercy and freedom from the extreme violence that is so pervasive in the form of cheeseburgers, fish patties, egg omelettes, and dairy yogurt.

Another point I would make on the issue of executions is that a major component of why many people have come to oppose the death penalty is the fact that people who are sentenced to death and executed are generally not, in fact, blessed with the same capacities and privileges that the rest of the population enjoys. Typically, such people have grown up with severe disadvantages, have often been abused themselves in violent environments, and are vulnerable in a variety of other ways.  In other words, the sort of autonomy that grounds our willingness to execute a person for his crime may often be lacking in the people who find themselves on death row, not because they are necessarily intellectually disabled (although quite a few are, and fights abound about who gets to "qualify" as intellectually disabled under Atkins) but because they may suffer from mental disorders (as a disproportionate number of prisoners generally do, relative to the rest of the population) short of insanity and of incapacity to be executed and may, on the whole, fall short of the image of the person who has freely chosen to commit a vicious crime on which a just system of punishment is based.

Some opponents of the death penalty have also documented and cited the racial disparities in sentencing that infect the death penalty and suggest that rather than showing respect for autonomous decisions-making, the death penalty may instantiate the sort of violence that once typified slavery and the post-civil-war era of lynchings:  violence against vulnerable and defenseless individuals who never really had a chance.  Whether one accepts this characterization of the criminal justice system or the death penalty, though, it is clear that what drives many objections to executions has a lot to do with the vulnerability of the death row population and the consequent unfairness of targeting such individuals for violence.  This objection can be made as effectively against the wholesale captivity, breeding, and slaughter that service consumer demand for animal products taken from innocent, vulnerable, and doomed domesticated animals.






34 comments:

David Ricardo said...

Much of the commentary on this subject is well reasoned but dispassionate. Almost all of the rest is passionate but poorly written and lacking well reasoned arguments. This post is a rare combination of both the passionate and the well said. That it does so as succinctly that it does speaks volumes.

Michael C. Dorf said...

DR: Thanks much for your comment. Let me suggest that most of the commentary on VIRTUALLY EVERY SUBJECT is passionate but poorly reasoned! We here at DoL do our best to combine passion with reason (and occasionally humor).

Joe said...

I do appreciate the eloquent discussion though respectfully continue to disagree in part as to the strategic value of shall we say somewhat less inhumane slaughter while the consumption of animals will occur for quite some time.

Part of it is somewhat related to the discussion here -- once we do that, we are resting on a principle of some due care for fellow animals which stops at an artificial point. And, people will notice that and press for more.

This tends to be the practice when dealing with evils, even if in the short term tempering the evil might make some feel the practice now is bearable (we saw this with slavery, e.g.).

BTW, you are allowed a bit of snark now too.

Michael C. Dorf said...

Three further thoughts:

1) Before I posted my comment above in response to DR's comment, I misread his comment as a critique and hastily posted a (snarky) reply. I then re-read DR's comment and realized my mistake and so deleted the reply. If you saw the initial reply, please ignore. Apologies!

2) Joe's point is a fair one. Sherry and I have a chapter in our forthcoming book on abortion and animal rights (still in the works) in which we acknowledge that the question of whether laws regulating slaughter and treatment of animals move matters in the right direction is an empirical question, albeit one that is difficult to answer. The studies that are sometimes cited on this point all turn out to have very serious limitations.

3) Sherry's point that the law evaluates humans slated for execution individually was underscored by Justice Alito's grant yesterday of a stay of execution for a Missouri man whose petition argued that his particular medical condition would make him especially susceptible to suffering from a lethal injection. Of course, it's possible that the full Court will vacate the stay upon further consideration, but even this much attention to his individual circumstances is noteworthy.

barcrunchsub said...

I’m wondering how well-meaning people could be largely oblivious of how their own demand for meat keeps the farms and slaughterhouses running. A chicken sandwich necessarily requires a dead chicken, surely everyone knows this. It seems to me that they have decided that the satiating their taste buds for a few minutes is worth more than the life of a chicken. As long as people continue to believe that, they will kill chickens (or pigs or cows) for that purpose.

David Ricardo said...

What we had here was a failure (on my part) to communicate. Apologies if anyone, particularly Ms Colb or Mr. Dorf interpreted my initial post as something other than highly complimentary.

