Posts

Same-Sex Marriage, Abortion Rights, and Too-Much-Too-Soon Litigation

by Neil H. Buchanan Over the weekend, I attended the annual meeting of the Association of American Law Schools (AALS), where my GW Law colleague Joan Schaffner chaired the Section on Animal Law's panel, "Animal Rights: From Why to How."  Among the six panelists were Dorf on Law 's own Sherry Colb and Michael Dorf.  It was an interesting and lively session, in large part focused on strategic questions of advancing the cause of animal rights in the legal, legislative, and public spheres. Professor Dorf began his remarks by commenting on the question of timing.  Noting that people involved in the gay civil rights movement had spent years obsessing over the question of when it would be wise (or even safe) to bring a high-impact case challenging prohibitions on gay marriage, he concluded that such strategizing is often pointless, because the courts are (relatively) open to the public at large, which means that the best-laid small-c conservative strategies can be ignor...

Chief Justice Roberts and the Legal Profession

By Michael Dorf In a  post  last week, I noted how the end-of-year report by Chief Justice Roberts characterized what were largely minor wording changes in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure as authorizing federal district judges to play a more aggressive role in supervising--and importantly, in limiting--discovery in civil cases. Here I want to focus on the tone of the Chief's report and what it says about his conception of the legal profession. In the report, the Chief is, as always, a powerful polemicist, especially because he seems so reasonable that it is easy to miss just how polemical he is being. If Justice Scalia is the Donald Trump of the Court's right wing (always in your face), Chief Justice Roberts is its Ben Carson (lulling you to sleep). The Chief begins his report by condemning dueling. Why? It appears that dueling is used to show the importance of an effective system of civil justice so that people do not resort to violence to resolve their grieva...

Big Government Fantasies of Conservative Economists

by Neil H. Buchanan Do academics have pre-existing ideological policy agendas to which they fit their arguments, or do they follow logic wherever it leads and adopt whatever policy positions are warranted by evidence and reasoning?  If one believes, as I do, that academic writing ultimately has a profound impact on public policy, the answer to this question is rather important. My impression throughout my academic career has been that my fellow professors are, in the main, honestly following the trail of evidentiary and theoretical crumbs to determine the best answers to the questions at hand.  This is why I have never been particularly surprised or worried about the unbalanced party affiliations of professors.  On his blog earlier this week , Paul Krugman runs through the numbers and makes some important observations about the right's claims of left-wing bias in the academy.  Among other things, he notes in particular that the hard-science people are actually m...

Fired Up About Toys

by Lisa McElroy Last fall, I joined a camping group of about 6000 women who live across the country.  The members meet up at campgrounds and in state parks; they hike and glamp.  Most of them work in the service industry, if they work outside the home.  Many are devoutly Christian. And lots and lots of them are members of the NRA. As in, they have NRA stickers on and gun racks in their trucks. When I first got involved with this group, I was struck by how different these women were from me, but I saw that as a good thing.  After all, as Justice Thomas told me recently, “There’s nothing more democratic than camping.”  And I still believe that difference is a really good thing – it was important to me to break out of my ivory tower, in which all of my friends had gone to graduate school and most parents abandoned traditional gender roles.  Meeting people from different walks of life was enriching and educational – not to mention just plain fun (these ...

Unfairness in Public Restrooms

by Sherry F. Colb In my Verdict column this week , I discuss Donald Trump's remarks about Hillary Clinton's use of the restroom during the latest Democratic debate.  While seemingly a bizarre outlier, I suggest in my column that Trump's thinking may be shared by other men and may help explain the existence of sex-segregated restrooms.  In this post, I want to respond to an argument that people sometimes make in defense of sex segregation.  The more typical arguments have to do with safety and privacy, and I address those in my column.  A third argument I have heard is one about fairness. Men who have used public restrooms have certainly noticed that women take much longer than men do, as a general matter.   Some men have accordingly come to view a shorter wait for the restroom as something to which they are entitled.  They may see  men as a group very much like the group of people purchasing "10 items or fewer" at the grocery store, entitled to end...

The Oregon Standoff and Strategies to Fight Politically Inspired Violence

by Neil H. Buchanan The new year brought with it a strange new criminal/political event, in the form of an anti-government group's armed takeover of a building at a National Wildlife Refuge in a remote part of Oregon.  It turns out that the leader of the group is a son of the rancher who came to fame some time ago for threatening violence against federal agents, threats that were prompted by the federal government's efforts to enforce grazing laws that the rancher had been violating for more than two decades.  (Professor Dorf wrote an interesting post about that situation in April of 2014.) The details about this new standoff are interesting, in a perverse way, and they tell us a lot about the sense of grievance that has been incubating for a long time among certain fringe elements on the right.  My purpose here, however, is not to discuss the legal merits of the Oregon situation (which are obviously quite one-sided), but instead to put this new standoff in the conte...

Chief Justice Roberts Takes a Fourth Bite at the Apple

By Michael Dorf The Chief Justice's Year-End Report on the Federal Judiciary was released at 6 p.m. on New Year's Eve, perhaps in the hope that it would be ignored. It wasn't. An article by Adam Liptak in The New York Times quotes various civil procedure scholars who are critical of the very developments that Chief Justice Roberts praises in his report. In a follow-up post at the end of the week, I'll say something about the view of the legal profession expressed in the Chief's report. Here I want to reflect on the misdirection in the report. The Chief devotes nearly all of his report to praising the recently adopted amendments to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure , which went into effect on December 1. According to the Chief's report, the amendments--and especially language in Rule 26 that limits discovery to matters that are "proportional" to the asserted claims and defenses--place a new common-sense limit on discovery run amok. Indeed, the ...

Happy New Year!

by Neil H. Buchanan It's hard to believe that this is the tenth New Year's Eve since Dorf on Law came into existence.  We wish our readers the best of the new year.  We will be back to our regular publication schedule next week.

Androids and Animals

by Michael Dorf My latest Verdict column is titled Do Androids Dream of Animal Rights? .  I usually write a blog post to go with each column, but it's practically New Year's Eve, so I'll simply invite readers to check out the column and post any comments either on Verdict or here. Happy New Year

It's Serious, Important, and Interesting, But It's Still Funny

by Neil H. Buchanan The big political story of 2015 was the unexpected emergence -- and even more unexpected staying power -- of Donald Trump as a presidential candidate.  For most of the summer and early autumn, I chose to write nothing about his candidacy, in part because the absurdity of it all made serious commentary seem pointless, while sarcastic commentary would have been redundant.  As the story grew, however, it became all but impossible not to say something about the emptiness of Trump's assertions, the lack of any details in the few policy positions that he announced, the ugliness of his rhetoric, and so on. As the year ended, I used three Dorf on Law posts ( here , here , and here ), as well as my most recent Verdict column , to assess an emerging discussion among politicians and pundits about whether Trump could destroy the Republican party in 2016 (and perhaps permanently).  In those pieces, I did not actually discuss Trump's assertions in any detail, ...