Saturday, June 25, 2011

Some Implications of NY's New Same-Sex Marriage Law

By Mike Dorf


Herewith, a few reactions to the passage last night of the Marriage Equality Bill:

1) Hooray! A great day for the Empire State.

2) Andrew Cuomo is now the front-runner for the Democratic Presidential nomination in 2016.  He already has fiscal conservative street cred. By 2016, the economy will have turned around and he can take credit for that. He spent political capital on the same-sex marriage issue and won, with some crucial Republican support.

3) The actions of the NY Republican Party during this debate were fascinating. The Republican leadership and the vast majority of Republican members of the NY legislature opposed legalizing same-sex marriage but nonetheless did not use their procedural leverage to block a vote.  Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos deserves considerable credit for honoring his earlier commitment to bring the issue to the floor and for making this a "conscience vote" rather than insisting on party discipline.  I think there is a broader lesson there, because I don't believe that successful politicians of any party ever make important decisions like this without an eye on the political consequences. Here, it seems to me, Skelos was able to read the writing on the wall. He can see the generational divide on this issue and knows that in the long run there is just no angle in having his party seen as bigoted.  Political opinion is regional as well as generational, of course, so it will take some time to spread around the country, but eventually this issue will disappear from politics.

4) What will replace it? Ever since Nixon's "Southern strategy," the Republican Party has been very good at finding and exploiting social "wedge" issues.  First race. Then abortion. Then gay rights. Opposition to gay rights will soon (10 years?) be a non-starter, and unlike race, there will not be readily available ways to use the issue in a coded way. That's because on average, gay and lesbian Americans do just fine economically, so it won't be possible to favor formal equality while opposing programs that benefit the minority at issue--as conservatives have been able to do with respect to affirmative action and other matters that implicate racial politics.  They will continue to use race as a wedge issue, although its potency also diminishes over time, as America becomes less white.  (People like to talk about how white the typical Tea Party rally is, but the more important fact is how old).  Abortion will also remain a potent wedge issue.  Beyond that, as opposition to gay rights comes to be more of a liability than a valuable wedge issue, I would look to see the number 3 spot on the wedge issue hit parade increasingly filled with non-issues blown up to look like issues.  Examples in the relatively recent past include flag-burning; the "war on Christmas"; and various forms of personal attack (e.g., Kerry faked his war record; Obama was  "palin' around with terrorists;" etc).

5) Tomorrow I'll post a follow-up on the significance of the ways in which the marriage bill was amended before being enacted.

6) Did I say hooray?

10 comments:

Steve S said...

Mike, I doubt Cuomo is the favorite for the Democratic nomination. Indeed, I doubt a pro life Catholic will get the Democratic Presidential nomination for many decades.

Steve S said...

Oops, I meant pro choice

Michael C. Dorf said...

Steve S,

I could see your disagreeing about Cuomo. Perhaps Hillary Clinton is the front-runner. But your broader point baffles me.

Why couldn't a pro-Choice Catholic get the Presidential nomination? Every Democratic Presidential nominee after Jimmy Carter was pro-choice, and while none of them were Catholic, the Catholic barrier was broken over 50 years ago. Michael Dukakis was a pro-choice Greek Orthodox candidate. The Democratic Party nominated pro-choice Catholic Vice-Presidential candidates in Geraldine Ferraro and Joe Biden, as well as a pro-choice Jewish Vice-Presidential candidate in Joe Lieberman.

The Church doesn't like pro-choice Catholic candidates but that doesn't seem to matter with Catholic voters. E.g., Cuomo trounced pro-life Catholic Republican Carl Paladino among NY Catholic voters (and every other demographic group except perhaps rageaholics).

Neil H. Buchanan said...

I know that we tend to forget about John Kerry once having been the nominee, but he is Catholic.

michael a. livingston said...

The problem is this is a static analysis. Gay rights now is something like civil right in about 1964 or so: it still looks like people simply wanting to be treated "the same" as everyone else and so a plurality if not a majority are sympathetic. But it will rapidly proceed to the right to be "different" as well as an attempt to force itself on more conservative parts of the country where the popular sentiment if much more hostile. It will certainly not help the Democrats, and there is a very good chance it will hurt them.

Steve S said...

It is precisely the Kerry campaign that prompts my comment. The Kerry campaign was plagued by the Bishops. Non-Catholics do not get the same fire from them, and though many Catholics ignore the Bishops, the Bishops are still powerful. Bob Shrum, who wrote speeches for Kerry and otherwise played a leadership role in the campaign, also commented in his book No Excuses that pro-choice Catholics bring a kind of baggage that would foreclose a nomination.

Bill Walton said...

What place? Since NixonsSouthern strategy,the Republican Party has been very good to find and exploit the social wedge issues. The first contest. Then abortion. Then gay rights. The opposition to gay rights in the shortest time (10 years?) To be doomed to failure, and, unlike race, is not readily available ways to use the question-coded way.WOW Items WOW Gear eden gold buy eden gold cheap eden gold

chengnuo said...

My job is definitely secure. No one else wants it.

Merchanting in Runescape is the popular making method. merchanting is mostly a complex and multi-faceted enigma. You can apply the rules of merchanting in the WOW Gold
exchange.

Two tu said...

As an advocate of gay civil rights, I view all of this as good news. Naturally, I view the possibility of legislation legalizing gay marriage in New York as bigger news. cambridge satchel|cambridge satchels|cambridge satchel bag|the cambridge satchel|cambridge leather satchel|cambridge satchel company bag|satchel cambridge|cambridge satchel|cambridge satchels|cambridge satchel bag|the cambridge satchel|cambridge leather satchel|cambridge satchel company bag|satchel cambridge|

aminos lahragui said...




Very awesome post , i am really impressed with it a lot

فوائد الزنجبيل

فوائد الرمان

فوائد الحلبة

فوائد البصل

فوائد الزعتر

فوائد زيت السمسم

علاج البواسير

فوائد اليانسون

فوائد الكركم

قصص جحا

صور يوم الجمعه

علامات الحمل

تعريف الحب

حياة البرزخ

فوائد الزبيب