I have on previous occasions in posts on DoL listed my real name in a post for the very reason that Mr. Dorf states. Having no qualms about taking good ideas from others I use the name of a prominent (and dead, so no copyright issues) economist in the tradition of columnists in The Economist.

Michael C. Dorf said...

DR: Again, there was nothing wrong with your comment. I was somehow primed to see it negatively, so that was entirely my error.

Sam Rickless said...

Passionate and always thought-provoking, in the best way. I have just a few reactions.

1. I find it interesting that one primary intellectual source of the presumed authority to kill and eat animals is the theological idea of God's have given human beings dominion over the rest of the animal kingdom. This idea is quite prominent, e.g., in Locke's Second Treatise, and I am sure the thought can be found all over the place in religious texts. Particularly interesting is how this is all supposed to fit with, say, Christianity's emphasis on love and mercy. (Blessed are the meek, and all that.) I am not a Christian, and so do not need to struggle with this, but I sometimes wonder what form of rationalization Christian carnivores must engage in in order to avoid blatant incoherence.

2. It's not clear that punishment recognizes the capacity of the punishee to have done otherwise. Perhaps the punishee could not have done otherwise, because there was an evil neuroscientist waiting to make him do as he did if he showed any signs of not doing as he did. This is the message of the large secondary literature (in philosophy) on Frankfurt-type counterexamples to the principle of alternate possibilities.

3. It's not always true, I think, nor should it be, that diminished capacity in humans leads us to grant mercy and care, as well as freedom from violence. Arguably psychopaths have diminished capacities relevant to whether they have what it takes to be deserving of punishment for their heinous crimes. But mercy, care, and freedom from violence seem completely out of place here, just as it seems out of place to be merciful towards the hungry tiger who is about to eat a human baby. What this brings up is a slightly different version of the principle you are trying for, one that takes account, not only of diminished capacities, but also lack of dangerousness.

Michael C. Dorf said...

A propos of Sam's point 3, I think it's useful to distinguish between justified self-defense or defense of others on the one hand, and punishment on the other. Even as a vegan, I have no problem in killing the tiger to save the baby if there's no equally effective method of saving the baby, but that's not because the tiger is blameworthy; it's because the tiger poses a deadly threat to the baby. I could also kill an attacker who is sleepwalking and is dreaming that the baby is a tiger that he needs to kill to save himself (assuming that I can't wake up the sleepwalker); the sleepwalker, like the actual tiger, is blameless, but nonetheless I can use lethal force to defend against him. And since I can use deadly force even against a blameless attacker, I can also use deadly force against a blameworthy attacker. So, it doesn't matter whether a psycopath is blameless or blameworthy in the case of the current threat.

But suppose that I manage to foil an attack without deadly force. If the attacker was a sleepwalker, punishment would be wholly inappropriate. If the attacker suffered from SOME mental illnesses or diminished capacities, punishment would be inappopriate (although civil detention in a mental hospital might be appropriate). If the attacker was just a regular person who chose to do evil, then punishment would be appropriate.

So the question is whether psychopathy is more like other mental illnesses that vitiate guilt or more like just being a bad person who chooses to do evil. To my mind, that question is partly empirical: what is psychopathy exactly? But it is also partly normative: To what extent do we want to hold people accountable for dispositions that themselves are ultimately not chosen, given that all behavior is ultimately caused?

Joe said...

The special nature of the case cited (guy with special blood disorder making lethal injection particularly troublesome) should not be taken to mean too much.

By chance, I found a citation to this:

http://writ.news.findlaw.com/colb/20001122.html

Finally, the subject here is being discussed in a somewhat academic fashion -- also the style of Prof. Colb's book, but I'm sure the people involved have a passion for the cause too.

It came to mind that for many vegans, eating animals & what is done to get them to one's plate must be utterly disgusting to contemplate. Something the regular person enjoys is more on the level of (to allude to one thought experiment) eating a dog.

Or worse. Ironically, it might be comparable to how some see same sex conduct. So, I understand when some passion is expressed.

Berita Terkini said...

obat pembesar penis
obat kuat

Evin Terna said...

products keeps the farms and slaughterhouses running. I would encourage her to put her money where her mouth is and become vegan (and I would offer to support her in that process, as I have done for others in her shoes).fut 14 coins | fifa 14 coins for sale | Elder Scrolls Online Gold |buy fifa 14 coins

lee woo said...

Education without values, as useful as it is, seems rather to make man a more clever devil. See the link below for more info.

#clever
www.mocsbar.com

Evin Terna said...

It is that they are nonexistent. There just *is* no premise of the 'round square' variety from which to derive any interesting logical consequence, let alone any illuminating such consequence, and Palley's point is that US Cambridge 'capital' is of this vareity. Krugman must accordingly either explicitly question the applicability of the 'round square' analogy or recognize that he hasn't yet answered Palley. FIFA COINS

喜洋洋 said...

監聽器材
離婚諮詢
監聽手機
財產調查
電話監聽
網路詐欺
女人偷腥
肉體外遇
商業調查
信用調查
婚姻諮商
婚姻問題
老婆外遇
外遇處理
筆跡鑑定
挽回婚姻
老公偷腥
男人外遇
丈夫外遇
婚姻諮詢
感情諮詢
挽回感情
老婆偷腥
工商徵信
商標侵權
市場調查

Cicy said...

it does make an effort to attend to a person's individuality and capacity in a way that shows respect for autonomy, life, and the abilities that typify "normal" humans who make the choice to do the wrong thing. By contrast, we allow ourselves the "liberty" to slaughter all manner of living beings who think, who suffer, and bond with one another, and who experience fear just as we do, precisely because they lack the sorts of abilities that are a prerequisite to eligibility for the death penalty among humans.League of Legends Boosting
WildStar Platinum
lol代练

奇堡比 said...

新女性徵信
外遇調查站
鴻海徵信
亞洲徵信
非凡徵信社
鳳凰徵信社
中華新女性徵信社
全國新女性徵信社
全省女人徵信有限公司
私家偵探超優網
女人感情會館-婚姻感情挽回徵信
女子偵探徵信網
女子國際徵信
外遇抓姦偵探社
女子徵信社
女人國際徵信
女子徵信社
台中縣徵信商業同業公會
成功科技器材
女人國際徵信社
女人國際徵信
三立徵信社-外遇
女人國際徵信
女人國際徵信
大同女人徵信聯盟
晚晴徵信

喜洋洋 said...

高雄縣徵信商業同業公會
南部徵信聯盟
外遇觀測站
大愛離婚諮詢網
離婚大剖析
大愛徵信有限公司
尋人專家徵信服務網
女人徵信公司
華陀徵信
離婚協助中心
跟蹤蒐證徵信器材網
抓姦觀測
大愛徵信
溫馨徵信
成功徵信社

forrest codilla said...

great post! very helpful. keep it up!

www.triciajoy.com

Bondan Domino Putra said...

Produk Best Seller Unggulan " Cafe Pembesar Penis "

?. Obat Pembesar Penis
~ Vimax
~ Neosize XL
~ VigRX Plus

?. Alat Pembesar Penis
~ ProExtender

?. Oil Pembesar Penis
~ Cobra Oil
~ VigRX Oil
~ Vimax Oil
~ Arabian Oil

?. Obat Pelansing Badan
~ Fruit Plant

?. Obat Kuat Pria
?. Pemen Perangsang Wanita
?. Obat Penyubur Sperma
?. Obat Peninggi Badan
?. Alat Bantu Sex Wanita
?. Alat Bantu Sex Pria
?. Vakum Pembesar Payudara
?. Obat Penggemuk Badan
?. Obat Pemutih Badan

Kunjungi Web Kami :
www.CafePembesarPenis.com ?
www.RoomPembesarPenis.wordpress.com ?

Warta Joko said...

Jual Obat Kutil Kelamin Wanita
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Ampuh
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tanpa Operasi

Galeri Cassanova said...

Very good post! We are linking to this particularly great content on our website, Keep up the good writing.
# cara mengatasi ejakulasi dini
# obat pelangsing badan
# cara alami memperbesar alat vital pria
# obat peninggi badan
# cara membesarkan payudara
# jual obat bius wanita
# vimax asli
# obat perangsang alami
# minyak lintah papua
# obat pembesar penis
# cara membesarkan alat vitalff

Tina Mulya said...

Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat kutil Kelamin Ampuh
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tanpa Operasi
Obat kutil kelamin untuk pria
Obat kutil kelamin untuk wanita
Cara mengatasi kutil kelamin
Cara mengobati kutil kelamin
Cara menyembuhkan kutil kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Ampuh
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tanpa Operasi
Obat kutil kelamin untuk pria
Obat kutil kelamin untuk wanita
Cara mengatasi kutil kelamin
Cara mengobati kutil kelamin
Cara menyembuhkan kutil kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Ampuh
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tanpa Operasi
Obat kutil kelamin untuk pria
Obat kutil kelamin untuk wanita
Cara mengatasi kutil kelamin
Cara mengobati kutil kelamin
Cara menyembuhkan kutil kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Ampuh
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tanpa Operasi
Cara Mengobati Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Untuk Wanita
Obat Kutil Kelamin Untuk Pria
Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Kelamin
Cara Mengatasi Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin
Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria

Tina Mulya said...

Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Penyebab Sipilis
Cara Mengobati Sipilis
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Wasir Ampuh
Obat Wasir Herbal
Obat Sipilis Tradisional
Obat Sipilis Pada Pria
Obat Kanker Payudara
Obat Sipilis Raja Singa
Obat Wasir Luar
Obat Penyakit Kutil Kelamin
Obat Sipilis
Ciri Penyakit Sipilis
Tanda - Tanda Penyakit Sipilis
Obat Kutil Kelamin Pria
Obat Kutil Kelamin Wanita
Jual Obat Wasir atau Ambeien Pada Pria Dan Wanita
Obat Ambeien
Obat Kencing Nanah
Gejala Penyakit Sipilis
Penyakit Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Alami
Obat Kutil Kelamin Herbal
Pengobatan Kutil Kelamin
Cara Mengobati Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kencing Nanah
Obat Gonore
Obat Raja Singa Ampuh

Tina Mulya said...

Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin
Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin
Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?

Tina Mulya said...

Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin
Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita

Tina Mulya said...

Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin
Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin

Tina Mulya said...

Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin
Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar

Tina Mulya said...

Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
Obat Kutil Kelamin Tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Obat Penyakit kutil Kelamin Wanita (sudah di komen)
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
obat kutil kelamin tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin
Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Obat Penyakit kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin

Tina Mulya said...

Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
obat kutil kelamin tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin
Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Obat Penyakit kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
obat kutil kelamin tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina Dan Definisi Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya

Tina Mulya said...

Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
obat kutil kelamin tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin
Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Obat Penyakit kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin

Tina Mulya said...

Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
Obat Penyakit kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
obat kutil kelamin tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin

Tina Mulya said...

Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek
Obat Penyakit kutil Kelamin Wanita
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Ibu Hamil
Cara Menghilangkan kutil Di Kelamin Pria
Di Sekitar Penis Tumbuh Kutil ? Obatnya Apa ?
Berbahayakah Kutil Kelamin
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata
Obat Kutil di Batang Zakar
Obat Kutil Di Kemaluan Wanita | Penyakit Kelamin Wanita
Obat Penghilang Kutil Kelamin
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Vagina
obat jengger ayam untuk wanita
Kutil Di Alat Kelamin Serta Cara Menghilangkanya
obat kutil kelamin tradisional
Obat Kutil Pada Memek | Cara Menyembuhkan Kutil Pada Kemaluan Wanita
Penyembuhan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina | Penyakit Kelamin Kutil
Penyebab Kutil Kelamin dan Cara Penyembuhanya
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Di Bibir Memek
Cara Menghilangkan Kutil Di Kemaluan | Vagina, Anus, Atau Penis Tumbuh Kutil
Obat Menghilangkan Kutil Di Bibir Vagina
Tumbuh Kutil di Penis Dan Anus | Obat Herbal Penyakit Kelamin
Kenapa Ada Kutil Di bibir Vagina ? Cara mengobatinya Bagaimana?
Tanda-Tanda Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria | PENYAKIT KELAMIN JENGGER AYAM
Kutil Kelamin Condyloma Acuminata Pada Bibir Memek

Cindy Dy said...


This is a great website. I will make sure that I stop back again!.

Sherly
www.gofastek.com